Welcome to the new Independent website. We hope you enjoy it and we value your feedback. Please contact us here.


Letter: Out of step with EU

Sir: I read with concern the claim made in Gordon Brown's document to the European Commission that the traditional differences between the British economy and those of its EU partners "are becoming less distinct over time" ("Brown spells out plans to join euro", 13 January). The evidence for this is patchy, and where such "convergence" may be happening it is still wholly inadequate for the UK to accommodate the "one size fits all" monetary policy that comes with the single currency.

Even on the quite inadequate criteria of inflation rates and interest rates we have not converged.

Of course, inflation rates are falling towards EU levels but they are still higher. And, of course, UK interest rates have fallen, but at 6 per cent they are still well above Euroland's and any precipitate fall towards 3 per cent would surely trigger inflation in the labour and housing markets.

But these criteria do not get to the heart of real cyclical convergence.

On any measure of capacity utilisation (whether it is, for example, unemployment for pressures in the labour market or a more general "output gap" measure) Britain shows no signs of moving into line with the core European economies.

Our business cycle is stubbornly transatlantic rather than continental.

There remain fundamental structural differences (for example, more divergent trade patterns and a greater sensitivity to changes in short-term interest rates) which - even if we were ever to get into "sync" with core Europe - would effectively torpedo any hopes of sustained cyclical convergence.


Head of Policy Unit

Institute of Directors

London SW1