A Syrian Love Story - Storyville, BBC4 - TV review: One of the joys of this film was the way it refused easy judgments

Amer and Raghda fought a dictator. Now they're at war with each other

Click to follow
The Independent Culture

It's all too easy to view stories of war and devastation as things that happen in some other less fortunate land, a place we read about over our breakfasts from the warm safety of our homes. Sean McAllister's assured, intimate and ultimately devastating documentary exposed the comforting lie at that heart of that belief, peeling back the layers of one marriage to tell a universal story of love, loss and the pain of exile.

Filmed over five years, McAllister's film focused on Amer Daoud and Raghda Hasan, who first met when both were imprisoned in a Syrian jail. Communicating through a hole in the wall of their adjoining cells they fell in love, married and had children. By the time McAllister met them Raghda had been imprisoned again for writing a book attacking President Bashar al-Assad's brutal regime.

"She's a very strong woman and I'm a very weak man," announced Amer and, as his love for his wife curdled following her release from prison, it was tempting to accept that statement at face value. Yet one of the joys of this film was the way it refused easy judgments, showing us that there are many different kinds of strength from Raghda's refusal to stop fighting for her country to Amer's no less admirable desire to find a "quiet life" for his children away from destruction and death.

Just as there were many different kinds of strength so too were there many different types of love from the passionate belief Amer nurtured during the long, terrible months of his wife's imprisonment to the conflicted emotions Raghda felt for her family and her country. "I started [fighting for my country] before the revolution and can not abandon it now," she admitted hollow-eyed during the film's harrowing midpoint, and you could see what it cost her to tell that bitter truth.

The most emotional moments, however, came from their sons, in particular the two youngest, Kaka and Bob. "My dad doesn't love my mum any more," said Bob, who in the earliest scenes had been shown hugging a phone with his absent mother's picture on it. "Do you think we'll be a real family some day?' asked the older Kaka, before wearily answering his own question: "I don't think so" and it was hard not to weep watching the protracted collapse of a loving group who had once believed that the simple act of reunion would be strong enough to help them survive.

Comments