Badger cull to halt rise of TB in cattle 'will in fact spread the disease'
Michael McCarthy
Michael McCarthy, formerly the Independent’s longstanding Environment Editor, now its Environment Columnist, is one of Britain’s leading writers on the environment and the natural world. He has won a string of awards for his work, including Environment Journalist of the Year (three times) and Specialist Writer of the Year in the British Press Awards in 2001. In 2007 he was awarded the Medal of the RSPB for “Outstanding Services to Conservation,” in 2010 he was awarded the Silver Medal of the Zoological Society of London, and in 2011 the Dilys Breeze Medal of the British Trust for Ornithology. In 2009 McCarthy published Say Goodbye To The Cuckoo (John Murray), a study of Britain’s declining migrant birds.
Sunday 24 June 2012
Related articles
Caroline Spelman’s proposed badger cull to halt the rise of TB in cattle will in fact spread the disease, campaigners will tell the High Court tomorrow.
The Badger Trust charity is seeking judicial review of the decision last year by the Environment Secretary to allow a cull to go ahead, after nearly 15 years of argument about the links between the animals and bovine TB.
Opponents of the plan argue that it will not only mean widespread cruelty – badgers are difficult to shoot cleanly, especially at night – but it will be ineffective, because scientists discovered during a seven-year-long culling trial, which ended in 2007, that killing badgers on a large scale can actually make the incidence of TB infection worse.
This is because survivors of a disturbed, partly-culled group of badgers tend to wander about the countryside, spreading TB as they go, in a phenomenon known as ‘perturbation’.
The perturbation argument will be at the heart of the challenge to the decision, being put before Mr Justice Ouseley at the High Court in London this morning by Mr David Wolfe, QC, on behalf of the Badger Trust (formerly the National Federation of Badger Groups).
Mr Wolfe will argue that the culls proposed will not meet the strict legal test of “preventing the spread of disease” in the areas being licensed, as Defra's own evidence for the hearing confirms that the proposed cull would in fact cause the spread of disease in and around the cull zones.
Defra argues that the effects of perturbation eventually die away, and after some years a reduction in the incidence of the disease of between 12 and 16 per cent is made possible.
But the Trust and Mr Wolfe are seeking to show that Mrs Spelman’s decision is legally flawed on two more grounds: firstly, that the cost estimates of the cull for farmers may be very much an under-estimate, and secondly, that the Environment Secretary was wrong in law to give to the job of licensing the shooting to the Government’s wildlife watchdog, Natural England.
The hearing is expected to last for two days, with a judgement expected in several weeks.
David Williams, chairman of the Badger Trust, said at the weekend: “We see it as our duty to use all legal means of persuasion and scientific argument to overturn this decision, which risks making a bad situation even worse.”
The Trust’s solicitor, Gwendolen Morgan of Bindmans, said: “The Badger Trust has not embarked on this litigation lightly. However, against Defra’s ‘flat earth’ approach to the evidence and determination to pursue an unlawful and costly culling spree, they have been left with no option.
Mrs Spelman’s decision, which reversed the policy of the previous Labour Government, delighted farmers and vets, but dismayed animal welfare campaigners, environmentalists and also some senior scientists.
A trial of the cull is due to take place this autumn in two of the worst affected areas, Gloucestershire and Somerset, and if it is successful it will be rolled out widely in 2013. Farmers will bear the cost themselves, and will form syndicates to hire trained marksmen to shoot badgers as they emerge from their setts in the evening. Thousands of the animals could eventually be killed.
It is widely accepted that badgers form a reservoir for the disease and do pass it on to cattle herds, and Mrs Spelman’s Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (Defra) holds that the situation is so serious that culling is now essential.
Compensation for cattle put down because of TB infection – at present, 25,000 are being slaughtered annually – has already cost the taxpayer £500m and the Government estimates the cost will rise to £1bn over the next decade unless “further action” is taken.
“Defra’s culling plans are bad for farmers, bad for cattle, and bad for badgers. The plans cost millions, and threaten to prompt rather than prevent the spread of disease. We hope that the decision to cull will be struck down by the court.”
Today’s case is not the only legal challenge to the cull which the Government faces. The Bern Convention – the Convention on the Conservation of European Wildlife and Natural Habitats – is considering at its Strasbourg headquarters a complaint lodged in January by the UK branch of the Humane Society International, which believes that the cull plan is a breach of the Government’s obligations under the convention.
In March this year, the Welsh government announced it had abandoned the idea of a badger cull of its own, in favour of a badger vaccination programme instead.
Defra has rejected a vaccination-only policy as it believes it would be too slow, with the animals having to be caught and then injected.
An easily-distributable oral vaccine is thought to be several years away at least.
From the blogs
Dish of the Day: Lily Vanilli’s recipe for making a human brain cake
A slight deviation from style this week and admittedly a bit weird, but at least I can finally say I...
Owen Howells: From the UK to Australia and back again (and again!)
Owen Howells is a DJ/producer who grew up in Australia but was born in the UK. He came back to the U...
Justice for sale but who pays for the cost?
Justice, the bedrock of our society is for sale under the Government’s latest plan to sell legal aid...
Dish of the Day: How to… make flower power cocktails
Take inspiration from the green-fingered brigade who have been showing off their creativity at the R...
- 1 What, let gays get married? We must be bonkers
- 2 Rocky Horror star Tim Curry 'suffers major stroke'
- 3 Exclusive: How MI5 blackmails British Muslims
- 4 Lord of the Sings: Sir Christopher Lee, 91, to release heavy metal album
- 5 Exclusive: Woolwich killings suspect Michael Adebolajo was inspired by cleric banned from UK after urging followers to behead enemies of Islam
Get your summer started with British Military Fitness
BMF is the UK’s biggest and best loved outdoor fitness classes
Visit York
Find out what The Independent's resident travel expert has to say about one of the most beautiful small cities in the world
Making reading fun for kids
Nook is donating eReaders to volunteers at high-need schools and participating in exclusive events throughout the campaign.
Introducing the 'Get Reading' campaign
Get the latest on The Evening Standard's campaign to get London's children reading.
Enter the latest Independent competitions
Win anything from gadgets to five-star holidays on our competitions and offers page.
Business videos from commercial thought leaders
Watch the best in the business world give their insights into the world of business.
Johnny Marr talks relationships and reunions
In pictures: After the flood
Death becomes her: A very modern mortician
School of chop: Learning the art of butchery
The man who's eaten everywhere
A Berliner in 1963 – but did John F Kennedy once admire Adolf Hitler?

Comments