Nature

1° London Hi 4°C / Lo -2°C

Conservationists do 'deal with the devil' to save orang-utans

Agreement sought with palm-oil industry to create ape-saving forest corridors

By Lewis Smith

Borneo's orang-utans

Borneo's orang-utans face a bleak future as loggers and farmers clear the rainforest

Wildlife campaigners have made "a deal with the devil" in a bid to save the orang-utan from being driven into extinction. They have teamed up with the palm-oil industry, widely condemned by conservationists for causing devastation to orang-utans.

But palm-oil companies and the Sabah state government in Borneo have agreed to a project to create wildlife corridors that will link forest areas and create a network of safe havens. They signed up to the pilot scheme last month in Kota Kinabalu, Borneo, and will meet again this month in London to try to agree final details. There are hopes the project can be expanded. Dr Marc Ancrenaz, director of the Kinabatangan Orang-utan Conservation Project, agreed the alliance between conservationists and the palm oil industry was like a pact with the devil but said the green lobby had to be pragmatic in its hopes of saving the red ape.

"The oil-palm industry is going to stay," he said. "There's no point in fighting development. We need to look for a solution together to save the orang-utan. By recreating 100m-wide corridors of forest along major rivers we will provide contiguous corridors of natural habitat to link isolated orang-utan populations. The oil-palm industry has to be part of our conservation efforts if we want to succeed, since the major orang-utan populations in Sabah are fragmented by oil-palm estates."

The meeting in London has been organised by the World Land Trust (WLT), which is anxious to keep all sides talking. Mary Tibbet, of the WLT, said: "It's important to get everyone to the table. The palm-oil industry has been vilified but there could be a mechanism in which they are engaged in the conservation of orang-utans.."

Orang-utans live only in Borneo and Sumatra but have been pushed back into ever-smaller areas of their rainforest habitat largely because of intensive logging and agriculture. In the past century, orang-utan numbers in Borneo and Sumatra have slumped by more than 75 per cent, and in Sabah they have crashed up to 90 per cent in 200 years. But Sabah remains a stronghold for the animal, with more than 11,000 orang-utans living there, a fifth of the total estimated wild population.

The palm-oil industry has expanded rapidly over 20 years, encroaching heavily on the forests where orang-utans live, in response to increasing demand from western countries for palm-oil in cooking and in biofuels. Malaysia is the world's biggest producer of palm oil, the country's third-biggest export, worth £11.5bn last year.

Without the corridors, the animals, which dislike travelling either on the ground or through crop plantations, are trapped in small areas of forest. These fragments support only a handful of the apes and in the long term they would die out because the gene pool is too small to be biologically viable.

The World Bank has stopped lending money to the palm-oil industry amid concerns about the impacts of plantation expansion on local people and the effects of deforestation on orang-utans and other wildlife. Companies such as Lush cosmetics and Cadbury New Zealand have stopped using palm-oil because of environmental concerns.

Post a Comment

View all comments that have been posted about this article.

Offensive or abusive comments will be removed and your IP logged and may be used to prevent further submission. In submitting a comment to the site, you agree to be bound by the Independent Minds Terms of Service.

Comments

Compromise
[info]tallise wrote:
Monday, 16 November 2009 at 09:17 am (UTC)
If every woman in the world had only two children, if every woman in the world had access to contraceptio, then the human population would stabilise and slightly decrease, and we could live at peace with the other wonderful occupants of this world.
The Red Ape Debate - World Land Trust
[info]claraduparc wrote:
Monday, 16 November 2009 at 11:06 am (UTC)
On 27th November 2009 at 7pm World Land Trust is hosting “The Red Ape Debate – The future for the orang-utan” at The Royal Geographical Society, London.

Experts from around the world will come together to discuss some of the key issues involved in both the conservation of wild orang-utans and the rehabilitation and release of captive orang-utans.

Urgent decisions need to be made: how best to ensure the survival of this, the “person of the forest”? Experts are divided in their opinions and this discussion will integrate some of their views and open the debate to the floor.

Expert participants include: Dr Marc Ancrenaz of Kinabatangan Orangutan Conservation Project, Dr Erik Meijaard from the Orangutan Conservation Services Programme, Lone Drosher Nielsen of Borneo Orangutan Survival Foundation, and Raymond Alfred from WWF Malaysia. The Earl of Cranbrook will be Chairing the debate.

Please use this link to purchase tickets http://www.worldlandtrust.org/news/events.htm#debate and see www.worldlandtrust.org for further information on the World Land Trust.



Land use?
[info]gloriapower wrote:
Monday, 16 November 2009 at 02:07 pm (UTC)
I want wild species saved from us. Palm oil is not as important as beautiful, innocent animals. I am happy the World Bank stopped lending money to palm oil interests.
Errors in the article
[info]helena_wlt wrote:
Tuesday, 17 November 2009 at 11:42 am (UTC)
Unfortunately, there were a couple of significant errors in the article published by the Independent yesterday (Conservationists do 'deal with the devil' to save orang-utans).

Firstly, Marc Ancrenaz of HUTAN never said that ‘the situation was like making a pact with the devil’. HUTAN are keen to emphasise that they would not make such a statement.

Secondly, the following paragraph is factually incorrect: “But palm-oil companies and the Sabah state government in Borneo have agreed to a project to create wildlife corridors that will link forest areas and create a network of safe havens. They signed up to the pilot scheme last month in Kota Kinabalu, Borneo, and will meet again this month in London to try to agree final details.”

The Sabah Government have not ‘signed up’ for any pilot scheme, but they have drawn up some positive resolutions in discussion with Oil Palm leaders at the recent Orangutan Conservation Colloquium, held in Kota Kinabalu in October 2009.

The event in London referred to in the article is a orang-utan conservation debate the World Land Trust is holding 27 November. This does not involve the Sabah Government and is not about them meeting to ‘agree final details’.

The journalist has been contacted and has apologised for the errors.

Article Archive

Day In a Page

Sun | Mon | Tue | Wed | Thu | Fri | Sat

Select date