Welcome to the new Independent website. We hope you enjoy it and we value your feedback. Please contact us here.

Books: A week in books

  • @indyvoices
Asking Clint Eastwood to direct the film of Midnight in the Garden of Good and Evil - John Berendt's steamy faction set in decadent Savannah - always sounded rather like hiring a rugby-league coach to train the Royal Ballet. True to form, Clint has now turned in a pretty flat-footed adaptation of the book (re-issued by Vintage; pounds 5.99). But his plodding movie does boast one sparkly rhinestone of a cameo role. The Lady Chablis (a razor-tongued local drag-queen who makes Lily Savage look like Ann Widdecombe) is played with show-stealing pizzazz by - The Lady Chablis. Think too hard about these layers of illusion, and vertigo will soon kick in. Suffice to say that the confusion has its roots not in Chablis's wardrobe, but in the very concept of a 'non-fiction novel'.

Berendt's bestseller helped revive this dubious brand of dramatised reportage. A hybrid and a bastard the form remains, although - like many such - it can exert a seductive pull. The genre in its modern guise began in the New Yorker in 1965, with the work that still defines it best: In Cold Blood, Truman Capote's throat-gripping account of four senseless murders on an isolated Kansas farm, and of the pair of wild drifters who were hanged for them.

A plump country caterpillar from Alabama who mutated into Manhattan's flashiest social butterfly, Capote never came close to equalling the book through his drink-and-drug-addled later years. That much, at least, is plain from the 500 grinding pages of George Plimpton's new 'oral biography', Truman Capote (Picador, pounds 20). If you fancy a gargantuan, high-society reprise of Lou Reed's 'New York Telephone Conversation' (with 30 pages lavished on a single party), Plimpton's vast patchwork of interviews will fit the bill. If not, just nip into a bookshop, find the index, and check the contributions from the grumpily respectful Norman Mailer and the archly hostile Gore Vidal. ('Capote said to me, "Thank heavens, Gore, we're not intellectuals". I said, "Speak for your fucking self!"').

For a writer who always chose to mingle gossip, fact and myth, a bald set of transcripts must count as the worst conceivable portrait. So, in the case of In Cold Blood, clashing statements from law officers about its veracity lie side by side on the page. Capote's reputation rests on us knowing exactly what sort of alchemy he worked with the truth. Yet, without any critical analysis, the many contradictions dangle in mid-air. One witness even claims that Capote wrote 'a good part' of To Kill a Mockingbird for his childhood friend and co-researcher in Kansas, Nelle Harper Lee. Well, did he or didn't he? It matters to that novel's horde off fans. This lazy method can't enlighten us.

Indeed, you often wonder how strong a guiding hand Plimpton imposed on the team of minions who did the tape-recording. This bloated tome alludes to an ex-Observer editor it calls 'David Avsder'. Now, Plimpton probably knows David Astor, and the great literary socialite can certainly spell his dynasty. If a book carries your name on its cover, surely good manners dictate you should at least read it first?