Size-zero hero: Fashion's high priestess calls time on 'size zero'
'Vogue' admits to retouching photos as editor calls on world designers to stop producing clothes that even the skinniest models can't get into
It is the ultimate "size zero" backlash. The editor of Vogue has lambasted the world's top designers for making their clothes too tight for even the skinniest models.
In a letter sent to the biggest names in fashion, from Prada to Chanel, Alexandra Shulman has blamed fashion houses for forcing fashion magazines to find unrealistically tiny models to squeeze into their designs. Photos of models with "no breasts or hips" encourage eating disorders, which affect more than a million people in Britain, campaigners believe.
Her letter to designers from Stella McCartney and John Galliano to Karl Lagerfeld and Alexander McQueen comes as new designers are being urged to "recast the beauty ideal" by designing catwalk clothes that might actually fit real women. For the first time, this autumn's London Fashion Week will feature an event celebrating all shapes and sizes, rather than the "size zeros" that prevail in a typical catwalk show.
The British Fashion Council, which organises the capital's biannual fashion extravaganza, is backing the initiative from Beat, Britain's leading eating disorder charity, which will showcase curvier, older models than the likes of such skinny catwalk superstars as Agyness Deyn and Lily Cole. "It will celebrate and represent a range of body shapes and sizes," said Caroline Rush, the BFC's joint chief executive.
Caryn Franklin, a fashion writer and broadcaster who is working with Beat on the event, said: "It's about expanding the imagery that comes out of LFW so that women can for once see themselves mirrored [in the catwalk photos]."
The supermodel Erin O'Connor, who is deputy chairman of LFW, is also working with Beat on the event. She backed Ms Shulman's call for designers to rethink their sizing, fashion's dark secret that lies at the heart of the "size zero" furore, which has claimed the lives of several models who starved themselves to shoehorn their bodies into tiny catwalk designs. Ms Franklin added: "It's fantastic that Alex, from her position of power and respect, is saying that even Vogue has had enough."
Ms Shulman's letter pointed out that Vogue frequently had to retouch photographs to make models look larger – the opposite of the sort of vanity airbrushing that usually goes on at magazines. It is the first time that a fashion magazine has ever locked horns with designers over their skimpy sizes.
Ms Rush added: "We are pleased that Vogue has chosen to highlight issues of sample sizing and identify their readers' concerns for model health and the photographic representation of fashion."
Although designers claim their samples are sized 8 to 10, fashion insiders admit that these bear no resemblance to anything you might find hanging on the size 8 or 10 hangers at a high street retailer.
Even some of the hottest newer models, such as Daisy Lowe, are too big for most sample sizes.
So far, no designer has responded publicly to the Vogue editor's letter, which was sent at the end of last month. Instead, designers have defended their sizing as "perfectly reasonable", according to Ms Shulman.
But for Beat's LFW event, which will be held at Somerset House in September, designers will have to cut their clothes more generously. Susan Ringwood, chief executive of Beat, said: "We want to encourage the fashion industry to show diversity and to challenge the aesthetic. The beauty ideal needs to be recast. It's not about being very tall or very thin."
It is the first time that the eating disorder charity will be involved with an event at London Fashion Week.
View all comments that have been posted about this article.
Offensive or abusive comments will be removed and your IP logged and may be used to prevent further submission. In submitting a comment to the site, you agree to be bound by the Independent Minds Terms of Service.
- Print Article
- Email Article
-
Click here for copyright permissions
Copyright 2009 Independent News and Media Limited



Comments
Of course, women come in all shapes and sizes including the naturally tall and thin but that is different from unnaturally jutting, protruding bones.
24 Apr 2009 ... The appearance of a super skinny contestant in Australia's Miss Universe pageant has re-ignited the debate over size zero models
Latest News
The pattern of burn marks on her bones showed that after she died, ... As he sees it, there was no later migration and replacement "Only one species of human .... Mungo Man also appeared to mock the findings of previous scientists: His mtDNA ... wolves and coyotes, dromedaries and Bactrian camels also cross-mate. ...
21 Sep 2006 ... This is the young model who died at a catwalk show after days without eating. Her death, during Uruguay's fashion week, led to the ban on ...
I am sorry I just lost my eggs on toast and am looking for these. With any luck by the ants, I will come back eat them.
I saw this in the Sky news. I hate one thing. Not just the nudes no shapes but the comments column. You comment and go back after some time to see if your comments the comment column shows three comments and there is a small line .. Page expands. And it does for thirty-five minutes and you do not see your comment that was one line. Boy these models and SKY get me at times. Other ting I see is the fat lady who talks about the Vogue magazines and these zero and 1111 the bits and bytes cannot come. I agree they are not worth to hyenas but the lady Ms Shulman says. Ironically, the highly respected fashion editor also revealed that some cover images only show faces - not the clothes - because readers are "uncomfortable". I swear I am very interested. My fish can play with them.
The Times has now published parts of the lambasting letter, which was not intended for publication, from Ms Shulman about so-called size-zero models.
"During the time I have been at Vogue the sample sizes that models are required to wear have become substantially smaller," she wrote in the missive.
http://news.sky.com/skynews/Home/UK-New
I thank you
Firozali A. Mulla
They could easily used a bigger model and ask for a bigger size from the designers.... instead of just blaming them.