Science proves acupuncture is sound medicine

On Facebook
Life & Style blogs

Online House Hunter: Mortgage relief

Banks would appear to be finally relinquishing their stranglehold on mortgages. Our Online House Hun...

Online House Hunter: Hard sell

How much would you reduce the price of your house by to achieve a sale? Our Online House Hunter look...

Not sick enough for hospital, not well enough to cope

Another day, another report concluding that “integration” is what will save a health and social care...

Acupuncture works – but it does so thanks to orthodox scientific principles and not because of the centuries-old Chinese philosophy on which it is based, a leading acupuncturist has said – on the day the British medical establishment adopted the technique.

Adrian White, editor-in-chief of the journal Acupuncture In Medicine, said the principles of acupuncture were firmly grounded in science. "You don't need Chinese philosophy either to make it work or to practise it."

His remarks, at a reception to mark the first venture into the world of alternative medicine by the BMJ Group, publishers of the British Medical Journal, ruffled feathers in the traditional acupuncture world.

The BMJ Group is taking over publication of Acupuncture In Medicine. It aims to build up an evidence base for acupuncture treatment and to help doctors practise it. Dr White, a clinical research fellow at the University of Plymouth and trained acupuncturist, said the public and doctors had a distorted view of acupuncture which had hindered its acceptance in medicine and its wider use in pain control after surgery, and in conditions ranging from nausea to arthritis.

"One of the major problems facing medical acupuncture is preconceived notions. The perception is that acupuncture is all about chi and meridians.

"In the past, it was easy for scientists to dismiss acupuncture as highly implausible when its workings were couched in these terms. But it becomes very plausible when explained in terms of neurophysiology. Unfortunately, the scientific approach just isn't as sexy."

Scientific evidence had been building for 30 years showing that acupuncture stimulated the nerves in the brain and spinal cord, releasing "feel good" chemicals such opioids and serotonin.

Research also showed that needles placed outside of the traditional meridians also had an impact. Studies comparing needles placed according to traditional teaching and those placed randomly have shown similar effects.

"Points don't have any magical properties. They are simply convenient locations to needle," Dr White said.

The mystery of Chinese philosophy in which acupuncture was shrouded acted as a deterrent to doctors. "They can easily learn to practise acupuncture safely and effectively after a short foundation course," he said.

Paul Robin, the chairman of the Acupuncture Society, which combines traditional and medical approaches, said: "Dr White is talking about a very limited form of acupuncture and trying to justify it scientifically. It is not the whole story. Using meridians to place the needles is very useful. The Chinese have mapped them out and they are linked to body organs, sometimes by nerves and sometimes by energy movements."

Mr Robin, who had nine years training, also dismissed the suggestion that a practitioner could learn the technique in days. "To become a full acupuncturist requires three years training and involves study of the meridians and Chinese philosophy," he said.

Independent Comment
blog comments powered by Disqus

Day In a Page

Jim Gamble: We are losing the race to protect our young

Jim Gamble: We are losing the race to protect our young

Technology and the children who use it won't wait for slow-moving child-protection services and police to catch up
Sarah Sands: A friend is not the one you turn to, but the person who turns to you

Sarah Sands on friendship

A friend is not the one you turn to, but the person who turns to you
Andy Burnham: 'It's a genie out of the bottle moment'

Andy Burnham interview

'It's a genie out of the bottle moment'
Leveson: What we've learnt so far

Leveson: What we've learnt so far

Ingenious hacks, shifty editors and attacks of Sudden Memory Loss Syndrome – Matthew Bell assesses the state of play at the Royal Courts of Justice
Modern lovers: The 'sexual body warriors' and pioneers transforming 21st-century relationships

Modern lovers: The 'sexual body warriors'

Sarah Morrison meets the people redefining love in the 21st century.
'I was angry, so angry': How heartbreak, betrayal and Su Pollard helped Estelle find pop success

Estelle: 'I was angry, so angry'

The singer talks about heartache, betrayal and bouncing back.
Choc tactics: Bill Granger's Valentine's recipes for chocoholics

Bill Granger's Valentine's recipes for chocoholics

Should it be white, milk or plain? Can you make a melt-in-the-mouth pudding without using any?
Male, pale & stale: Could more women on the board help Mothercare – and other ailing firms?

Male, pale & stale

Could more women on the board help Mothercare – and other ailing firms?
Upstairs, downstairs, 2012-style

Upstairs, downstairs, 2012-style

There are now more domestic workers in Britain than in Edwardian times
Boos in Berlin for Jolie's war drama

Boos in Berlin for Jolie's war drama

Hollywood star defends her hard-hitting and controversial story set during the 1990s Bosnian conflict
How Whiteclay (population: 11) sells 5m cans of beer a year

How Whiteclay (population: 11) sells 5m cans of beer a year

It's 20 minutes' drive from a 20,000-strong Native American reservation, which is now suing brewers and the town's off-licences
Ian Holloway: Choose Harry, then give the next English batch a chance

Ian Holloway

Choose Harry, then give the next English batch a chance
Peter Storrie: Forgotten man has his day in the sun

Peter Storrie interview

Forgotten man has his day in the sun
The Last Word: If Harry can't get England out of jail, we may as well throw away the key

The Last Word

If Harry can't get England out of jail, we may as well throw away the key
Suits you sir: Bill Nighy talks politics and sartorial style

Suits you sir: Bill Nighy talks politics and sartorial style

He avoids Shakespeare at all costs, almost killed Judi Dench in his latest film, and only steps out in the sharpest jacket and tie...