Budget '97: Problems ahead as legal wrangles start
Windfall tax: CHALLENGE IN THE COURTS
The company, which did not want to be identified, has already decided it will almost certainly not challenge the legality of the tax and was told by a leading tax lawyer that it would have to pay the levy whether or not other groups make a legal challenge.
The advice has emerged as the chances of serious court battle against the windfall tax increased after British Telecom made an unexpected and unprecedented public outburst.
Some electricity and water companies had hoped they may be able to defer payment of the tax pending BT's court battle in the UK or, more probably, in Europe.
But the multi-utility was told it could only avoid handing the money across if it joined any BT action.
In reality, as BT's interest in legal challenges has grown, the attraction of the move for the electricity and water groups has dimmed. In February Labour attempted to take the heat out of the debate with a legal opinion by Michael Beloff QC.
It argued that the companies would have no chance of fighting the policy through the UK courts.
"It is a fundamental principle of domestic law that Parliament is sovereign; it may make or unmake any law whatsoever." Yet behind the scenes the legality of the tax was giving the party cause for concern.
City lawyers had shifted their attention to an appeal through the European Commission. They suggested the tax could unfairly discriminate between different EU nationalities, for example in the case of Northumbrian Water, which is now owned by Lyonnaise des Eaux of France.
However, sources within DG15, the Commission arm responsible for the single market, predicted national governments would still have the final say. "From our point of view it's a UK matter," said the source.
The most hopeful area of attack for the utilities remained a challenge to the windfall tax on competition grounds, using the argument that the tax amounts to state aid in reverse, by giving rival companies an advantage.
Karel van Miert, the Competition Commissioner, has already indicated that he may have to examine this case closely.
BT claimed the windfall levy amounted to a subsidy for its main UK competitor, Mercury, which would not be included in the levy.
Even if Mr Van Miert sought to hold up the windfall tax, he cannot act in isolation.
Another EC source said: "If there was a state aid issue the Commission would have to look at it. But the final decision would be taken by the Commission as a whole, so it would be a collegiate matter."
- 1 Man and woman arrested on suspicion of conspiracy to murder victim of Woolwich machete attack, named as Drummer Lee Rigby
- 2 'Sickening, deluded and unforgivable': Horrific attack brings terror to London’s streets
- 3 Grace Dent: I’m not sure how these people can avoid being called ‘bigots’. And the more ‘civilised’, the worse they are
- 4 Woolwich murder: They killed, then they performed - these men should be starved of our attention
- 5 Woolwich attack: The EDL will seek to exploit this evil crime for their own evil ends
BMF is the UK’s biggest and best loved outdoor fitness classes
Find out what The Independent's resident travel expert has to say about one of the most beautiful small cities in the world
Nook is donating eReaders to volunteers at high-need schools and participating in exclusive events throughout the campaign.
Get the latest on The Evening Standard's campaign to get London's children reading.
Win anything from gadgets to five-star holidays on our competitions and offers page.
Day In a Page
A modern home of almost 1,000sq ft is close to Stoke Newington's high street. £499,950
A five-bedroom bungalow in Hoveton with riverside garden and mooring dock, £550,000
A refurbished one-bedroom flat with south-facing reception and high ceilings. £579,950
A four-bedroom Grade II-listed house in Nazeing with large gardens. £550,000
A modern four-bedroom house in a converted stable within walking distance to Peckham Rye. £695,000
Three-bedroom house in a quiet residential area within close distance to Battersea Park. £450,000
A three-bedroom cottage within commuting distance of London, Norwich and Cambridge. £250,000
A two-bedroom cottage with a sun room and gardens in South Chard. £350,000.
A three-bedroom semi-detached house with original features including fireplaces and wooden flooring. £399,950
A modern two-bedroom flat split across two floors and close to several public transport links. £595,000
A one-bedroom flat with an open-plan reception/kitchen and private balcony. £315,000.
A bright two-bedroom garden flat between South Acton and Chiswick Park. £499,950.
A listed four-bedroom farmhouse with stables, set in four acres. £500,000.
A three-storey family home with four bedrooms and an extended kitchen/diner. £995,000.
A three-bedroom Hamstone cottage in the rolling Somerset countryside. £430,000.
A luxury one-bedroom apartment on the first floor of a converted Victorian house. £425,000.