Stay up to date with notifications from The Independent

Notifications can be managed in browser preferences.

As war buffets the world's airlines, which ones will still be in it for the long haul?

Conflict could spell the end for at least one big-name carrier

Clayton Hirst
Sunday 23 March 2003 01:00 GMT
Comments

Read this list carefully: British Airways, Virgin Atlantic, KLM, SAS, Lufthansa, Alitalia, Air France, American Airlines and United Airlines. Analysts believe it's safe to assume that at least one of these names will disappear as a result of the war with Iraq.

Already cash-starved from the aftermath of the 11 Sep- tember attacks and the downturn in the global economy, the airlines couldn't have seen the war come at a worse time. The long-haul carriers have already suffered a 15 per cent fall in forward ticket sales as passengers fret about the risks of flying. Now that hostilities have begun, sales are predicted to plummet 30 per cent over the next month.

Last week the airlines began to prepare for what could be one of the most troubled periods in civil aviation history, by cutting routes and making thousands of redundancies. But, as credit agency Standard & Poor's put 11 airlines on watch for a possible downgrade, this will just be the start. "The last Gulf war resulted in a four-year trough for the airline industry. Because the industry is already in a trough, this time it could take much longer to climb out," says Daniel Solon, an analyst at aerospace research company Avmark International.

The news couldn't be much worse for Rod Eddington, chief executive of British Airways. He has already slashed costs and made 10,000 redundant. But these drastic steps won't be enough. Some 80 per cent of the company's revenues come from long-haul flights, leaving it acutely exposed to the war.

"It's going to be pretty hardcore for BA," says Rebecca Langley, an analyst at investment bank Dresdner Kleinwort Wasserstein (DKW). Based on the fall in customers during the 1991 Gulf war, DKW estimates this conflict could cost BA £300m, pushing it £100m into the red next year. BA is expected to announce 3,000 new redundancies soon to stem the decline.

Another threat is the sharp rise in the price of aviation fuel as a result of the troubles in the Middle East. BA, like most airlines, buys fuel on long-term contracts. But at the end of this month many of those contracts will expire and the company will be forced to buy around half of its fuel on the open market. Over the last year the price of aviation fuel has risen by more than 50 per cent, and the airlines will be praying that the latest fall in oil prices is sustained.

But BA has a buffer against the downturn in the shape of £1.8bn of cash on its balance sheet and £400m available in loans. As a result, most analysts believe it will survive and may even be the catalyst for mergers. It is understood that KLM is in BA's sights and Mr Eddington is due to meet his Dutch counterpart in the next few days for talks.

It is more difficult to assess how the war will affect BA's big rival, Virgin Atlantic, as it is a private com- pany. Virgin Atlantic concedes that forward ticket bookings have fallen, but a spokesman says that it won't cut capacity until it is clear how war will affect sales. However, accounts filed at Companies House reveal that Virgin Atlantic is still suffering from the aftermath of 11 September. In the year to 30 April 2002, it made a £92m loss after tax on a turnover of £1.4bn. This compares with a £45m profit and £1.5bn turnover in the previous year.

Other European airlines, such as KLM, SAS and Alitalia, are also struggling. And the recent revival in the fortunes of Air France and Lufthansa could be quickly snubbed out by the war.

The conflict could also deliver a double blow to airports operator BAA. The former monopoly, which owns airports such as Heathrow, Gatwick and Stansted, makes its money by charging airlines for its facilities and by taking a slice of the revenues generated by retailers. On average, each passenger generates £5 in airport fees and £4 in retailing for BAA.

The 1991 Gulf war led to a 7 per cent fall in passenger volumes at BAA's airports over a year, with a 14 per cent drop in the first quarter. If this war leads to a similar fall then BAA will lose around £75m of revenues this year with £35m going in the next three months. Having committed to invest £8bn over 11 years on new facilities such as the fifth terminal at Heathrow, it would find any fall in revenues hard to stomach.

A spokeswoman says that BAA has no plans to scale back or postpone its investment programme, but admits "it could be a contingency".

The biggest impact of war, though, could be felt at US airlines. Already the effects of 11 September have forced United Airlines and US Airways into Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection. American Airlines, the world's biggest carrier which last year lost $3.5bn (£2.2bn), is teetering on the edge. The war is expected to force it to seek protection from creditors.

Much to the annoyance of the European airlines, the American carriers can turn to Washington for help. Following11 September, US airlines received $15bn in aid. Some US airline lobbyists have described the outbreak of war as a "silver lining".

Sensing further gloom in the industry, on Wednesday US politicians proposed a law, the Aviation Stabilization Act, which if passed would allow airlines to borrow money from the government to pay for fuel, insurance and new security systems. While there is no guarantee that it will become law, US government sources insist that it is "ready to move quickly" to help the airlines.

This is in stark contrast to the attitude of the British Government. The Department for Transport hasn't even set up a working group to discuss the impact of war on the airlines. A spokesman says that there are no plans to offer UK carriers any financial assistance.

But amid the gloom, there is one sector that could emerge from war unscathed; it may even profit. In the countdown to the war, many budget and short-haul airlines increased ticket sales. The most dramatic uplift has come at Ryanair, which this month has seen bookings rise 35 per cent on the same period last year. Meanwhile, easyJet is predicting growth of 25 per cent this year and BMI British Midland, principally a short-haul airline, says war "hasn't had any effect on our business at all".

In an echo of the period immediately after 11 September, travellers are turning away from long flights and planning shorter trips in Europe. But every week that this trend continues is a week of pain for established airlines. When war with Iraq is over, aviation will be changed for good.

Join our commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies

Comments

Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in