Battle of the break-up: Will bankers win in September?

Lord Oakeshott says it's 'creepy' the way unelected but powerful groups like the banks and the Murdoch empire call the shots. But the Independent Commission on Banking's autumn report could redress the balance, writes Margareta Pagano

While bankers are slipping away to the beaches, members of the Independent Commission on Banking will not be taking time off as they work flat out on the final report into the future structure of banking ahead of the September deadline.

Until recently, the ICB's conclusions appeared done and dusted; the interim report in April suggested that ring-fencing the retail parts of the UK's banks from their investment divisions was the preferred solution to prevent the banks ever again having to be rescued by the taxpayer. And, only a few weeks ago, the ring-fencing option – as opposed to a full separation – looked sewn up, particularly as it was given such support by George Osborne, the Chancellor, in his Mansion House speech.

But now the game could be changing; there are signs that the interim was really only an interim, a teaser to flesh out the some of the more strident views and criticisms. One politician who has picked up that the ICB may be having second thoughts is Lord Oakeshott, the former Liberal Democrat Treasury spokesman.

He says: "I hear vibrations coming from those around the commission that it's not done and dusted, that many of the commissioners are worried that ring-fencing isn't the most effective solution after all. They have heard many of the criticisms and misgivings that have been expressed – from the Treasury Select Committee among others – and they are still looking at all the options, including full separation."

Lord Oakeshott is not the only one to have picked up on a change in mood. In the City, banking analysts to whom I have spoken suggest there maybe up to two out of the five commissioners moving towards separation, including Clare Spottiswoode, the consumer advocate and former gas regulator, as well as Martin Taylor, ex-boss of Barclays, and Martin Wolf, FT writer and economist. The fourth member of the ICB, which is chaired by the economist, Sir John Vickers, is Bill Winters, ex-head of JP Morgan, who is unlikely to support a full separation, considering his investment banking background.

That's why Vince Cable's decision to throw down the gauntlet on banking reform in a big speech last week for a Which? conference was so fascinating. Cable called into question again whether the ICB's ring-fencing would work in practice and repeated his own backing for the nuclear option of full separation.

The Business Secretary's warning carried two clear messages – that Sir John and his team should be courageous when they make their recommendations – and a subtle hint that it's not too late to change them – as well as a reminder to the City that this is by no means a done deal.

He said: "The ring-fencing approach has been criticised for being insufficiently clear cut and too open to regulatory arbitrage by those arguing for full separation; and by the banks themselves for going too far – though the ICB discounts the threat of banks to relocate headquarters elsewhere."

After the speech, Cable elaborated, saying that if Vickers and his team go for ring-fencing, then they need to persuade the public that it will work in practice, and that it is not going to be too expensive. "If the ICB can't demonstrate that a ring-fenced form of separation works in practice, then they need to go the whole hog for full separation. At the moment, we have the minimum argument but need to hear the maximum."

These are his questions: "Would ring-fencing stop banks using deposits underwritten by the taxpayer to cross-subsidise their 'casinos'? Will the ring-fence be high enough and the 'Chinese walls' strong enough to eliminate regulatory arbitrage by the banks? Will the division between what is inside and outside the ring-fence ensure that nothing resembling a universal bank remains?"

But Cable added: "I'm sure that the Vickers team – which includes five of the brightest people in Britain – set up by me and George Osborne will come up with the right answers. I'm fairly optimistic that when they do decide, we will back the report and then move very quickly to get it into place.

"This is only the first step towards getting the fundamental structure of the banking system right, and is critical to the way we deal with the economy in the aftermath of the banking crash of two years ago. We've got to get more competition into the high street too, and more lending through to the SMEs."

Reforming the banking system is still top priority for the Lib Dems and it is the number one item in the coalition agreement. As Lord Oakeshott said: "Vince's speech last week was hugely important, as it reasserted his authority over the debate. It's been rather creepy over the last year watching two unelected but powerful groups – the Murdoch empire and the banks – go about their lobbying in Westminster; one has been dealt with, and now we have got the banks to deal with, and we are not backsliding, I can assure you.

"What the Lib Dems did over tuition fees and the NHS were a warm-up; this could be much bigger."

Expect a heated autumn start to Parliament. Sir John is due to deliver his final report to the Chancellor and Cable, the chairman and deputy chairman respectively of the Cabinet committee which set up the ICB, before publishing it on 12 September. They are then expected to consult on the report with fellow committee members, including Sir Stephen Green, the ex-HSBC boss and now Trade and Investment minister, before giving their backing – or not. It's likely to be a fiery week, as the Lib Dem party is holding its annual conference the following weekend and Cable is planning a big keynote speech on the Monday – on banking.

So far, this debate has not followed political lines. The Lib Dems, almost to a man and woman, want breaking up the banks as the first step towards fundamental reform. It's a view endorsed by the Governor of the Bank of England, Mervyn King, who has on many occasions said: "Of all the many ways of organising banking, the worst is the one we have today."

In a speech last week David Miles, one of the Monetary Policy Committee members of the Bank of England, raised the issue again when he questioned the assumption that it is too costly for banks to fund their assets through equity.

George Osborne is one the few senior Tory politicians to back ring-fencing, a stance seen within the Treasury as a elegant compromise which doesn't annoy the banks too much. But, at No 10 the mood is said to be more complex, with David Cameron and his advisers under heavyweight lobbying from the top bankers to stop any big-scale reform – Bob Diamond, head of Barclays, was on a recent trip with David Cameron to Nigeria. To date, the Labour Party has refused to say where it stands – although both Gordon Brown and Alistair Darling were always against reforms.

Banks such as Barclays and Royal Bank of Scotland are still lobbying against a big break-up, as is the British Bankers Association, worried by the costs of legal separation. As one insider said: "The ICB is in a tricky position because it must come up with reforms which are effective, but also a plan which is palatable, and it can get through Parliament."

It's also why the City economist Professor John Kay backed Vince Cable's dramatic intervention last week: "It was absolutely necessary for Dr Cable to throw down the gauntlet. It's hard to see how ring-fencing will work without really tough conditions. There are still too many big questions that the ICB hasn't answered but which are key to whether ring-fencing can work.

"We need to know what assets a retail bank can hold within the fence. It's got to be all government securities, all residential mortgages and all SME lending – if anything else fiddly or complicated gets included, then the game is up."

Professor Kay, who was one of the earliest proponents in favour of a full split between retail and investment banking as the safest way of protecting taxpayers from the future follies of bankers, added: "Banks like Barclays are absolutely opposed to any ring-fencing, and it's an open question whether BarCap would be viable without the retail assets of Barclays. Other banks like HSBC do, in effect, already operate their own form of ring-fence. I don't see any problem with the UK making a unilateral decision either."

The two banks he says that are the most vulnerable, and the most important to make watertight, are Barclays and Royal Bank of Scotland – the government-owned bank which still has a balance sheet bigger than the whole of the UK.

He also has the answer to introducing more competition into SME lending – "Break up Royal Bank of Scotland which has 40 per cent of all small business lending. The Government had the chance to do it a long time ago – when it was rescued. It's not late: it could still be broken up."

But Kay, who was one of the first proponents of breaking up the banks, has an interesting challenge for ICB to consider while making its decision – that the banks should be given the option to choose what they want to do voluntarily first. "Give them the option to decide how to break themselves up. They would then have to demonstrate that the method they chose would be fire-proof and that, in the event of failure, they would not resort to taxpayer subsidies."

As he says, break-ups worked, eventually, for British Gas and British Telecom, so why shouldn't the same principle be applied to banks? It's another good question and one which the banks might like to ponder themselves if they don't want to be forced to split.

The Commission: A brief to protect the public from future crises

The Independent Commission on Banking was set up following the 2008 crash to consider the structure of the UK banking sector, including the complex issue of how best to separate retail and investment banking functions, as well as promoting more competition.

The commission is trying to tackle several related issues: how to protect high-street banking operations if a bank collapses, how to make huge banking losses fall on the bank's investors and not on tax-payers via a publicly funded bail-out and how to introduce some more competition for basic banking services.

To date the ICB has recommended that setting up a legal 'ring-fence' or some form of 'subsidiarisation' between the two functions would be the most effective and the least costly solution but has stopped short of calling for a full break-up. All the UK's big banks such as Barclays and Royal Bank of Scotland are fighting the reforms, claiming that neither ring-fencing nor a full separation will reduce risk and warn that costs will go up. They have also threatened to move overseas if the Government were to go ahead, a threat which the ICB has been dismissed as unrealistic.

Suggested Topics
voicesGood for Lana Del Rey for helping kill that myth, writes Grace Dent
The Pipes and Drums of The Scottish Regiments perform during the Opening Ceremony for the Glasgow 2014 Commonwealth Games at Celtic Park on July 23, 2014 in Glasgow, Scotland.
Commonwealth GamesThe actor encouraged the one billion viewers of the event to donate to the children's charity
Karen Dunbar performs
Entertainers showcase local wit, talent and irrepressible spirit
Arts and Entertainment
The Tour de France peloton rides over a bridge on the Grinton Moor, Yorkshire, earlier this month
Life and Style
fashion Designs are part of feminist art project by a British student
Very tasty: Vladimir Putin dining alone, perhaps sensibly
Life and Style
Listen here: Apple EarPods offer an alternative
techAre custom, 3D printed earbuds the solution?
The University of California study monitored the reaction of 36 dogs
sciencePets' range of emotions revealed
Arts and Entertainment
The nomination of 'The Wake' by Paul Kingsnorth has caused a stir
Joining forces: young British men feature in an Isis video in which they urge Islamists in the West to join them in Iraq and Syria
newsWill the young Britons fighting in Syria be allowed to return home and resume their lives?
Snoop Dogg pictured at The Hollywood Reporter Nominees' Night in February, 2013
people... says Snoop Dogg
ebookA unique anthology of reporting and analysis of a crucial period of history
Life and Style
food + drinkZebra meat is exotic and lean - but does it taste good?
Bey can do it: Beyoncé re-enacts Rosie the Riveter's pose
newsRosie the Riveter started out as an American wartime poster girl and has become a feminist pin-up. With Beyoncé channeling her look, Gillian Orr tells her story
Life and Style
Donna and Paul Wheatley at their wedding
healthShould emergency hospital weddings be made easier for the terminally ill?
Arts and Entertainment
Residents of Derby Road in Southampton oppose filming of Channel 4 documentary Immigration Street in their community
Latest stories from i100
Have you tried new the Independent Digital Edition apps?
Independent Dating

By clicking 'Search' you
are agreeing to our
Terms of Use.

iJobs Job Widget
iJobs Money & Business

PMO Analyst - London - Banking - £350 - £400

£350 - £400 per day: Orgtel: PMO Analyst - Banking - London - £350 -£400 per d...

Cost Reporting-MI Packs-Edinburgh-Bank-£350/day

£300 - £350 per day + competitive: Orgtel: Cost Reporting Manager - MI Packs -...

Insight Analyst – Permanent – Up to £40k – North London

£35000 - £40000 Per Annum plus 23 days holiday and pension scheme: Clearwater ...

Test Lead - London - Investment Banking

£475 - £525 per day: Orgtel: Test Lead, London, Investment Banking, Technical ...

Day In a Page

Screwing your way to the top? Good for Lana Del Rey for helping kill that myth

Screwing your way to the top?

Good for Lana Del Rey for helping kill that myth, says Grace Dent
Will the young Britons fighting in Syria be allowed to return home and resume their lives?

Will Britons fighting in Syria be able to resume their lives?

Tony Blair's Terrorism Act 2006 has made it an offence to take part in military action abroad with a "political, ideological, religious or racial motive"
Beyoncé poses as Rosie the Riveter, the wartime poster girl who became a feminist pin-up

Beyoncé poses as Rosie the Riveter

The wartime poster girl became the ultimate American symbol of female empowerment
The quest to find the perfect pair of earphones: Are custom, 3D printed earbuds the solution?

The quest to find the perfect pair of earphones

Earphones don't fit properly, offer mediocre audio quality and can even be painful. So the quest to design the perfect pair is music to Seth Stevenson's ears
Climate change threatens to make the antarctic fur seal extinct

Take a good look while you can

How climate change could wipe out this seal
Should emergency hospital weddings be made easier for the terminally ill?

Farewell, my lovely

Should emergency hospital weddings be made easier?
Man Booker Prize 2014 longlist: Crowdfunded novel nominated for first time

Crowdfunded novel nominated for Booker Prize

Paul Kingsnorth's 'The Wake' is in contention for the prestigious award
Vladimir Putin employs a full-time food taster to ensure his meals aren't poisoned

Vladimir Putin employs a full-time food taster

John Walsh salutes those brave souls who have, throughout history, put their knives on the line
Tour de France effect brings Hollywood blockbusters to Yorkshire

Tour de France effect brings Hollywood blockbusters to Yorkshire

A $25m thriller starring Sam Worthington to be made in God's Own Country
Will The Minerva Project - the first 'elite' American university to be launched in a century - change the face of higher learning?

Will The Minerva Project change the face of higher learning?

The university has no lecture halls, no debating societies, no sports teams and no fraternities. Instead, the 33 students who have made the cut at Minerva, will travel the world and change the face of higher learning
The 10 best pedicure products

Feet treat: 10 best pedicure products

Bags packed and all prepped for holidays, but feet in a state? Get them flip-flop-ready with our pick of the items for a DIY treatment
Noel Fielding's 'Luxury Comedy': A land of the outright bizarre

Noel Fielding's 'Luxury Comedy'

A land of the outright bizarre
What are the worst 'Word Crimes'?

What are the worst 'Word Crimes'?

‘Weird Al’ Yankovic's latest video is an ode to good grammar. But what do The Independent’s experts think he’s missed out?
Can Secret Cinema sell 80,000 'Back to the Future' tickets?

The worst kept secret in cinema

A cult movie event aims to immerse audiences of 80,000 in ‘Back to the Future’. But has it lost its magic?
Facebook: The new hatched, matched and dispatched

The new hatched, matched and dispatched

Family events used to be marked in the personal columns. But now Facebook has usurped the ‘Births, Deaths and Marriages’ announcements