Hamish McRae: Even wealthy Germany can't afford to save the eurozone

Economic Life: Bond yields are lower than at any time in the 19th century, lower than in the 1930s

The long and winding tale of the eurozone took a new twist yesterday, with money flooding into German bonds, taking their interest rates to the lowest ever, and with the euro extending its fall, reaching the lowest level against the dollar since August 2010.

Click HERE to view graphic

Meanwhile, the pressure has mounted for Germany to agree to issuing "eurobonds", guaranteed by the whole of the eurozone. That was a key issue at the informal eurozone summit in Brussels yesterday.

It is a neat idea, the logical next step in unifying the eurozone. Why cannot the entire financial weight of the monetary union be put behind its borrowing? This would cut the cost of borrowing dramatically for the weaker members and only make a marginal increase to the cost for the core ones. France's previous president wanted it, as does the present one. Most other European nations support it in some measure. Only Germany is holding out.

Well, we may end up there, but Germany has powerful reasons not to allow itself to be pushed down this particular path.

For a start, while from the outside Germany looks all powerful, with its growing economy (unlike the rest of the eurozone), its super-competitive exports, and of course this status as a safe haven for scared funds, its position is not as secure as it seems.

I am writing this from Wiesbaden, the spa town near Frankfurt, where all is calm and prosperous (I am told things hot up in the evening, when the casino gets going).

You see all around you the fruits of the German achievement. It arouses resentment as well as admiration: Germany has benefited from the euro so it can pay to keep it going.

But it has only benefited because it has squeezed down costs and consumption for more than a decade, for as is now generally recognised Germany joined the euro at too high a rate and it therefore had to follow the course of austerity it now feels the rest of the eurozone should adopt. Back in the early 2000s it had a higher rate of unemployment than France. Furthermore, it cannot afford to pay to keep the single currency going if that means underwriting a much larger part of the eurozone's debts.

I'll come to the financial numbers in a moment. First consider the key weakness of Germany: its demography. German public debt is 80 per cent of GDP, within a few percentage points of that of France, the US and UK. True, its private debt is much lower than the UK's, but this has to be serviced by the taxes of a declining workforce.

The US and UK, and to a lesser extent France, still have rising populations. Germany's workforce is already shrinking and its overall population is expected to fall in the next few years. By 2050 it is projected that Germany will have a population of some 72 million, against its present 82 million. Indeed, some estimates suggest that it will have a smaller population than the UK. Among the large European economies only Italy faces as serious an issue.

From a debt point of view this is very important: keeping debt service costs down because Germany, unlike the UK, already has a shrinking tax base.

Let's look at the numbers, which come from some work by Capital Economics.

The first graph shows the extreme levels to which 10-year bond yields have risen for Greece and Portugal and, to a lesser extent, Ireland. It also shows the similar yield on eurozone debt if it were averaged out, with Germany in particular pulling the rate down. Since the average rate has not risen over the past four years it is argued that Europe as a whole is still seen as a credit-worthy borrower.

Now look at the second graph. This shows the theoretical saving the weaker countries could make were they able to borrow at the average rate – the winners, so to speak, from eurobonds. This assumes their entire debt were redesignated as eurobonds. It also shows the losers, with Germany at the head, but the Netherlands, Finland, France and Austria also doing badly. Greece would save 15 per cent of its GDP a year if it could finance itself at 4 per cent a year, the rough, weighted average of the eurozone. By contrast, Germany's financing costs would rise by only 2.5 per cent a year.

Well that is the theoretical case for burden-sharing. But there are problems with it. For a start, that 4 per cent rate is the current rate, at a time when bond yields of major developed countries are at an all-time low. We have just had a 30-year bull market in bonds. Historically we should now expect a 30-year bear market to begin pretty soon. So that yield rationally cannot be expected to stay as low as 4 per cent.

Secondly, 2.5 per cent of GDP for Germany is huge. We are talking of €50bn (£40bn) a year. How would we cope in Britain if we had to tighten fiscal policy by another £40bn a year over and above the present cuts and tax increases?

Third, what if the very fact that Germany was taking on huge, but almost unquantifiable additional liabilities, undermined its present safe-haven status? My instinct is that if eurobonds were indeed introduced, this would draw attention to the implicit guarantees that Germany has already been giving to the rest of the eurozone via the European Central Bank. By adding new explicit guarantees to the existing implicit ones, Germany's safe-haven status would come under serious pressure.

And finally, while eurobonds could in theory at least help solve the debt problems of the fringe countries that are unable to borrow at sustainable rates, they would do nothing to solve the competitiveness problem within Europe.

Several countries need to reduce their costs by a third or more, a scale of adjustment that has never been achieved in a democracy without a devaluation – which in this case means leaving the eurozone.

The big thing to realise here is that these bond market conditions are not normal. Bond yields are lower than at any time in the 19th century, lower than in the 1930s, lower than the long squeeze after the Second World War. Therefore, they won't last.

And if long-term interest rates are bound to rise, bundling together good creditors with bad ones is a toxic policy. The harsh truth is that even Germany – prosperous, organised, secure Germany – is just not rich enough to save the eurozone.

Arts and Entertainment
'A voice untroubled by time': Kate Bush
musicReview: A preamble, then a coup de théâtre - and suddenly the long wait felt worth it
Life and Style
Cooked up: reducing dietary animal fat might not be as healthy as government advice has led millions of people to believe
healthA look at how governments started advising incorrectly on diets
peopleJustin Bieber accuses papparrazzi of acting 'recklessly' after car crash
Life and Style
Roger Federer is greeted by Michael Jordan following his victory over Marinko Matosevic
tennisRoger Federer gets Michael Jordan's applause following tweener shot in win over Marinko Matosevic
Arts and Entertainment
Oppressive atmosphere: the cast of 'Tyrant'
tvIntroducing Tyrant, one of the most hotly anticipated dramas of the year
Life and Style
Ukrainian Leonid Stadnik, 37, 2.59 meter (8,5 feet) tall, the world's tallest living man, waves as he poses for the media by the Chevrolet Tacuma car presented to him by President of Ukraine Viktor Yushchenko in Kiev on March 24, 2008.
newsPeasant farmer towered at almost 8'5'' - but shunned the limelight
Walter Matthau and Jack Lemmon in ‘The Front Page’, using an old tech typewriter
Life and Style
Could a robot sheepdog find itself working at Skipton Auction Mart?
techModel would allow robots to be programmed to control crowds and save people from burning buildings
ebooksAn evocation of the conflict through the eyes of those who lived through it
Arts and Entertainment
Suha Arraf’s film ‘Villa Touma’ (left) is set in Ramallah and all the actresses are Palestinian
Angel Di Maria poses with Louis van Gaal after signing for Manchester United
sportWinger arrives from Real Madrid and could make debut on Saturday
Arts and Entertainment
Kingston Road in Stockton is being filmed for the second series of Benefits Street
arts + entsFilming for Channel 4 has begun despite local complaints
Arts and Entertainment
Hooked on classical: cellist Rachael Lander began drinking to combat panic attacks
musicThe cellist Rachael Lander’s career was almost destroyed by alcohol she drank to fight stage fright. Now she’s playing with Elbow...
Latest stories from i100
Have you tried new the Independent Digital Edition apps?
Independent Dating

By clicking 'Search' you
are agreeing to our
Terms of Use.

iJobs Job Widget
iJobs Money & Business

Client Services Executive / Account Executive - SW London

£23000 - £26000 per annum: Ashdown Group: Account Executive / Client Services ...

PA to CEO / Executive Secretary

£36000 - £38000 per annum: Ashdown Group: Executive PA to CEO & Executive Dire...

Generalist HR Administrator, Tunbridge Wells, Kent - £28,000.

£25000 - £28000 per annum: Ashdown Group: Generalist HR Administrator - Tunbri...

Senior C# Developer (.NET, C#, JMS, TDD, Web API, MVC, integrat

£45000 - £75000 per annum + benefits+bonus+package: Harrington Starr: Senior C...

Day In a Page

Kate Bush, Hammersmith Apollo music review: A preamble, then a coup de théâtre - and suddenly the long wait felt worth it

Kate Bush shows a voice untroubled by time

A preamble, then a coup de théâtre - and suddenly the long wait felt worth it
Robot sheepdog technology could be used to save people from burning buildings

The science of herding is cracked

Mathematical model would allow robots to be programmed to control crowds and save people from burning buildings
Tyrant: Is the world ready for a Middle Eastern 'Dallas'?

This tyrant doesn’t rule

It’s billed as a Middle Eastern ‘Dallas’, so why does Fox’s new drama have a white British star?
Rachael Lander interview: From strung out to playing strings

From strung out to playing strings

Award-winning cellist Rachael Lander’s career was almost destroyed by the alcohol she drank to fight stage fright. Now she’s playing with Elbow and Ellie Goulding
The science of saturated fat: A big fat surprise about nutrition?

A big fat surprise about nutrition?

The science linking saturated fats to heart disease and other health issues has never been sound. Nina Teicholz looks at how governments started advising incorrectly on diets
Emmys 2014 review: Can they genuinely compete with the Oscars

Can they genuinely compete with the Oscars?

The recent Emmy Awards are certainly glamorous, but they can't beat their movie cousins
On the road to nowhere: A Routemaster trip to remember

On the road to nowhere

A Routemaster trip to remember
Hotel India: Mumbai's Taj Mahal Palace leaves its darker days behind

Hotel India

Mumbai's Taj Mahal Palace leaves its darker days behind
10 best pencil cases

Back to school: 10 best pencil cases

Whether it’s their first day at school, uni or a new project, treat the student in your life to some smart stationery
Arsenal vs Besiktas Champions League qualifier: Gunners know battle with Turks is a season-defining fixture

Arsenal know battle with Besiktas is a season-defining fixture

Arsene Wenger admits his below-strength side will have to improve on last week’s show to pass tough test
Pete Jenson: Athletic Bilbao’s locals-only transfer policy shows success does not need to be bought

Pete Jenson: A Different League

Athletic Bilbao’s locals-only transfer policy shows success does not need to be bought
This guitar riff has been voted greatest of all time

The Greatest Guitar Riff of all time

Whole Lotta Votes from Radio 2 listeners
Britain’s superstar ballerina

Britain’s superstar ballerina

Alicia Markova danced... every night of the week and twice on Saturdays
Berlin's Furrie invasion

Berlin's Furrie invasion

2000 fans attended Eurofeurence
‘It was a tidal wave of terror’

‘It was a tidal wave of terror’

Driven to the edge by postpartum psychosis