Knowledge of a banana may be the key to Oxbridge entry

News in pictures
News in pictures
On Facebook
From the blogs

The future of academic publishing

These are the most uncertain times in living memory for academic publishing. After decades of bumpin...

Books with soundtracks: no, really, this one works…

Books with soundtracks. The idea is so glaringly obvious, and so obviously feeble, that I hesitate t...

Criminalising squatting: Is it worth it?

Squatters haven’t received the most glowing press over the past year. Various cases of displaced pro...

Would you be willing to profit from selling Nazi surgical equipment?

Imagine for a moment that, for whatever reason, you find yourself to be in possession of a case of m...

It is probably the most important day of your life. Your mind is racing and your hands are trembling at the thought of the erudite questions you are about to be asked, which will determine your future education, career and indeed the rest of your life. Then a man leans forward towards you and says: "Tell me about a banana."

Welcome to the world of university interviewing, Oxbridge-style. The banana question has been unearthed by Rachel Spedding and Jane Welsh, the editors of a new book designed to help would-be Oxford and Cambridge students cope with the notoriously arduous admissions process.

Other examples include: "Why isn't this chair acting as a wave?"(Chemistry, Oxford). And: "Estimate the number of pebbles on Brighton Beach. If a pebble was given to each person would there be enough for the entire population?" (Natural sciences, Cambridge).

"The key thing to it," the editors write, "is that there is seldom a right answer. You do not need an encyclopaedic memory to answer Oxbridge questions successfully, nor do you have to be a genius in the making.

"Oxbridge interview questions are designed to get applicants thinking laterally and logically and test how they use their existing knowledge, ascertaining whether the applicant will thrive, learning in the intimate environment of the tutorial or supervision system and whether the tutor will enjoy teaching them for the next three or potentially more years."

And so on to the next question. "If you leave the fridge turned on in a thermally isolated room, what happens to the room?" (Physics, Oxford).

More than 4,000 students who were interviewed for Oxbridge places last year were also questioned by the authors of the book, which is fittingly titled, So you want to go to Oxbridge? Tell me about a banana.

The editors conclude by posing three questions: "Can you be trained for cracking the Oxford and Cambridge admissions process? Can you copy what those who have done it successfully did and expect the same [sic: similar] results? So does this mean there is nothing you can do to prepare yourself?" The answer to all three, they say, is no.

Independent Comment
blog comments powered by Disqus

Day In a Page

The data goldmine: Why forgetting to log out can cost you dearly

Data goldmine: Have you forgotten to log out?

David Crookes finds out how much stolen Twitter accounts, hacked eBay pages and more are really worth.
The 10 best free games

The 10 best free games

From The Secret of Grisly Manor to Words With Friends...
Fear and loathing in London: The Death of Klinghoffer is staged in the capital for the first time

Fear and loathing in London: The Death of Klinghoffer

The ENO is staging the controversial opera in the capital for the first time
'Today, Rita could have signed up to Open University on Facebook'

'Rita could have signed up to Open University on Facebook'

The OU's famous fictional student wouldn't recognise the video-conferencing, social networking, flexible insitution it's grown into.
Kenya's coffee wars

Kenya's coffee wars

The boom in high-grade beans should be bringing rural Africa riches. Instead, it is fuelling a lethal crimewave
Billions of tons of water lost from world's glaciers, satellite reveals

Climate change

Billions of tons of water lost from world's glaciers, satellite reveals
Out of fashion: Designers finding new ways to sell their style

Out of fashion

Designers finding new ways to sell their style
James Lawton: Sadness and anger over the ultimate betrayal

James Lawton on Capello resignation

Sadness and anger over the ultimate betrayal
Tale of the trial: Laughter, anger... and bulldogs

Tale of the trial: Laughter, anger... and bulldogs

Redknapp's trial was the most remarkable and colourful case the modern game has seen. Sam Wallace, who was there for all 13 days, recounts the defining moments
Rhys Priestland: Praise for North star

Rhys Priestland: Praise for North star

The Wales No 10 may not be getting his kicks but he's not concerned... he plays with George North
Yayoi Kusama brings colour to Tate Modern

Colourful Yayoi Kusama

Japanese artist's retrospective at Tate Modern.
Church debate: Who'd be a bishop?

Church debate: Who'd be a bishop?

The General Synod debates women bishops again today. While they make up their minds, John Walsh weighs the palaces and puce robes against the political powerlessness
A tale of two cities: Portsmouth and London say happy birthday to Dickens

A tale of two cities

Portsmouth and London say happy birthday to Dickens
Pitch battle! Football league in Argentina renamed in honour of 'General Belgrano'

Pitch battle in Argentina!

Football league renamed in honour of 'General Belgrano'
Altar of Bones: A literary sensation – but who dunnit?

A literary sensation – but who dunnit?

The books world mulls over the identity of an acclaimed new author, but what drives writers to hide behind a nom de plume?