Matterhorn conqueror cleared over fatal falls

Edward Whymper's first ascent of the Matterhorn in 1865 ended in tragedy when four climbers died. The 132-year controversy over who was to blame may about to be laid to rest, reports Stephen Goodwin

As mountaineering accidents go, it was horribly ordinary. A slip at the wrong moment, and four men fell to their deaths, tumbling from rock to rock. But who was to blame?

Edward Whymper, the artist-engraver who became the most controversial figure of Victorian alpinism has been accused of causing the death of his four climbing companions as they attempted to master the Matterhorn in 1865, in one of the worst disasters ever seen on the peak.

Now a new 674-page guide to the accident and its aftermath says that Whymper has been judged wrongly.

Over the years the climbing fraternity has been split between those who say that Whymper displayed callous indifference to the deaths, and those who believe he avoided casting blame to spare the feelings of relatives. Whymper's enemies even suggested her accused the guides of wanting to murder him after the accident so they could enjoy the publicity of being the sole survivors. The new volume by Alan Lyall confirms Whymper's own account and concludes that much of the "unjustified" criticism levelled at him stemmed from his reluctance to cast blame.

The 4,477m Matterhorn rears like a challenge above the Swiss resort of Zermatt, beautiful but deadly. The Swiss slopes still claim lives: at least five climbers have been killed on the Matterhorn in the last month.

Its first ascent on 14 July 1865 marked the climax of the "Golden Age" of alpine mountaineering. Whymper, aged 25, and his companions beat an Italian team, climbing from their country's side, to the summit and in a display of triumphalism hurled rocks down on them.

"We remained on the summit for one hour - 'One crowded hour of glorious life'," wrote Whymper. But an hour or so later euphoria turned to despair as the ill-matched party descended snow and ice-covered rocks. It started with a slip by Douglas Haddow, a "gentle, simple-minded pious youth" who had done little climbing and even had difficulty descending Pen-y-ghent, a hill in Yorkshire. Haddow knocked over his aide and foot placer, the Chamonix guide Michel Croz; the next man up the rope, the Rev Charles Hudson was dragged from his feet and so, in turn, was Lord Francis Douglas, younger brother of the Marquess of Queensberry.

Above were the Zermatt guides Old Peter and Young Peter Taugwalder, father and son, and Whymper. The Englishman and Old Peter had planted themselves firmly to try and take the strain but the thinner rope Old Peter had tied between himself and Douglas broke midway between the two.

"For a few seconds we saw our unfortunate companions sliding on their backs, and spreading out their hands, endeavouring to save themselves. They passed from our sight uninjured, disappeared one by one, and fell from precipice to precipice on to the Matterhorngletscher (glacier) below, a distance of nearly 4,000 feet in height. From the moment the rope broke it was impossible to help them," wrote Whymper.

Had the inferior "sashline" between Douglas and Old Peter not broken all seven would most likely have perished. Today it would be unusual for such a large party to rope together.

The rumour that the rope was cut was never regarded as credible by climbers - though guides in the rival French resort of Chamonix seized on it as propaganda. But the rope, and the questions that were never asked about it at the official inquiry, form an intriguing part of Alan Lyall's study, entitled, with a touch of gallows humour, The First Descent of the Matterhorn.

Attempts to "play down" the circumstances of the accident lest blame attach to local guides and damage the reputation of Zermatt have left the smell of a cover-up. "Coroner" Joseph Clemenz owned the town's largest hotel and asked no searching questions. Whymper's own written questions were mistranslated and the evidence was not revealed to either him or the Swiss press. Whymper thought this "suppression of the truth" served neither the "travellers" - the English climbers - nor the guides. "If the men were untrustworthy, the public should have been warned of the fact; but if they were blameless, why allow them to remain under unmerited suspicion?"

Lyall's painstaking translation of inquiry documents and reassessment of the welter of letters and written accounts has highlighted not only the shortcomings of the inquiry, but the calumnies heaped on Whymper by a succession of writers.

Arnold Lunn, a great ski-mountaineer and father of the ski industry, railed at his "bogus pretence of scrupulous partiality". Lunn accused him of ruining Old Peter's reputation as a guide and, embellishing misinformation, invented the notion that Whymper accused the Taugwalders of plotting to murder him.

Though Lyall regards Whymper as a sensitive man and an honest chronicler, Whymper's disgust with the Taugwalders' behaviour after the accident is plain. In one of many letters, he expressed his "extreme dissatisfaction" with the pair. "They showed a most unmanly fear for their own lives, but directly we got to the easy part of the descent showed a heartlessness that was perfectly revolting."

In his 1870s bestseller Scrambles amongst the Alps, Whymper recorded that after the accident, the Taugwalders were paralysed with terror and "cried like infants". But later on the descent they began to worry over whether they would get paid - their patron, Douglas, was dead - and even suggested a ruse to add to their notoriety. The "murder charge" flowed from a memorandum in which he observed that "men who could view the loss of their fellow creatures with such commercial feelings as these, might not, possibly, be ill pleased if I also slipped". Whymper, in fact, paid Old Peter a record Sfr120 and his son Sfr80.

Lyall's encyclopaedic work is likely to reheat a mountaineering controversy that has never really grown cold since the day the rope broke 132 years ago.

The First Descent of the Matterhorn, by Alan Lyall, Gomer Press, Llandyssul, Ceredigion SA44 4BQ, pounds 45.

Suggested Topics
Arts and Entertainment
'A voice untroubled by time': Kate Bush
musicReview: A preamble, then a coup de théâtre - and suddenly the long wait felt worth it
Life and Style
Cooked up: reducing dietary animal fat might not be as healthy as government advice has led millions of people to believe
healthA look at how governments started advising incorrectly on diets
News
peopleJustin Bieber accuses papparrazzi of acting 'recklessly' after car crash
Life and Style
tech
PROMOTED VIDEO
Have you tried new the Independent Digital Edition apps?
News
ebooksAn evocation of the conflict through the eyes of those who lived through it
News
people
Voices
voices
Sport
Roger Federer is greeted by Michael Jordan following his victory over Marinko Matosevic
tennisRoger Federer gets Michael Jordan's applause following tweener shot in win over Marinko Matosevic
Arts and Entertainment
Oppressive atmosphere: the cast of 'Tyrant'
tvIntroducing Tyrant, one of the most hotly anticipated dramas of the year
News
i100
News
Ukrainian Leonid Stadnik, 37, 2.59 meter (8,5 feet) tall, the world's tallest living man, waves as he poses for the media by the Chevrolet Tacuma car presented to him by President of Ukraine Viktor Yushchenko in Kiev on March 24, 2008.
newsPeasant farmer towered at almost 8'5'' - but shunned the limelight
News
Walter Matthau and Jack Lemmon in ‘The Front Page’, using an old tech typewriter
media
Life and Style
Could a robot sheepdog find itself working at Skipton Auction Mart?
techModel would allow robots to be programmed to control crowds and save people from burning buildings
News
i100
Arts and Entertainment
Suha Arraf’s film ‘Villa Touma’ (left) is set in Ramallah and all the actresses are Palestinian
film
Sport
Angel Di Maria poses with Louis van Gaal after signing for Manchester United
sportWinger arrives from Real Madrid and could make debut on Saturday
Arts and Entertainment
Kingston Road in Stockton is being filmed for the second series of Benefits Street
arts + entsFilming for Channel 4 has begun despite local complaints
Arts and Entertainment
Hooked on classical: cellist Rachael Lander began drinking to combat panic attacks
musicThe cellist Rachael Lander’s career was almost destroyed by alcohol she drank to fight stage fright. Now she’s playing with Elbow...
Independent
Travel Shop
the manor
Up to 70% off luxury travel
on city breaks Find out more
santorini
Up to 70% off luxury travel
on chic beach resorts Find out more
sardina foodie
Up to 70% off luxury travel
on country retreats Find out more
Have you tried new the Independent Digital Edition apps?
Independent Dating
and  

By clicking 'Search' you
are agreeing to our
Terms of Use.

iJobs Job Widget
iJobs General

Organisational Change/ Transition Project Manager

£500 - £550 Per Day: Clearwater People Solutions Ltd: Our client are currently...

Head of IT (Not-for-Profit sector) - East Sussex

£45000 - £50000 per annum + 5 weeks holiday & benefits: Ashdown Group: Head of...

Accountacy Tutor

£100 - £120 per day: Randstad Education Bristol: Randstad Education is looking...

Generalist HR Administrator, Tunbridge Wells, Kent - £28,000.

£25000 - £28000 per annum: Ashdown Group: Generalist HR Administrator - Tunbri...

Day In a Page

Kate Bush, Hammersmith Apollo music review: A preamble, then a coup de théâtre - and suddenly the long wait felt worth it

Kate Bush shows a voice untroubled by time

A preamble, then a coup de théâtre - and suddenly the long wait felt worth it
Robot sheepdog technology could be used to save people from burning buildings

The science of herding is cracked

Mathematical model would allow robots to be programmed to control crowds and save people from burning buildings
Tyrant: Is the world ready for a Middle Eastern 'Dallas'?

This tyrant doesn’t rule

It’s billed as a Middle Eastern ‘Dallas’, so why does Fox’s new drama have a white British star?
Rachael Lander interview: From strung out to playing strings

From strung out to playing strings

Award-winning cellist Rachael Lander’s career was almost destroyed by the alcohol she drank to fight stage fright. Now she’s playing with Elbow and Ellie Goulding
The science of saturated fat: A big fat surprise about nutrition?

A big fat surprise about nutrition?

The science linking saturated fats to heart disease and other health issues has never been sound. Nina Teicholz looks at how governments started advising incorrectly on diets
Emmys 2014 review: Can they genuinely compete with the Oscars

Can they genuinely compete with the Oscars?

The recent Emmy Awards are certainly glamorous, but they can't beat their movie cousins
On the road to nowhere: A Routemaster trip to remember

On the road to nowhere

A Routemaster trip to remember
Hotel India: Mumbai's Taj Mahal Palace leaves its darker days behind

Hotel India

Mumbai's Taj Mahal Palace leaves its darker days behind
10 best pencil cases

Back to school: 10 best pencil cases

Whether it’s their first day at school, uni or a new project, treat the student in your life to some smart stationery
Arsenal vs Besiktas Champions League qualifier: Gunners know battle with Turks is a season-defining fixture

Arsenal know battle with Besiktas is a season-defining fixture

Arsene Wenger admits his below-strength side will have to improve on last week’s show to pass tough test
Pete Jenson: Athletic Bilbao’s locals-only transfer policy shows success does not need to be bought

Pete Jenson: A Different League

Athletic Bilbao’s locals-only transfer policy shows success does not need to be bought
This guitar riff has been voted greatest of all time

The Greatest Guitar Riff of all time

Whole Lotta Votes from Radio 2 listeners
Britain’s superstar ballerina

Britain’s superstar ballerina

Alicia Markova danced... every night of the week and twice on Saturdays
Berlin's Furrie invasion

Berlin's Furrie invasion

2000 fans attended Eurofeurence
‘It was a tidal wave of terror’

‘It was a tidal wave of terror’

Driven to the edge by postpartum psychosis