Goodie turns baddie as viewers protest at Oddie's 'X-rated' wildlife commentary
Friday, 30 May 2008
For the millions of viewers who tune in every week, the BBC's Springwatch, fronted by the former Goodie Bill Oddie, has long been a beacon of prime-time decency. So it came as a shock to many when, earlier this week, the presenter used rather direct language when narrating sexual congress in the natural world.
Describing a mating scene between two sparrows, Oddie, 66, said: "The female is asking for it – and getting it, basically. She is doing that wing-fluttering think like that as if to say: 'I am a baby, feed me'... [and] is getting quite the opposite." He concluded the piece by saying: "That's a wing-trembler she's just had there."
An item on beetles reignited the sensitivities of some viewers. Describing the sexual congress taking place in front of viewers' eyes, Oddie abandoned euphemism altogether. "He crash-lands on top of a likely looking lady – there's a bit of luck! One thing's for sure: this boy is horny!"
Then, as the male fought off a competing suitor for the right to mate, Oddie went into character, adopting the part of the female and saying in a high-pitched voice: "Come on big boy, come and get it. Oh, be gentle with me!"
Viewers reacted with outrage. One man complained: "I am sick to death of the constant innuendo being offered by Bill every time a scene of mating appears.
"It isn't funny or witty... just downright embarrassing when you are watching it with children. For example, being asked by my 10-year-old daughter: 'What does horny mean, daddy?' when watching mating beetles isn't right.
"I would never try to stop her understanding how animals reproduce, but commentary such as: 'She got more than she bargained for', and: 'He has his wicked way' isn't called for, and I am considering stopping her watching it."
Another viewer said: "This is schoolboy sniggering, behind-the-bike-sheds type humour and it's out of place in a programme that is otherwise marvellously educational for all age groups."
Oddie, who came to fame in the 1970s as one of comedy trio The Goodies, has been a keen birdwatcher since his childhood.
The BBC commented that many viewers endorsed the "light-hearted view" of Springwatch and Oddie. "The programme is always looking at new, creative and entertaining ways of bringing nature to a wider audience. Storytelling is one of many ways of doing this. No offence was intended."
Birds do it, bees do it... Oddie's mating commentary
On sparrows:
'The female is asking for it – and getting it. That's a wing-trembler she's just had'
On beetles:
'He lands on a likely looking female. One thing's for sure – this boy's horny!'
Click here to watch the episode of Springwatch which prompted the complaints
-
Print Article
-
Email Article
-
Click here for copyright permissions
Copyright 2008 Independent News and Media Limited

Comments
14 Comments
Honestly, what's all the fuss about? There are far worse programmes young children could be watching of an evening, and if there were no puns such as the beetle gag, Springwatch wouldn't be the same! The light entertainment element of the programme is what sets Springwatch apart from other nature documentaries; it makes it more accessible and enjoyable for everyone. I don't believe for a second that there can possibly have been that many complaints- and if you don't like it, then for heaven's sake just stop watching it! Also, to this comment:
'Maybe they should just turn the camera away to preserve the beetles and birds modesty, with Oddie not making any comment on the horrible business that is reproduction.'
Posted by John
how can you say that the act that brought us all into existence is 'horrible'?
Oddie is an excellent, entertaining and inspiring presenter and I hope he continues to host the programme for a long time to come.
Posted by Jamie Males | 03.06.08, 14:46 GMT
For Goodness sake!Stop making a fuss, springwatch is probably one of the best things on.Its all about nature and i think its excellent for children to watch.Bill is great and funny and makes Springwatch even better.He is making our world greener and loves and help animals and the environment!Bill is FANTASTIC so stop critisizing whats a brilliant, funny, educational, enjoyable program!
Posted by Sarah | 01.06.08, 20:34 GMT
I love springwatch and think Bill is inspiering.I think people should stop insulting him.He is an excellent presenter and loves wildlife.On the beetle part of the program, he actually said he did not write the script and anyway he is only trying to make the program entertaining and funny.I thnik veiwers should stop making a fuss and realise how great Bill is!
Posted by Kate Wathetr | 01.06.08, 20:23 GMT
For goodness sake, get real! If your ten year old is asking "what does horny mean Daddy", then take this golden opportunity to educate. Switch off the tv and get into important family time by explaining the facts of life. Obviously is it easier to write and complain to the BBC!
Posted by Janet Grundy | 01.06.08, 11:11 GMT
Yes I agree with the viewer who said Bill Oddie's remarks were quite unnecessary. It is not as you suggest 'a light hearted view of the subject in question' but a lack of thought to who is watching the programme. I think it is incorrect to make remarks that children cannot understand and having to define "horny" is beyond the pale.
Might I suggest that Mr Oddie prepares his remarks somewhat before the programme. Perhaps he could anticipate what he might see and think quietly what he could say in a language that offends nobody. No viewer wishes I'm sure to curtail his wonderful insight into country life but just please contemplate a little on his off the cuff remarks - before the filming of the programmes which Mums, Dads, Grandparents & children etc all thoroughly enjoy.l
Posted by Pam Lee | 31.05.08, 13:55 GMT
Hi All,
In today's print edition this caption appeared next to a photograph of two sparrows attempting to mate.
'The female is asking for it – and getting it. That's a wing-trembler she's just had'
The photograph was of two males!
What would Bill say if he knew?
Posted by Steve Bramley | 30.05.08, 21:07 GMT
Oddie's constant interruption and juvenile sense of humour has put me off watching what should be an intreresting programme,
Posted by E Roberts
There's a button on the remote control, and on some televisions, that lets you control the level of sound the aforementioned device outputs. I would suggest you use it to turn the level down to zero if Oddies commentary bothers you so much. There, problem solved.
Posted by sinister dexter | 30.05.08, 18:59 GMT
For goodness sake....
Open your minds and take it as it is meant to be..which is lighthearted towards what has made all of us...SEX SEX SEX.
Sex is the most natural,beautiful and wonderful thing to mankind and animals,without it we would not be hear.
It is only dirty to those who think it is,and if you cannot find a way to describe what HORNY is on a beetle who has horns,then the problem is in your mind.
Stay ON TOP Bill Oddie.
Posted by H Keddie | 30.05.08, 16:13 GMT
For heaven's sake - perhaps four people commented 'in outrage'. The 'horny' was referring to the stag beetle's long antler-like pincers - it's called a PUN. If children don't know the facts of life, why are they watching a nature program where things like that happen day in day out - especially in spring. Try and find something more relavant to report about - perhaps how springwatch is doing such a good job in making people 'get out there' and really working to transform this country into a greener place.
Posted by Claire Robertson | 30.05.08, 15:43 GMT
Bill Oddie is a national treasure. His comments are typical of his sense of humour, and the tension between his style and co-presenter Kate Humble's is what makes the show so fresh.
I really can't understand why such prissy people as the complainers must surely be, think that their views are worthy of publicity. Britain is a bawdy country, and folks ought to cherish this.
Posted by Jim Friday | 30.05.08, 15:17 GMT
14 Comments