LAW REPORT: Company's liability was for breach of covenant

LAW REPORT 25 August 1995

Barclays Bank plc and others v British and Commonwealth Holdings plc; Court of Appeal (Lord Justice Kennedy, Lord Justice Aldous and Sir Roger Parker) 28 July 1995

To decide whether, by virtue of section 178(2) of the Companies Act 1985, a company was excused liability to pay damages for failing to redeem its own shares, the court should ask itself whether the damages were claimed because of the failure to redeem. Where, in fact, the damages were claimed in respect of the breach of a covenant in an option agreement, the section did not preclude liability.

The Court of Appeal dismissed an appeal by the defendants, British and Common- wealth Holdings plc (B & C), against a ruling by Mr Justice Harman, sitting in the Chancery Division on 14 November 1994, in favour of the plaintiffs, Barclays Bank plc, Banque Paribas, Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corporation Ltd, Royal Bank of Scotland plc, Standard Chartered Bank, Creditanstalt-Bankverein, and Tindalk Ltd.

The proceedings arose out of the collapse of B & C in 1990. In 1987 it had entered into a scheme, sanctioned by the court, to enable Caledonia Investments Ltd to divest itself of 90 million ordinary stock units which Caledonia held in B & C. Under the scheme, B & C would buy back some of the stock units at once and would cancel the remainder in exchange for the issue to Caledonia of new redeemable preference shares in B & C. These were to be redeemed at a preset price in four tranches on 31 December of each of the years 1988 to 1991 at the wish of either Caledonia or B & C. If B & C failed to redeem any tranche of shares, Caledonia had the right to sell them at the same price to Tindalk Ltd, a company formed for this purpose and financed by the six plaintiff banks.

B & C covenanted with the six banks that it would conduct its affairs so as to maintain certain asset rates. Any breach of covenant would give rise to a claim in damages by the banks against B & C. In 1988 and 1989 B & C duly redeemed the first two tranches of Caledonia's preference shares.

But in 1990 B & C was placed in administration and the last two tranches of preference shares were not redeemed. Caledonia therefore exercised its right to require Tindalk to purchase them. Tindalk was provided with finance to do so by the six banks. Since the shares were unlikely to be of any value, the banks were unlikely to recover their loans. They therefore sued B & C for damages for breach of covenant. B & C relied on section 178(2) of the 1985 Act: "The company is not liable in damages in respect of any failure on its part to redeem or purchase any of [its] shares."

William Stubbs QC and Sir Thomas Stockdale (Wilde Sapte) for the defendants; Robin Potts QC and Christopher Butcher (Clifford Chance) for the plaintiffs.

Lord Justice Aldous said thatto decide whether a company was excused liability to pay damages, the court should ask itself whether there had been a failure to redeem and, if so, whether the damages were claimed in respect of that failure, in the sense of being damages recoverable because of the failure to redeem. The loose connection or relationship for which B & C contended was insufficient. The damages claimed by the plaintiffs in this case were in respect of breaches of covenants in the option agreement and not in respect of the failure to redeem. Section 178(2) therefore did not exclude the claim.

B & C also relied on section 151 of the 1985 Act, under which it was unlawful for a company to give a person direct or indirect financial assistance to enable that person to acquire shares in the company. The option agreement and in particular the covenants were said by B & C to constitute "financial assistance" for the purpose of either Caledonia's or Tindalk's acquisition of the preference shares.

In his Lordship's judgment the purpose of the covenants in the option agreement was to reassure Caledonia. The fact that breach of the covenants might render B & C liable in damages did not mean that it gave financial assistance thereby. Section 151 also, therefore, did not preclude the plaintiffs' claims.

Lord Justice Kennedy and Sir Roger Parker agreed.

Paul Magrath, Barrister

Have you tried new the Independent Digital Edition iPad app?
Independent Dating
and  

By clicking 'Search' you
are agreeing to our
Terms of Use.

iJobs Job Widget
iJobs People

SharePoint Administrator/Developer (C#, VB.NET, VISUAL STUDIO 2

£35000 - £50000 per annum + benefits+bonus+package: Harrington Starr: SharePoi...

European HR Director, London

£80000 - £95000 per annum: Charter Selection: A leading Global organisation Ja...

European Senior HR Manager, London

£80000 - £90000 per annum: Charter Selection: A leading Global organisation is...

Day In a Page

Homelessness: Why is the supported lodgings lifeline under threat?

Why is the supported lodgings lifeline under threat?

Zubairi Sentongo swapped poverty in Uganda for homelessness in Britain. But a YMCA scheme connected him with a couple offering warmth and shelter
A History of the First World War in 100 Moments: When the world’s biggest shed took over Regent’s Park

A History of the First World War in 100 Moments

When the world’s biggest shed took over Regent’s Park
The pain of IVF

The pain of IVF

As an Italian woman vows to keep the babies from someone else’s eggs, Julian Baggini ponders how the reality of childbirth is often messier than the natural ideal
Supersize art

Is big better? Britain's latest super-sized art

The Kelpies are the latest addition to a growing army of giant sculptures. But naysayers are asking what a pair of gigantic horse heads tells us about Falkirk?
James Dean: Back on the big screen

James Dean: Back on the big screen

As 'Rebel without a Cause' is re-released, Geoffrey Macnab reveals how its star perfected his moody act
Catch-22: How the cult classic was adapted for the stage

How a cult classic was adapted for the stage

More than half a century after it was published 'Catch-22' will make its British stage debut next week
10 best activity books for children

10 best activity books for children

Keep little ones busy this bank holiday with one of these creative, educational and fun books
Arsenal 3 West Ham United 1: Five things we learnt from the battle between the London sides

Five things we learnt from Arsenal's win over West Ham

Arsenal still in driving seat for Champions League spot and Carroll can make late charge into England’s World Cup squad
Copa del Rey final: Barcelona are paying for their complacency and not even victory over Real Madrid will put things right

Pete Jenson on the Copa del Rey final

Barcelona are paying for their complacency and not even victory over Real Madrid will put things right
Rafa to reign? Ten issues clay courts will serve up this season

Rafa to reign? Ten issues clay courts will serve up this season

With the tennis circus now rolling on to the slowest surface, Paul Newman highlights who'll be making the headlines – and why
Exclusive: NHS faces financial disaster in 2015 as politicians urged to find radical solution

NHS faces financial disaster in 2015

Politicians urged to find radical solution
Ukraine crisis: How spontaneous are the pro-Russian protests breaking out in Ukraine’s east?

Ukraine crisis

How spontaneous are the pro-Russian protests breaking out in Ukraine’s east?
A History of the First World War in 100 moments: The first execution at the Tower of London for 167 years

The first execution at the Tower of London for 167 years

A history of the First World War in 100 moments
Fires could turn Amazon rainforest into a desert as human activity and climate change threaten ‘lungs of the world’, says study

New threat to the Amazon rainforest:

Fires that scorch the ‘lungs of the Earth’
Liverpool, Chelsea and Manchester City: And the winner of this season’s Premier League title will be...

Who’s in box seat now? The winner of the title will be ...

Who is in best shape to take the Premier League prize?