Christopher Hitchens attacks Gore Vidal for being a 'crackpot'
Former protégé takes America's great man of letters to task for adopting 9/11 conspiracy theories
Sunday 07 February 2010
Latest in News
On Facebook
From the blogs
John Terry: How Sarah Palin got it right
It's been a notable week for the loss of titles: first Fred Goodwin, formerly a knight of the realm,...
The bitter taste of sugar prohibition
On Thursday, high-profile science journal Nature published a commentary by three academics, which ar...
The fight over the Port Said football narrative has already begun
It is a year to the day since the infamous camel charge during the Egyptian uprising. That day, Ultr...
Don’t be distracted by Goodwin’s dishonour
The purpose is to divert public attention from the fact that ministers have failed to do anything ab...
As literary feuds go it has the all the hallmarks of a classic. In one corner, the journalist and polemicist Christopher Hitchens. In the other, America's great man of letters, Gore Vidal.
The latest salvo is in this month's Vanity Fair where, in an article headlined "Vidal Loco", Hitchens launches a stinging attack on Vidal, claiming that the events of 9/11 "accentuated a crackpot strain" in the author. He claims that Vidal's work after the terrorist attacks consists of "a small anthology of half-argued and half-written shock pieces [which] either insinuated or asserted that the administration had known in advance of the attacks."
"He openly says that the Bush administration was 'probably' in on the 9/11 attacks, a criminal complicity that would 'certainly fit them to a T'; that Timothy McVeigh was 'a noble boy', no more murderous than generals Patton and Eisenhower; and that 'Roosevelt saw to it that we got that war' by inciting the Japanese to attack Pearl Harbor," Hitchens writes.
Vidal's reaction to the Vanity Fair article is not yet known. But yesterday, a British academic, who was also criticised by Hitchens, leapt to the author's defence. Dr Nafeez Mosaddeq Ahmed, of Sussex University, described Hitchens' attack as "extraordinarily vitriolic". He claimed there was a "sense of jealousy he never did quite get to Gore's level of literary flair and his almost iconic status. It does seem like a kind of bizarre personal vendetta being carried out on the pages of Vanity Fair, replete with factual inaccuracies and not very much substance."
Dr Ahmed, director of the London-based think tank the Institute for Policy Research and Development, claimed Hitchens failed to contextualise Vidal's comments.
"Hitchens has taken them very literally and Gore is being much more playful and much more provocative," Dr Ahmed said.
Vidal was not trying to absolve the Oklahoma City bomber, McVeigh, he added, but to make people think critically.
Hitchens referred to Dr Ahmed, who wrote The War on Freedom, used by the 9/11 Commission, in the article as a "risible individual wedded to half-baked conspiracy-mongering". Dr Ahmed said he had not suggested there was a conspiracy, rather a "dereliction of duty", and that he used the word "complicity" in a legal sense.
Hitchens wrote that he did not mind Vidal rewriting their personal history, after the American publicly distanced himself from Hitchens, but he did object "to the crank-revisionist and denialist history he is now peddling about everything else".
Hitchens claims in the article that Vidal once wrote to him offering to nominate him as his "dauphin". Such was Hitchens' admiration for Vidal that he asked to use a letter from the 85-year-old author on the jacket of his books. But since the 9/11 attacks he has stopped the practice.
But last October, Vidal told a New York audience: "Hitchens identified himself for many years as the heir to me ... unfortunately, for him, I didn't die."
Hitchens was unavailable for comment.
- 1 Drums of war beat louder as Iran and Israel step up rhetoric
- 2 Did Banksy's latest work bring misery to a homeless man?
- 3 Cheerleader must compensate school that told her to clap 'rapist'
- 4 The picture that shames Italy
- 5 Khmer Rouge jail chief gets life for his 'factory of death'
- 6 Zante, bloody Zante: Sun, sex and the dark side of The Med
- 7 Europe is too emotional about fracking, says Shell chief
- 1 Cheerleader must compensate school that told her to clap 'rapist'
- 2 Did Banksy's latest work bring misery to a homeless man?
- 3 Europe is too emotional about fracking, says Shell chief
- 4 The picture that shames Italy
- 5 Get fit the Djokovic way (it is as hard as it sounds)
- 6 Mona Lisa's 'twin sister' is discovered – 500 years late
- 7 The artist vandalising advertising with poetry
- 8 I don't want to go to Brighton
- 9 Party days are over for students
- 10 In the thick of a new satire: Peter Capaldi on his new foray into gentle comedy
Free trial of new Independent iPad app
Get your daily dose of the best of British journalism, sponsored by American Airlines
Win a three-week coastal jaunt
Spend three weeks exploring every nook and cranny of gorgeous Atlantic Canada.
Amazing restaurant offers
Three glasses of free champagne and a special menu at 46 top London restaurants.
Latest Independent competitions
Win anything from gadgets to five-star holidays on our competitions and offers page.
Commercial thought leaders
Watch the best in the business world give their insights into the world of business.
Day In a Page
The $18bn family feud
What happens when an uncontacted tribe meets 'civilisation'?
Divine duck: Mark Hix cooks with the most succulent of birds
On the waterfront: Frank Meadow Sutcliffe's Whitby

Comments