Science

Showers (AM and PM) 6° London Hi 10°C / Lo 6°C

Don't mock, this bird really can tell humans apart

By Steve Connor, Science Editor

A mockingbird grazes a woman's head in an attempt to drive her away from its nest in Florida

LOU GUILETTE

A mockingbird grazes a woman's head in an attempt to drive her away from its nest in Florida

A species of songbird has been shown to identify individual people in a crowd in order to target them aggressively if they pose a threat to their nests. North American mockingbirds can distinguish between individual men and women out of many thousands based on whether they have a history of getting too near to their nests, a study has found.

It is the first time that anyone has shown that wild birds are able to tell people apart and is one of the rare examples of one species being able to distinguish between individual members of another species, scientists said.

The mockingbirds in the study quickly learnt to identify people who regularly came too close to their nests on a busy university campus populated by thousands of passing students. The birds responded to further encroachments by screeching, dive bombing and sometimes grazing the heads of the intruders.

However, this extreme aggression was limited to those people who had already come too close to the birds' nests on two previous occasions. First-time human intruders were treated with far less aggression, the scientists found.

"We tend to view all mockingbirds as equal, but the feeling is not mutual. Mockingbirds certainly do not view all humans as equal," said Professor Doug Levey of the University of Florida in Gainesville, who led the study published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

"We do not believe mockingbirds evolved an ability to distinguish between humans. Mockingbirds and humans haven't been living in close association long enough for that to occur. We think that our experiments reveal an underlying ability to be incredibly perceptive of everything around them, and to respond appropriately when the stakes are high," Professor Levey said.

Post a Comment

View all comments that have been posted about this article.

Offensive or abusive comments will be removed and your IP logged and may be used to prevent further submission. In submitting a comment to the site, you agree to be bound by the Independent Minds Terms of Service.

Comments

bird brained humans
[info]jaffgyp wrote:
Tuesday, 19 May 2009 at 07:48 am (UTC)
i am sick of reading ever more stories about amazing animals which can actually think - of course they can, of course they are intelligent, and of course they are more intelligent than a lot of humans; where do all the dum dum gee whiz journalists get their blinkered homo-centric ideas from?
Re: bird brained humans
[info]philgibson wrote:
Tuesday, 19 May 2009 at 09:56 pm (UTC)
Agreed. Even if this was a cause for a shift in how we look at animals, this isn't a first or as much of a rarety as these 'scientists' claim:

"It is the first time that anyone has shown that wild birds are able to tell people apart and is one of the rare examples of one species being able to distinguish between individual members of another species, scientists said."

I remember a car park attendant being in the news years ago, for being repeatedly attacked and bombed by a single pigeon. The pigeon seemingly found it entertaining, and kept coming back again and again for a number of months. He was the pigeon's only target.

Also, it's clear that dogs and cats can distinguish between humans and domesticated animals of other species. The same applies to other pets, including birds. If a domesticated bird can tell two humans apart, why couldn't a wild one?

Humans are special, but not in terms of such basic thought processes.
Incredibly perceptive birds
[info]exportskip wrote:
Tuesday, 19 May 2009 at 09:46 am (UTC)
People are so full of themselves to think that they represent something supremely special in evolution. It's not enough that millions of years of evolution have produced the wonder that is the modern human, people seem to think that the modern human has been the sole beneficiary of a gigantic, magical leap in addition to evolution that makes it so far better developed and eternally special than any other creature on the planet. Of course other creatures have evolved intelligence. How arrogant to believe that we are so superior to and more deserving than our fellow creatures.
Re: Incredibly perceptive birds
[info]corporeal4now wrote:
Tuesday, 19 May 2009 at 04:58 pm (UTC)

Easy tiger. The birds ability to recognise individuals doesnt mean, you'll be called over for a cup of tea and an indepth chat about the expenses reforms anytime soon.
Tell me how far is too close find out that they are not mating then eavesdrop to their sex talks.
[info]famulla wrote:
Tuesday, 19 May 2009 at 11:39 am (UTC)
A mockingbird grazes a woman's head (may be the hair needs a wash) in an attempt to drive her away from its nest in Florida
Don't mock, this bird really can tell humans apart. CRAZY. Woman to peep in the nest. Why do we look at the naked birds?
However, this extreme aggression was limited to those people who had already come too close to the birds' nests on two previous occasions. First-time human intruders were treated with far less aggression, the scientists found.
I will not laugh nor cry. Tell me how far is too close to the birds' nests on two previous occasions.
What you are telling me that we look in the nest, find out that they are not mating then eavesdrop to their sex talks.
However, that we do the same. We do not want anyone to look at our naked bodies and see our private parts that are circumcised, the hot topic today.
I agree to the humans right but will you tell me where are the bird?s right? We have too many laws these days. U.S. to Issue Tougher Fuel Standards for Automobiles
I like the photo that is the entire article is like Willy the Dauphine and more stupid birds there are good for roasting.
"Any pop band is doing the same thing."
- JÖRN H. HURUM, a scientist at the University of Oslo, on the publicity
blitz surrounding a 47-million-year-old fossil soon to be
Exportskin, The bees are better and mosquitoes give income to the doctors.
I thank you
Firozali A Mulla
I feel the at the back ground there is a bat and bats love the wax of the ears of the women
[info]famulla wrote:
Wednesday, 20 May 2009 at 05:24 pm (UTC)
Now that I look at the picture magnified thousand times by the stethoscope, I feel the at the back ground there is a bat and bats love the wax of the ears of the women or the termites in the hair. Check this up and confirm. There is nothing to do with the listening. It is all pruning and picking the right insects without paying the barber.
I thank you
Firozali A.Mulla
birds of (human) prey
[info]thelatimes wrote:
Thursday, 21 May 2009 at 05:18 am (UTC)
"The Killer Mockingbird"?

Sorry, I couldn't resist.
Richard Nixon masks and gulls on Alcatraz
[info]aol1234aol wrote:
Friday, 29 May 2009 at 06:32 pm (UTC)
I very much doubt this is the first time scientists have shown birds can tell individuals apart. I heard of an experiment on Alcatraz (California) in which researchers used Richard Nixon masks to see if gulls could tell them apart, and thereafter anyone wearing a Richard Nixon mask caused quite a ruckus among the gulls. That was at least 10 years ago.

Most popular