The resurrection men

Surgeons have already brought frozen dogs back from the dead. Now they want to get their hands on us. Medical miracle - or zombie nightmare? Jimmy Lee Shreeve reports
Click to follow
The Independent Online

It was indeed an amazing story - which explained the tabloids' incredulity, and their interpretation of the discovery by scientists of the Safar Center for Resuscitation Research at the University of Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. It was reported that a New York Post journalist asked the director of the resuscitation centre, Dr Peter Kochanek, if he was "creating a race of zombie dogs fit for a Stephen King novel".

The team at Safar - which was founded by the late Peter Safar, who invented modern mouth-to-mouth resuscitation - weren't pleased at the frivolous coverage of their work.

The Safar scientists have developed a way to put the dogs into a hypothermia-like state - also known as suspended animation - which puts the animals' metabolism on hold. The process involves draining the dogs' veins of blood and then filling them with a near ice-cold salt solution, which lowers body temperature to 7C (usually 37C). They stop breathing and have no heartbeat or brain activity, so are considered clinically dead.

Three hours later, the dogs' blood is replaced and they are brought back to life with a gentle electric shock. The Safar scientists have since announced that they hope to test their hypothermic cooling techniques on humans and have gone as far as talking to hospitals about starting trials on emergency patients.

The aim is to buy time for people who have suffered massive blood loss through injury. They hope that soldiers wounded in the battle or people injured in car accidents or shootings could be preserved long enough to move them to a hospital, repair the damage and revive them.

"We hope to start trials [on humans] within a year," says Dr Samuel Tisherman, the associate director of the Safar Center. "We will probably focus on victims of penetrating trauma, such as gunshot or stab wounds, causing cardiac arrest. We'd try usual resuscitation attempts first and if we don't get anywhere, try suspended animation."

In using the hypothermic method, the human patient's blood would be drained and they would be flushed with a cold saline solution leaving them hovering in limbo between life and death.

"We've got a concept in emergency treatment called the 'golden hour'," says Dr Howard Champion, a British-born trauma surgeon based in the US. "This refers to the precious little time you have to get somebody who's bleeding to death to a hospital. The whole idea behind suspended animation or hypothermic cooling therapy is to buy extra time."

Injury is a major cause of death around the world, resulting in about eight million deaths a year. Forty to 50 per cent of these bleed to death. And 20 to 30 per cent of those, says Champion, bleed from injuries which, if treated in time, are fixable. "That's the target we're after with hypothermic cooling."

One of the most obvious applications is on the battlefield, which is why US defence agencies have provided funding for the Safar Center. According to Champion, medics would be alerted to wounded soldiers by sensors. "The sensors would tell us when a soldier has received an impact of a given level of kinetic energy and may have injuries that could cause fatal bleeding. We would pick up the soldier and put him through the hypothermic process, giving him a much greater chance of survival."

Even more futuristic sounding, the Pentagon recently awarded $12m (£7m) in grants to develop an unmanned "trauma pod" that would turn a drone (unmanned aerial vehicle) into an air ambulance. It would swoop down on an injured soldier, run X-rays and CT scans and even perform full scalpel-and-stitch surgery with robotic arms controlled by remote medics.

Such advanced vehicles are at least a decade away, so hypothermic cooling therapy is likely to be another of the technologies built into the trauma pod.

In the civilian world, the benefits of hypothermic cooling could be huge for people involved in accidents or violence. "It would have a big impact on the survival rates of people with traumatic injuries sustained from road accidents and gunshot or stab wounds," says Mark Voelker, a scientist at California-based BioTime Inc, another organisation experimenting with hypothermic cooling.

"Now, when emergency crews find an injured person lying in the street with their heart stopped, there may be little they can do. But if hypothermic cooling apparatus were on hand in ambulances, they could put a patient's metabolism on hold by cooling them down and then make attempts to stabilise them. The crew would then have a couple of hours to get the injured person to hospital."

Voelker sees hypothermic cooling as a way to push back the boundaries of death. "The definition of death depends on the technology you have to revive the subject," he says. "As medical technology gets better, the limits to being dead are pushed into more extreme physiological states. Death is really when a doctor says: 'I can't do any more.'"

In the Safar Center's experiments, not all the dogs came out unscathed - a few suffered serious physical and behavioural problems. Champion says this is to be expected: "You can never make a smooth transition from one environment to another. There will always be bugs to be ironed out."

But some people believe issues arise from the fact of being clinically dead for long periods. They worry that, if the procedure is used on humans, they may wake up without souls.

Ross Heaven, author of Vodou Shaman, says: "What the scientists are doing has parallels with the zombie experience in Haiti, where voodoo priests administer tetrodotoxin [a powerful nerve poison derived from puffer fish] and plant mixtures. This slows the body and sends the subject into a semi-comatose state. They are then buried for a few days and dug up in a big show.

"But they are not whole afterwards. According to voodoo practitioners, they're in a zombie state because their souls are missing. So it wouldn't come as a surprise to some that a few of these dogs displayed freaky behaviour after being clinically dead for three hours.

"Maybe, if the same technique is used on humans, you could justifiably wonder whether they would come back to life with an essential part of them missing," Heaven says.

The Church of England doesn't believe there is a risk to the soul. "From our point of view, there isn't an issue about the person coming back to life or not," a Church press officer said. "Clearly, if you can be brought back to life you aren't completely dead. We regard many new medical technologies as an extension of God's care."

Susan Blackmore, a writer and visiting lecturer to the University of the West of England, has studied near-death experiences. "I'd expect that if you got this procedure right by making sure the person received the correct level of nutrients and oxygen, then the person would come back just as they were before," she says.

She concedes that a patient could claim to have had a near-death experience, but says this wouldn't prove anything. "Different parts of the brain respond in different ways when you come close to death because of their structure. Again, there is no need to invoke a soul. And I would guess that if people had this hypothermic procedure, some would have near-death experiences. But that would not show that a soul is leaving the body," Blackmore says.

Advocates of hypothermic cooling are understandably exasperated when spiritual issues arise. Champion insists: "This is not resurrection research."

But the wider issues will not go away. In fact, they'll run riot if the therapy is used on a human. When it is, as the BioTime scientist Mark Voelker points out: "We will be reading about the first ice-cold human." And you can bet we'll hear a lot more about zombies, too.

Comments