A lawyer representing Jersey abuse victims has said it was widely believed that Edward Heath was “implicated” in child sex abuse on the island – but that making a solid case against him was “like pinning down a jellyfish”.
Police in Jersey have confirmed that Sir Edward “does feature” in an ongoing inquiry into decades of abuse on the Crown dependency, making them one of five forces investigating allegations against the former Tory Prime Minister.
On Tuesday, a spokesperson for the inquiry said no evidence was provided in public or private during its hearings to suggest that children from the Haut de la Garenne orphanage were allowed to visit Sir Edward on his boat, the Morning Cloud.
Alan Collins, a sexual abuse litigation expert who represented Haut de la Garenne victims, told The Independent: “There were always hints, suggestions, but I never met anybody who actually said to me 'I was abused by Ted Heath' or 'I know someone who was'.
“There seems to have been this currency that somehow he was implicated, but it was always like pinning down a jellyfish – it was very elusive.”
Leah McGrath Goodman, a respected US journalist with Newsweek, has said she was banned from the UK for two years after she tried to investigate allegations of abuse surrounding Sir Edward in 2011. The Uk Border Agency has said her ban was unrelated to her work, according to the Daily Mail.
A financial reporter, she was researching Jersey’s function as a tax haven when, she says, she heard about the growing scandal and the island’s “culture where people were much more likely to look the other way”.
She told Sky News: "[Police officers investigating claims at the children's home] had heard the rumours and I know a few of the senior members of the police believed that [Sir Edward] was at it.
Edward Heath - Life in pictures
Edward Heath - Life in pictures
1/15 Edward Heath
Leader of the British Conservative Party Edward Heath tours his constituency during the general election campaign, 1966
2/15 Edward Heath
British Conservative Party politician and amateur musician, Edward Heath conducting the annual carol concert at the Grand Ballroom, Broadstairs, Kent, in December 1963
3/15 Edward Heath
Conservative Party leader Mr Edward Heath holds up with pride the new Conservative election manifesto entitled 'A Better Tomorrow' at a press conference in London, 1970
4/15 Edward Heath
British prime minister Edward Heath chatting with US president Richard Nixon at Chequers in Buckinghamshire
5/15 Edward Heath
British Prime Minister Edward Heath, skipper of the British team for the Admiral Cup Series with his team aboard the yacht 'Morning Cloud' at Southsea, Hampshire, 1971
6/15 Edward Heath
In 1974 the Conservative Prime Minister Edward Heath, left, was ousted from Downing Street when Harold Wilson, right, formed a minority Labour government
7/15 Edward Heath
Ted Heath leaves Downing Street to hand in his resignation, 1974
8/15 Edward Heath
British Prime Minister Edward Heath announces the date of the General Election, 1974
9/15 Edward Heath
Deposed Conservative party leader Edward Heath with his successor Margaret Thatcher, 1975
10/15 Edward Heath
Former Prime Minister Edward Heath at his home in 1975
11/15 Edward Heath
At the Conservative Party Conference (L-R), Mr Edward Heath, MP for Bexley, Mr Francis Pym, Leader of the House of Commons, and Mr William Whitelaw, Home Secretary, applaud a colleague's speech, 1981
12/15 Edward Heath
Edward Heath at his home in Salisbury in 1980s
13/15 Edward Heath
Edward Heath bids farwell to Chia Chia the panda, London Zoo, 1988
14/15 Edward Heath
British prime minister Sir Edward Heath, appearing before the US Senate armed committee on the situation in the Persian Gulf, 1990
15/15 Edward Heath
Sir Edward Heath arrives at No.10 Downing Street for a dinner hosted by Prime Minister Tony Blair in London, 2002
Among those who regularly visited the Haut de la Garenne home was the now-disgraced entertainer Jimmy Savile.
“Jimmy Savile often stayed in the same hotel as Ted Heath,” McGrath Goodman told the dpa news agency, adding that both men were alleged to have taken children from Haut de la Garenne.
Mr Collins, who is now representing victims in the broader inquiry into “what went wrong in the island’s care system over many years”, said Jersey Police need to be “a lot more candid and forward” now they have confirmed Sir Edward is involved in the investigation.
“The way they have allowed it to be reported currently is not fair on anybody,” he said. “I’ve had genuine victims phoning me up worried about whether they might have to speak to the police again.
“The police have got to be open – if he did things, committed crimes, they need to give us dates and locations so we know and people can come forward.
“On the other hand, if they are just tidying up their records and there are no new allegations then they should say so. He was our Prime Minister after all, and if it’s just a case of throwing it out there in case somebody new comes forward it’s wrong, that’s not the way to go about it.”