UK

5° London Hi 10°C / Lo 5°C

Celebrating diversity: Nuclear families? Not us!

Mum, Dad and 2.4 children? Our domestic affairs are far more varied than ever before, with only 36 per cent of us living in traditional units, compared with 52 per cent in 1971. Love, though, is the common bond

Interviews by Nina Lakhani, Andrew Johnson and Jonathan Owen

The single father

Quincy, 38, became a single father at the age of 25 after the mother of his two sons died suddenly. He lives in East Ham in east London with Kieran, 16, and Kadeem, 14. He also has a daughter, Diaz, eight, who lives with her mother.

When Judith died in 1996, I suddenly found myself living alone with two young boys, and I had to learn how to be a mum as well as a dad. She was only 23 and it made me think that I never wanted to grow old wondering, "What if?" For the first few years I was doing regular nine-to-five jobs, sorting out the kids when I got home, spending time with my parents and Judith's parents. But I was so bored that I did a comedy course and started doing some gigs. My parents are old-fashioned West Indian folk so giving up a regular job to be a comedian caused some tension, but it made me realise that I had to be a success because I had a family to look after. When their mum passed away I'd vowed that I would be the only role model that they would need: I wanted to show them that they can break away from stereotypes and achieve anything with the right support. I did my show Quincy Single Mum at Edinburgh because I wanted to show people that there are decent black guys out there, doing right by their families.

One son, two mothers

Zoe Ward, 31, and her partner Nick, 39, from Farnham, Surrey, have a three-year-old boy called Will.

We wanted him to be part of both of us, so we took my egg, fertilised it with a sperm donor, and my partner carried him. It cost £10,000, which we had to borrow. We'd been together for three years, and like in any relationship, we'd fallen in love and the next step was to have children.

Will understands that he's got two mums. He calls me Mum and Nick Mummy. So if I'm with him and someone asks if his mummy is there, he'll say no. We have two gay male friends who act as his father, and he knows them as Daddy. We think it's important for him to have a male influence and we don't want him to be bullied at school.

We're very worried about that. Kids get bullied over anything. It's going to be hard so it's important he has dads as well. All parents are worried that their kids will resent them, so we are worried that when he gets older he may blame us. We didn't go to antenatal classes because at the first one everyone in the room was staring at us. We don't want Will to feel an outcast, so it stops us doing many things. But we're exactly the same as everyone else.

The family with disabled children

Jacqui, 49, and Paul Murray, 52, have been married for 22 years and live in Walsall, West Midlands. Paul has a learning disability, as do two of their three children. Both parents are full-time carers.

I met Paul at a Pontins holiday camp in 1983, where I was working in the café. Paul used to work as a fork-lift driver but he stopped a few years after our son Robert [now 20] was born. Robert has arthritis, cerebral palsy and severe learning difficulties and I still need to help him to get dressed. He'll never be able to work so of course I worry about him, but he's done so well at college. Ryan, 13, doesn't have any learning problems. I try not to ask him for too much help because it's important he has his own life. He wants to work with children with special needs. Sophie, five, has recently started at a special school. Her speech is affected; she wears a nappy and is like a two-year-old. Her behaviour can be difficult but we just get on with it. I've never considered putting them in care, or even respite care, because they're my children. Don't get me wrong: it's hard work. But we get time to relax at the weekend. Sky is our one treat so we can all watch the football together.

The grandparents

Sue Stewart, 53, and her husband Ian, 52, from Doncaster in Yorkshire, have looked after their grandchildren Jamie, 13, and Jade, 11, for the past 10 years.

They are my daughter's children. We had another grandchild who died at 14 months. The death certificate said cot death and obviously that was devastating for all of us. She was my daughter's eldest child. After that my daughter found it very difficult to cope. She was a single parent and started to become depressed and I began looking after the children so she could go to work and get a social life.

She wasn't working, however, and didn't tell anyone. Her rent and council tax weren't paid so she was evicted, and they all came to live with me full time. One day my daughter went out and didn't come home again. Eventually I ended up with custody of the children. My daughter returned after a year, with another child, who now lives with her.

I naturally didn't think about it at the time. It was very traumatic to lose one grandchild, and I was determined not to lose another one, whether it was to care or social services.

The children are very well adjusted and happy that they live with us. I look at them as my children, rather than grandchildren. That does take away the grandmother/grandchild relationship and sometimes I do feel that we're now in our 50s and should be enjoying life instead of raising another family. And I'm dreading the teenage years. But we have a very special relationship.

The adopted child with two fathers

Randall Cole, 39, from Haringey, north London, works for Barnardo's and has been with his partner Stuart, 37, for 10 years. They adopted Benjamin two and a half years ago when he was less than 24 hours old.

We met in San Francisco and married in 2001. I have never doubted that I wanted children. In America the adoption system is much more open that it is here. Benjamin's mother was a homeless drug addict and she chose us as parents. We adopted him shortly after he was born, and tell him that his mother made a choice to do the best thing for him. We are still in touch with his birth parents.

We moved to the UK in November to be nearer Stuart's parents, who live in Upminster, Essex. People are often surprised that we adopted a child at birth. Ben knows no different than he has a daddy and a papa. He hears other kids in the playground talk about their mummies, and once said "I want my mummy", but he was just parroting.

Kids can be cruel sometimes and pick up on differences. Our role as parents is to make sure he knows that he is loved and is as good as any other kid, and to know that his family is cool.

Two half-brothers, one household

Sam Barnett, 34, from Brighton has two children by different mothers – Ruben, nine, and Oscar, three – whom he looks after three days a week.

I have them both at the same time, so that they get to spend time with each other as well as me. Ruben's mother and I had been going out since university. Ruben was a happy accident and we decided to make a go of it, but six months after he was born we decided we'd both be happier with somebody else. I was 24 and spent the next four years living in a house with friends, and Ruben would stay with me for half the week, because I didn't want to be a weekend dad.

Then I met Oscar's mother and we moved in together. When she became pregnant we bought a flat where I live now. When we split up I kept the flat and made the same agreement I have with Ruben's mother.

It's difficult with two ex-partners to arrange things, but they have been understanding and we put the kids first. Ruben was the youngest for a while but now he enjoys being a big brother. They love each other and have a lot of time together. Ruben has lived with Oscar for a while so they've grown up together. Ideally I'd love to be in a traditional family and there's a bit of guilt that my sons don't have that, but the next best thing is for them to spend time together.

The single mother

Ionie Willis, 54, from Leytonstone in east London, is the single parent of four adult children, who all have different fathers. She is a qualified counsellor and mediator.

I've never been married and, while all the kids have had contact with their dads, it's always been just me and them in the house. But I come from Jamaica and we believe it takes a village to raise a child, not just a parent, and it's the role of grandparents to pass on their wisdom. I was very young when my eldest, Amanda, 34, was born and if it hadn't been for my mum and strong family, social services would have taken her away. It's only me and my youngest, Harriet, who is 18, at home now, but I've got seven grandchildren, who are here all the time and it's my role to be the elder. You'll often find us all sitting down to a home-cooked meal on Sundays. All the kids help with each other; it just comes automatically because that's the way we've all been brought up. There is no book on how to be a perfect parent and my children are learning by trial and error like I did.

The foster parent

Jane Slater, 61, from Kirkcudbright, Dumfries & Galloway, has fostered 43 babies and young children over the past 11 years. She has four birth children and nine grandchildren.

After my husband died in 1997, my seven-year-old grandson and I were left living in a big empty house, so I got into emergency foster caring as I thought it would be good to have other little bodies to keep him company. Since then there have been 43, staying anything between one night and two and half years. There was one magical weekend when I had five. At the moment I've a one-year-old baby boy, who has been with me since he was a day old. The more you have, the easier it is because they play together and I just have to feed them and stop the fights. My grandchildren are here all the time as well and they love having the children to play with. Lots of [the foster children] still come back and visit. It's a wonderful feeling because many come from horrendous experiences and I get a chance to settle them and build up their confidence.

Post a Comment

View all comments that have been posted about this article.

Offensive or abusive comments will be removed and your IP logged and may be used to prevent further submission. In submitting a comment to the site, you agree to be bound by the Independent Minds Terms of Service.

Comments

Love?
[info]adullamite wrote:
Sunday, 24 May 2009 at 06:42 am (UTC)
While those left after a death to bring up the family do a great job it appears I wonder if those who bring up children with different fathers have ever known 'love?' Are they just unable to commit, or accept commitment from the other? Is diversity good or just a means of confusion I wonder?
all of the above are not regarded as foirst class citizens
[info]cronyblatcher wrote:
Sunday, 24 May 2009 at 07:00 am (UTC)
in the Blatcherist post-democracy
http://www.dw-world.de/dw/article/0,2144,3617727,00.html

The good citizen acording to the Crone and WonderTone et al is a gluttonous, rat-racing, planet busting, part-time parenting, gluttonous consumer of anything and everything including their own children's future
So what!
[info]over325one wrote:
Sunday, 24 May 2009 at 07:01 am (UTC)
So what's new? Plenty of people carried on after and during the war and got no help for the authorities. Stop patting yourselves on the back for being a member of the human race.
A sick society
[info]andyman67 wrote:
Sunday, 24 May 2009 at 10:22 am (UTC)
Reading the case studies in this article made me feel physically ill. What a repugnant, revolting society we have become when such specimens are held up as examples of diversity. Four children by four different fathers, lesbian mothers using sperm donors, gay fathers adopting: all quite disgusting and depraved.
Re: A sick society
[info]cronyblatcher wrote:
Sunday, 24 May 2009 at 12:19 pm (UTC)
Society's sickness is manifested as refusal to implement fraudulently ratifed UNCRC, and as ranking the human rights of children lower than those of violent criminals and illegal immigrants, rather than people's menage arrangements / practices / necessities, in a society suicidally characterised by kinderfeindlichkeit
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CnqCUvGhxUQ&NR=1
Re: A sick society
[info]red_planet92 wrote:
Monday, 25 May 2009 at 12:07 am (UTC)
cronyblatcher,

Are you always deliberately obscure?
I hardly feel this is something to boast about
[info]kuma2000 wrote:
Sunday, 24 May 2009 at 05:42 pm (UTC)
Whilst this article may have some touching moments (Mrs Stewart and Mrs Slater), much of it is quite depressing where people are happy to have kids yet unable to maintain a relationship over long term - something which I would think you should be at least able to do for 16 years if you have a child - or else children are a puppy substitute like the lesbian couple see it. This is hardly something to be celebrated.
Diversity
[info]beckiewolf wrote:
Sunday, 24 May 2009 at 09:16 pm (UTC)
Relationships sometimes don't work out the way you plan them. The partner you chose may become abusive, violent or unstable and not adhere to their marriage vows. Is it better to stick with a partner for life or until a child grows up, as that's what tradition dictates? Children are not stupid! They pick up on unhappiness.

Whether we like it or not, the nuclear family is fast becoming a thing of the past. Human beings weren't built to be monogamous. Children are very adaptable and as long as they are put first and they are loved, cherished and listened to, then diversity works. I believe that a child can often be unhappiest when in a nuclear family situation that is failing, rather than a child who lives in an untraditional family such as those mentioned above, where there is love, support and happiness for all.
picking up the pieces
[info]jamesferndale wrote:
Sunday, 24 May 2009 at 11:15 pm (UTC)
Why are all these children without homes in the first place. O yes, most were dumped by their Heterosexual parents!! Well done to all the lesbian and gay couples out there who have stepped in to give these children a caring and loving home. One other thing, how lucky to have two fathers, most children in Britain don't even have one!! I and many other people like me where brought up in a single parent home by our mothers, I personally would have loved to of had even one father! So in answer to all the vile homophobes leaving comments, it is because you dumped your kids that gay men and women are having to step in and "pick up the pieces!
Pernicious, unrealistic and low in scholarship
[info]cybn wrote:
Saturday, 30 May 2009 at 08:49 am (UTC)
The Independent has really outdone itself here. This is as close to an outright attack on the traditional family unit as I have ever seen in recent times. Put simply it is saying this: anything goes. All is equal. Nothing is bad, or at least, all things are equally bad. More subtly however, it is actually making a judgement - that the nuclear family is not a sacred thing; it is not an ideal; it is not even worth talking about. Yet, as the data (and common sense) attests to, children raised in a nuclear family are the most well-adjusted adults in later life. They are much less likely to commit crime. They are much less likely to be expelled from school. Exceptions can always be found of course, but it is entirely appropriate to maintain a strong bias to the traditional arrangement, and by extension to encourage it with appropriate financial inducements. The message you are sending out to the public, on the other hand is "do what you want". The article is frivolous in the extreme.

Most popular

Article Archive

Day In a Page

Sun | Mon | Tue | Wed | Thu | Fri | Sat

Select date