Man wins house fire legal battle
Monday 17 September 2012
A man has won a legal battle over an insurance company's refusal to pay up for a fire it claimed was deliberately started by his partner.
St Andrew's Insurance linked the January 2008 blaze in Margaret Street, Brighton - described in London's High Court as "the gay village" - to Tony Howe's tendency to "hissy fits".
But Mr Howe, who has been with Jonathan Smyth for close to seven years, said the fire, which killed the household's three cats, was an accident.
Ruling today in favour of Mr Smyth - who is claiming around £300,000 - solely on the issue of liability, Deputy Judge John Randall said the insurers had not satisfied him that the fire was started by Mr Howe.
It was more likely than not that it was started accidentally by a lit cigarette carelessly discarded or accidentally dislodged by Rebecca Alexander, who rented the basement room in the four-storey terrace where the fire began.
Ms Alexander, said the judge, was an "overly defensive" witness who made accusations against Mr Howe which led to him being arrested, before he was bailed without charge and told he was not to be prosecuted.
She agreed she was a messy person and the state of her room that evening, with strewn clothing, discarded tissues and a highly flammable bed cover, made it a serious fire hazard.
The judge said she was tired from her shift as a care worker in a children's home, and agitated from a shouting match started by Mr Howe, who had been drinking, about the messy kitchen.
She was also naturally careless in that she would often go out to the shops having left the hob on, he added.
"It would not be surprising if a naturally careless person such as Ms Alexander, in the stressful circumstances in which she found herself that evening, had either carelessly discarded, or accidentally dislodged without noticing, a lit cigarette when rapidly preparing to leave the house, or perhaps when getting up to challenge Mr Howe when he first shouted at her though the door."
The judge said Mr Howe, who was 37 at the time, was not then employed but conscientiously undertook the housework, being fastidious and house-proud.
Sometimes, he had tantrums, or "hissy fits", which were in the nature of attention-seeking behaviour rather than being dangerous or destructive.
Information security manager Mr Smyth, now of Cooperage Quay, Stirling, Scotland, affectionately called them "Tony Bear tantrums".
The judge said Mr Howe's essential account of matters and firm denial of arson had been calm and consistent throughout, and was convincing.
"I find there to be no cogent reasons - beyond the bare facts of the shouting match or argument which had occurred that evening, that Mr Howe was 'merry', and that he had once kicked out the wobbly spindles supporting a bannister while in a tantrum - for concluding that he deliberately started the fire, and that the preponderance of the available evidence, as well as a common sense view of inherent probabilities, is against such a conclusion."
For Mr Howe to have done so would have been an act of "extraordinary malice and recklessness", said the judge.
- 1 Oxygen-starved 'dead zones' with no marine life up to 100-miles long discovered in the Atlantic Ocean
- 2 The man who filmed the Freddie Gray video has been arrested at gunpoint
- 3 Indonesia executions: Death row British grandmother Lindsay Sandiford will refuse to wear a blindfold when she faces firing squad
- 4 How the language you speak changes your view of the world
- 5 Tory activist asked to step down after Labour candidate Rupa Huq is 'manhandled' while questioning Boris Johnson on the campaign trail
General Election 2015: Fishing is on Nigel Farage's mind as he casts a line to the disaffected of Grimsby
The man who filmed the Freddie Gray video has been arrested at gunpoint
Indonesia executions: Death row British grandmother Lindsay Sandiford will refuse to wear a blindfold when she faces firing squad
Oxygen-starved 'dead zones' with no marine life up to 100-miles long discovered in the Atlantic Ocean
Russian warships accused of 'chasing away' Swedish vessel to prevent Baltic States from achieving energy independence
Over 50,000 families shipped out of London boroughs in the past three years due to welfare cuts and soaring rents
EU asylum policy is 'a direct threat to our civilisation', says Nigel Farage
The Rothschild Libel: Why has it taken 200 years for an anti-Semitic slur that emerged from the Battle of Waterloo to be dismissed?
General Election 2015: SNP and its activists 'openly racist' towards the English, Farage says
General Election 2015: UK will be 'run for the wealthy and powerful' if Tories retain power, Labour warns
Schools forced to act as 'miniature welfare states' with teachers buying underwear and even haircuts for poor pupils
£28000 - £45000 per annum: Recruitment Genius: A Senior Digital Marketing Cons...
£16640 - £18500 per annum: Recruitment Genius: An Assistant Stores Keeper is r...
£16000 - £18500 per annum: Recruitment Genius: This is an excellent opportunit...
£17000 - £30000 per annum: Recruitment Genius: Developer required to join a bu...