Parliament 'misled over rendition of alleged terrorists'

News in pictures
News in pictures
On Facebook
From the blogs

How the Mail Online turned us into misogyny addicts

Mail Online, the more insistent, bitchier spawn of the Daily Mail, is now the most visited newspaper...

Becoming Damien Hirst? You’re not the first

Damien Hirst, the richest, probably most famous, contemporary living artist, once remarked: “I don't...

The Photography Blog: Rise of the smartphone, but smart photography too?

Assuming Mark Zuckerberg hasn’t got his sums wrong, the market for smartphone photography is booming...

Poll: Labour gain as Tories suffer from euro crisis

Labour’s lead is up to nine points in a ComRes opinion poll for The Independent on Sunday, sha...

Suggested Topics

The Government misled Parliament over two alleged terrorists who were subject to 'extraordinary rendition', a legal charity said today.

Clive Stafford Smith from Reprieve said ministers had made "factually incorrect" statements to MPs when they admitted Britain's complicity in their rendition.



Both men were captured by British soldiers in Iraq in February 2004 and handed over to the US authorities, who flew them to Afghanistan.



In a statement to the House of Commons in February, then Defence Secretary John Hutton said the men were members of an extremist group Lashkar e Taiba (LeT)



LeT, which was responsible for the Mumbai attacks this year, is a radical Sunni group.



Mr Hutton also said the US Government claimed the men were moved to Afghanistan because of a lack of translators.



But an investigation by Reprieve revealed one of the men, Pakistani national Amanatullah Ali, is from the Shia sect of Islam.



Reprieve said both men were Arabic speakers and so could have been interrogated in Iraq. The US moved the men so they could be held in prison, the charity claimed.



Former shadow home secretary David Davis has tabled a string of questions about the case in Parliament. The Tory MP said ministers had "washed their hands" of the two men.



According to Reprieve, Ali is a rice merchant from Pakistan who was on pilgrimage in Iraq when he was shot in the foot and captured.



The identity of the second man has not been confirmed but he is thought to be called Salahuddin. Reports from Afghanistan suggest he has "catastrophic" mental health problems, Reprieve said.



The Ministry of Defence has not identified either man, and in correspondence with Reprieve said doing so would violate their rights under the Data Protection Act.



Reprieve is demanding access to the men - who are thought to be in detention at Bagram Air Base - to provide them with legal assistance.



Mr Hutton's statement followed years of denials that Britain had been involved in rendition.



He revealed both Justice Secretary Jack Straw and former Home Secretary Charles Clarke had been informed about the case in briefing papers.



MPs and civil liberties groups have repeatedly called for a full inquiry into what happened.









Mr Stafford Smith said: "The particular importance of this case - beyond the fact that an entirely innocent person seems to have been held in prison for more than five years - is that Government ministers misled Parliament and the country by denying that we had anything to do with rendition and then, when John Hutton 'apologised' for this, he misled Parliament again.

"And the government now appears unwilling to admit that they are still propagating falsehoods."

Independent Comment
blog comments powered by Disqus
Career Services

Day In a Page

Bee Gees star Robin Gibb - A Life in Pictures

A Life in Pictures

Bee Gees star Robin Gibb
Antelope first seen 20 years ago is on brink of extinction

Endangered animals

The good news and the bad news
Second best day of his life? Zuckerberg surprises friends with secret wedding

Second best day of his life?

Zuckerberg surprises friends with secret wedding
Laurie Penny: In the age of camera phones the message is that protesters are watching police too

Occupy in the age of the camera phone

In Chicago, you can't see the cops for the cameras
Exclusive extract: How Cameron tried to evade Murdoch's embrace

Exclusive book extract

How Cameron tried to evade Murdoch's embrace
Pathetic fantasist or Nazi spy? The mysterious Mrs O'Grady

Pathetic fantasist or Nazi spy? The mysterious Mrs O'Grady

She was the only British woman sentenced to death for treason during the Second World War. Now, a new book revisits her bizarre case
Introducing the wellderly

Introducing the wellderly

Growing numbers of the over-65s want to keep working, volunteer or go on gap years
Penny Junor: 'I'm absolutely not a friend of Prince Charles'

Penny Junor interview

'I'm absolutely not a friend of Prince Charles'
Joe Strummer: The angry young man who grew up

Joe Strummer

How to remember the punk hero?
Patrick Cockburn: Goodbye to recent delusions - the age of nationalism is back with a vengeance

Patrick Cockburn: Goodbye to recent delusions...

... the age of nationalism is back with a vengeance
AN Wilson: Can Hollande live down the rain on his parade?

Can Hollande live down the rain on his parade?

The new French President's debut last week has drawn comparisons with Clouseau. But AN Wilson says curious things can happen after a downpour
Slumdog the musical calls in Julian Fellowes

Slumdog the musical calls in Julian Fellowes

Danny Boyle has broken off talks on staging his hit movie after an argument over artistic control
Like hotcakes: Bill Granger thinks the world is about to go pancake-crazy

Like hotcakes

Bill Granger thinks the world is about to go pancake-crazy
Siren sisters: The fishy tale of America's strangest theme park

Siren sisters

The fishy tale of America's strangest theme park
Blade Runner with a female lead: All-action gals... just like mother

All-action gals... just like mother

It's no surprise Ridley Scott is to remake his sci-fi action thriller 'Blade Runner' with a female lead