Law Report: Court can give protection against self-incrimination: A T & T Istel Ltd and another v Tully and others - House of Lords (Lord Templeman, Lord Griffiths, Lord Ackner, Lord Goff of Chieveley and Lord Lowry), 20 July 1992

A party in civil proceedings can be required to disclose material which may incriminate him in criminal proceedings if the court can adequately protect him from the material being used in a criminal court. Protection was adequate only if the prosecuting authorities agreed not to make use of the material disclosed.

The House of Lords (Lord Griffiths dissenting) allowed an appeal by the plaintiffs from the Court of Appeal's decision ((1992) 1 QB 315; The Independent, 22 November 1991) that compliance by the defendants, Arthur Tully and Margaret Tully, of an order for discovery would infringe their privilege against self-incrimination and restored an order requiring the defendants to disclose certain information.

The first plaintiff bought the second plaintiff company which had been controlled by Mr and Mrs Tully and which had provided computer services to a health authority. The first plaintiff discovered that the service contract had been fraudulently operated. The matter was under police investigation but no charges had been laid. The first plaintiff commenced an action against, among others, Mr and Mrs Tully, alleging a large commercial fraud.

Mr Justice Buckley made an order for discovery against Mr and Mrs Tully for disclosure of their dealings and documents relating to the second plaintiff. The order was subject to the condition that no disclosure made should be used as evidence in the prosecution of an offence alleged to have been committed by the person required to make the disclosure.

Mr Justice Wright allowed Mr and Mrs Tully's appeal against the order on the ground that compliance with it would infringe their privilege against self-incrimination since the condition could not bind the Crown Prosecution Service. The Court of Appeal upheld Mr Justice Wright's decision. The CPS decided not to take part in the proceedings. In a letter they accepted that the order restricted them in any prosecution to utilising material they had already obtained or other material obtained independently of that disclosed under the order.

Michael Tugendhat QC and Richard Spearman (Taylor Joynson Garrett) for the plaintiffs; Alan Rawley QC and Jeremy Gibbons (Lawrence Graham for Dutton Gregory & Williams, Eastleigh) for Mr and Mrs Tully.

LORD TEMPLEMAN said that it was difficult to see any reason why in civil proceedings the privilege against self-incrimination should be exercisable so as to enable a litigant to refuse relevant and even vital documents in his possession or power and which spoke for themselves. The principle against self-incrimination exercisable in civil proceedings was an archaic and unjustifiable survival from the past.

Parliament had recognised in a piecemeal fashion that the privilege was unsatisfactory when no question of ill-treatment or dubious confessions was involved and had been willing to abrogate or modify the privilege: see section 31 of the Theft Act 1968, section 72 of the Supreme Court Act 1981 and section 434 of the Companies Act 1985.

The present proceedings were not covered by any of the statutory relaxations of the privilege but they were similar to and analogous to situations in which Parliament had intervened.

Since Parliament had not abolished the privilege the Tullys would be entitled to rely on it if but only if and so far as compliance with Mr Justice Buckley's order would provide evidence against them in a criminal trial. There was no reason why the privilege should be blatantly exploited to deprive the plaintiffs of their civil rights and remedies if the privilege was not necessary to protect the Tullys.

In view of the letter from the CPS, compliance with Mr Justice Buckley's order with the safeguard provided by the condition of that order would not create any real danger that the Tullys would be prejudiced in criminal proceedings. Mr Justice Buckley's order should be restored.

LORD JUSTICE GRIFFITHS, dissenting, said that Mr and Mrs Tully, by producing documents in this civil action, could safely resist their use if the police subsequently acquired them independently from some other source. Only if the CPS letter was written by or with the direct authority of the DPP or the Director of the Serious Fraud Office would his Lordship feel assured that there was no risk that the criminal law would be impeded.

LORD ACKNER said that if the privilege against self-incrimination was to be abolished or abridged, then that must be done by Parliament.

The Tullys were sufficiently safeguarded in the circumstances of this case. The courts were entitled to substitute some different protection in place of the privilege against self-incrimination providing that such protection could properly be considered as adequate protection.

Not only must the prosecuting authorities have notice of the proposed order but they must unequivocally agree not to make use, directly or indirectly, of material divulged as a result of compliance with the order. It must remain entirely a matter for the discretion of the prosecuting authorities as to whether they were in a position to and were prepared to give an assurance. Without such an assurance the court would not be able to provide a substitute protection which was adequate.

LORD GOFF agreed with Lord Ackner.

LORD LOWRY said that real problems for the DPP could be foreseen if they were expected to join in applications or to provide undertakings or letters for the purpose of facilitating parties in complex civil proceedings. It was necessary for Parliament to give the problem its urgent attention.

Ying Hui Tan, Barrister

Have you tried new the Independent Digital Edition apps?
ebookA unique anthology of reporting and analysis of a crucial period of history
Luis Suarez looks towards the crowd during the 2-1 victory over England
Life and Style
Cheesecake frozen yoghurt by Constance and Mathilde Lorenzi
food + drinkThink outside the cool box for this summer’s frozen treats
John Barrowman kisses his male “bride” at a mock Gretna Green during the Commonwealth Games opening ceremony
peopleBarrowman's opening ceremony message to Commonwealth countries where he would be sent to prison for being gay
Sir Bradley Wiggins removes his silver medal after the podium ceremony for the men’s 4,000m team pursuit in Glasgow yesterday
Commonwealth games Disappointment for Sir Bradley in team pursuit final as England are forced to settle for silver
Alistair Brownlee (right) celebrates with his gold medal after winning the men’s triathlon alongside brother Jonny (left), who got silver
England's Jodie Stimpson won the women’s triathlon in the morning
Travel Shop
the manor
Up to 70% off luxury travel
on city breaks Find out more
Up to 70% off luxury travel
on chic beach resorts Find out more
sardina foodie
Up to 70% off luxury travel
on country retreats Find out more
Latest stories from i100
Have you tried new the Independent Digital Edition apps?
Independent Dating

By clicking 'Search' you
are agreeing to our
Terms of Use.

iJobs Job Widget
iJobs General

Process Improvement Analyst (Testing)

£40000 - £45000 Per Annum: Clearwater People Solutions Ltd: Our client is curr...

Service Delivery Manager - Derivatives, Support,

Negotiable: Harrington Starr: Service Delivery Manager - (Derivatives, Support...

Technical Account Manager - Java, FIX Protocol, FIX 5.0, C++

£30000 - £55000 per annum: Harrington Starr: Technical Account Manager - Java,...

WPF .NET Developer

£300 - £350 per day: Harrington Starr: WPF Analyst Programmer NET, WPF, C#, M...

Day In a Page

Backhanders, bribery and abuses of power have soared in China as economy surges

Bribery and abuses of power soar in China

The bribery is fuelled by the surge in China's economy but the rules of corruption are subtle and unspoken, finds Evan Osnos, as he learns the dark arts from a master
Commonwealth Games 2014: Highland terriers stole the show at the opening ceremony

Highland terriers steal the show at opening ceremony

Gillian Orr explores why a dog loved by film stars and presidents is finally having its day
German art world rocked as artists use renowned fat sculpture to distil schnapps

Brewing the fat from artwork angers widow of sculptor

Part of Joseph Beuys' 1982 sculpture 'Fettecke' used to distil schnapps
BBC's The Secret History of Our Streets reveals a fascinating window into Britain's past

BBC takes viewers back down memory lane

The Secret History of Our Streets, which returns with three films looking at Scottish streets, is the inverse of Benefits Street - delivering warmth instead of cynicism
Joe, film review: Nicolas Cage delivers an astonishing performance in low budget drama

Nicolas Cage shines in low-budget drama Joe

Cage plays an ex-con in David Gordon Green's independent drama, which has been adapted from a novel by Larry Brown
How to make your own gourmet ice lollies, granitas, slushy cocktails and frozen yoghurt

Make your own ice lollies and frozen yoghurt

Think outside the cool box for this summer's tempting frozen treats
Ford Fiesta is UK's most popular car of all-time, with sales topping 4.1 million since 1976

Fiesta is UK's most popular car of all-time

Sales have topped 4.1 million since 1976. To celebrate this milestone, four Independent writers recall their Fiestas with pride
10 best reed diffusers

Heaven scent: 10 best reed diffusers

Keep your rooms smelling summery and fresh with one of these subtle but distinctive home fragrances that’ll last you months
Commonwealth Games 2014: Female boxers set to compete for first time

Female boxers set to compete at Commonwealth Games for first time

There’s no favourites and with no headguards anything could happen
Five things we’ve learned so far about Manchester United under Louis van Gaal

Five things we’ve learned so far about United under Van Gaal

It’s impossible to avoid the impression that the Dutch manager is playing to the gallery a little
Screwing your way to the top? Good for Lana Del Rey for helping kill that myth

Screwing your way to the top?

Good for Lana Del Rey for helping kill that myth, says Grace Dent
Will the young Britons fighting in Syria be allowed to return home and resume their lives?

Will Britons fighting in Syria be able to resume their lives?

Tony Blair's Terrorism Act 2006 has made it an offence to take part in military action abroad with a "political, ideological, religious or racial motive"
Beyoncé poses as Rosie the Riveter, the wartime poster girl who became a feminist pin-up

Beyoncé poses as Rosie the Riveter

The wartime poster girl became the ultimate American symbol of female empowerment
The quest to find the perfect pair of earphones: Are custom, 3D printed earbuds the solution?

The quest to find the perfect pair of earphones

Earphones don't fit properly, offer mediocre audio quality and can even be painful. So the quest to design the perfect pair is music to Seth Stevenson's ears
US Army's shooting star: Lt-Col Steven Cole is the man Hollywood calls when it wants to borrow a tank or check a military uniform

Meet the US Army's shooting star

Lt-Col Steven Cole is the man Hollywood calls when it wants to borrow a tank or check a military uniform