Law Report: Disclosure orders are not limited: Re British & Commonwealth Holdings plc (No 2) - House of Lords (Lord Keith of Kinkel, Lord Ackner, Lord Jauncey of Tullichettle, Lord Lowry and Lord Slynn of Hadley), 29 October 1992
The House of Lords dismissed an appeal by Spicer & Oppenheim, chartered accountants, who had been auditors of Atlantic Computers plc from 1983 to 1989, and affirmed the decision of the Court of Appeal ((1992) 2 WLR 931), reversing the decision of Mr Justice Hoffmann on 24 July 1991, and restoring the decision of Mr Registrar Scott on 29 April 1991, requiring the auditors to produce to the joint administrators of British & Commonwealth Holdings plc all records relating to B&C's acquisition of Atlantic Computers plc and the latter's audits for the years ending 1987 and 1988.
Peter Goldsmith QC, and Robin Knowles (Linklaters & Paines) for the auditors; Gabriel Moss QC, and John Brisby (Stephenson Harwood) for the administrators.
LORD SLYNN said the administrators took the view that serious questions had to be investigated concerning the conduct of Atlantic's business before and after its acquisition, and as to representations made to British & Commonwealth Holdings plc prior to the acquisition.
To that end, the registrar made an order under section 236 of the 1986 Act.
Under that section, the court might require 'any person whom the court thinks capable of giving information concerning the promotion, formation, business dealings, affairs or property of the company' to 'produce any books, papers or other records in his possession or under his control relating to the company or (its affairs)'.
Mr Justice Hoffmann, relying on Cloverbay Ltd v BCCI (1991) Ch 90 at 102, considered that an order under section 236 was limited to information necessary to enable a liquidator or administrator to reconstitute that state of knowledge the company should possess.
But when read as a whole, Cloverbay did not appear to have that effect, and section 236, whose wording was quite general, contained no such express limitation.
In his Lordship's judgment, the power of the court to make an order under section 236 was not limited to documents needed 'to reconstitute the state of the company's knowledge' even if that might be one of the purposes most clearly justifying making an order.
At the same time, it was plain that it was an extraordinary power and that the discretion had to be exercised after a careful balancing of the factors involved, and consideration of the effects, on the parties concerned, of either making or not making the order.
The proper case was one where the administrator reasonably required to see the documents to carry out his functions and their production did not impose an unnecessary and unreasonable burden on the person required to produce them.
This was an exceptional case and the order, though wide, should be upheld.
LORD KEITH, LORD ACKNER, LORD JAUNCEY and LORD LOWRY agreed.
Paul Magrath, Barrister
Easter egg hunt horror as mother finds dead body under deck of house
Missing Malaysia Airlines Flight MH370: Wreckage could be found within a week as search reaches 'very critical juncture', says minister
Unbeliebable: The White House offer 'no comment' to anti-Justin Bieber petition
Loch Ness Monster found on Apple Maps?
Royal Tour 2014: Is the Duchess of Cambridge the only person ever to climb into a fighter jet wearing a dress and high heels?
The food poverty scandal that shames Britain: Nearly 1m people rely on handouts to eat – and benefit reforms may be to blame
Scottish independence: It is the English who should be on their knees, begging the Scots to vote ‘No’
Nigel Farage fatigue? Half of voters ‘immune’ to Ukip’s appeal
'Sinful': Video of British Muslims dancing to Pharrell Williams's hit Happy comes under attack
Nigel Farage: I’m taking on the status quo, and the Establishment’s fighting back
Refugee facing deportation from Sweden saved by fellow passengers refusing to let plane leave
- 1 Easter egg hunt horror as mother finds dead body under deck of house
- 2 A bottle of wine a day is not bad for you and abstaining is worse than drinking, scientist claims
- 3 Unbeliebable: The White House offer 'no comment' to anti-Justin Bieber petition
- 4 Loch Ness Monster found on Apple Maps?
- 5 How We Met: Alison Moyet & Emma Kennedy: 'I knew we'd be friends because she was happy to make a prat of herself'
£150.00 per week: QA Apprenticeships: This company is a company that specializ...
£153.75 per week: QA Apprenticeships: This company is an innovative outsourcin...
£150.00 per week: QA Apprenticeships: This company has been providing on site ...
£150.00 per week: QA Apprenticeships: We've been supplying best of breed peopl...