Stay up to date with notifications from The Independent

Notifications can be managed in browser preferences.

Commons Speaker Hoyle warns of prejudice risk if China spy suspect named

The 28-year-old researcher has insisted he is completely innocent and he has not been named by police.

David Hughes
Monday 11 September 2023 17:23 BST
Speaker Sir Lindsay Hoyle warned that discussing the identities of those involved could hamper any future prosecution (House of Commons/PA)
Speaker Sir Lindsay Hoyle warned that discussing the identities of those involved could hamper any future prosecution (House of Commons/PA) (PA Wire)

MPs have been urged not to name the parliamentary researcher arrested on suspicion of spying for China to avoid the risk of prejudice.

Commons Speaker Sir Lindsay Hoyle warned that discussing the identities of those involved could hamper any future prosecution.

The 28-year-old researcher has insisted he is completely innocent and he has not been named by police.

However, The Times newspaper has published the name of the researcher, with former Tory leader Sir Iain Duncan Smith saying there was a “clear public interest” in identifying him.

There had been speculation a MP would use the protection of parliamentary privilege to publicly name the suspect.

But Sir Lindsay told MPs: “I would remind all members of the importance of not discussing security issues on the floor of the House.

“That is particularly important in this case, where commenting on the identities of those alleged to be involved, engaging in speculation about the case or discussing other details runs a serious risk of prejudicing any future prosecutions – which the comments made in the media were unhelpful – something for which I’m sure no member will want to be responsible.”

Recent court rulings have made news organisations wary about naming suspects before they are charged.

The Supreme Court ruled last year in the case of a US citizen known only as ZXC that a person being investigated for a crime generally has “a reasonable expectation of privacy”.

The ruling confirmed the decision of the High Court in pop veteran Sir Cliff Richard’s privacy case against the BBC over its coverage of a South Yorkshire Police raid on his home in Sunningdale, Berkshire, in August 2014.

Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in