Magistrates rule CSA assessments can be overturned: Agency to challenge a ruling that could open floodgates for absent parents to challenge payments. Rosie Waterhouse reports
Friday 23 September 1994
The ruling by magistrates in Colchester last week could open the floodgates for absent parents to ask courts to overturn maintenance assessments made by the CSA. The decision has caused dismay at the highest levels of the CSA, which intends to challenge the decision in the High Court.
Roy Biggin, from Ardleigh near Colchester in Essex, who has two children from his first marriage, asked magistrates to overturn a Deduction from Earnings Order issued to his employers by the CSA after he refused to pay the pounds 80 a week maintenance assessed using the complex formula. He said the formula did not take into account all his financial circumstances and the assessment left him with so little money his children suffered.
Mr Biggin has a second family and helps provide for the two children of his new partner, Sue Boreham, whose ex- husband is dead and so cannot support them.
Mr Biggin, 39, a supervisor at Ardleigh reservoir, told the court the settlement meant one of his stepchildren was being hampered in her pursuit of a career as a social worker, but the whole family, including his children by the previous marriage, had been affected.
The CSA's solicitor argued that a magistrates' court did not have jurisdiction to examine CSA assessments, but the magistrates ruled that they did. The case could open the floodgates for every absent parents who has had a Deduction from Earnings Order to ask a magistrate to overturn the CSA's assessment.
Mr Biggin's solicitor, John Fellows, went on to argue that under section two of the Act, the CSA had to excercise its discretion and take into account the welfare of the children when deciding whether to make a Deduction from Earnings Order.
The magistrates agreed, so in principle, even if the agency staff have made an accurate assessment according to the letter of the formula, magistrates can re-examine an absent parent's financial circumstances and rule that it is too high and not in the best interests of the welfare of the children.
The court would take into account all the family circumstances including outgoings and expenses which the formula does not, such as debts, loans, the costs of travelling to work and seeing the children. The formula would in effect be thrown out.
However, the magistrates ruled that in Mr Biggin's case the child support officers did in fact exercise their discretion and consider the welfare of the children. They did not rule on whether the amount of the assessment was in the best interests of the children.
Susan Deas, a Liverpool solicitor who is fighting several CSA cases, said the magistrates' decision had 'enormous implications', especially for second families, which have been hardest hit since the agency took over maintenance assessments from the courts in April 1993.
- 1 Howard Jacobson: Let's see the 'criticism' of Israel for what it really is
- 2 Gingers face extinction due to climate change, scientists warn
- 3 Brazil vs Germany World Cup 2014: In defence of Mesut Ozil - the Arsenal midfielder works magic in the shadows
- 4 BBC’s new Game of Thrones slayer 'The Last Kingdom' relies on Saxon appeal, creators say
- 5 PornHub begs users to stop uploading video clips of Brazil getting beaten 7-1
Game of Thrones author George RR Martin says 'f*** you' to fans who fear he will die before finishing Westeros saga
Jennifer Lawrence face palms Emma Watson at Christian Dior show in Paris
Gingers face extinction due to climate change, scientists warn
Pamplona Running of the Bulls 2014: Briton critically injured in San Fermin festival
Israel's deadliest Gaza air strikes yet kill five children from same family as Palestinian rocket barrage continues
Sustained immigration has not harmed Britons' employment, say government advisers
British jihadist calls for 'flag of Islam' over Downing Street and Buckingham Palace
Australia facing international condemnation after turning around Sri Lankans at sea
7/7 memorial defaced on anniversary of 2005 attacks with ‘Blair lied thousands died’ graffiti
Even when it brutalises one of its own teenage citizens, America is helpless against Israel
There’s a nasty smell in the political air – and it’s coming from the Tories
£25000 - £30000 Per Annum: Clearwater People Solutions Ltd: Our client based i...
To £55kpa (12 Month Contract): Charter Selection: Major household name charity...
£40000 Per Annum Plus Package + Bonus: The Green Recruitment Company: The Gree...
£500 - £550 per day: Deerfoot IT Resources Limited: Build & Environment Manage...