Labour turmoil
Campaign to oust Prime Minister gathers pace
Labour rebels launch coup attempt against Brown on eve of crucial elections. Blears becomes focus of opposition after dramatic resignation from Cabinet
Gordon Brown was clinging on to his job last night as rebel Labour backbenchers threatened to force him out of Downing Street within days.
The Prime Minister suffered a crushing blow when Hazel Blears resigned as Communities Secretary on the eve of local and European elections today that could seal his fate. Ms Blears was incensed by Mr Brown's description of her non-payment of capital gains tax on the sale of two London flats as "totally unacceptable".
Should Gordon Brown resign?
The PM is facing calls from all sides to resign. Do you think he should go before the next election?
The PM is facing calls from all sides to resign. Do you think he should go before the next election?
| Yes |
|
| No |
|
Her timing was devastating, and seen as a deliberate attempt to destabilise Mr Brown and trigger a coup. It was the fourth ministerial exit in 24 hours and the second from the Cabinet.
Mr Brown faces a twin threat: a round-robin email circulating among Labour MPs calling on him to step down in the interests of the party and the nation, and a difficult cabinet reshuffle which could backfire rather than end the chaos engulfing his Government.
Organisers of the "Brown must go" campaign claimed that 80 backbenchers may be ready to sign the email. They intend to go public on Monday if they get at least 50 backers.
Another option being discussed is securing the 70 names needed for a "stalking horse" candidate, possibly a left-winger such as John McDonnell, to stand for the leadership. Such a huge revolt could force Mr Brown to quit without a special conference being called. That would open the way for other cabinet ministers to enter the leadership race. "We will get there, one way or the other," one Labour MP predicted last night. "It's tragic, but Gordon is not up to it. The only way to get out of this mess is to have the leadership contest we needed in 2007 [when Tony Blair resigned] or last year."
There were growing signs that ministers may scupper the smooth reshuffle Mr Brown desperately needs to restore his battered authority. Alistair Darling made clear he will leave the Cabinet if he is ousted as Chancellor, dashing hopes among Brownites that he would succeed the departing Jacqui Smith as Home Secretary.
David Miliband, another possible candidate for the Home Office, wants to remain as Foreign Secretary, while the Health Secretary Alan Johnson, the man most likely to take over if Mr Brown is ousted, is also reluctant to move to the Home Office.
John Reid, the former Home Secretary and a Blairite, turned down the offer of a surprise cabinet comeback in private talks with Mr Brown. The Independent understands that Mr Reid stopped Mr Brown in his tracks before a specific job was mentioned.
There was speculation that Mr Reid was offered a return to the Home Office. Brown aides insisted they had merely talked about football. Mr Reid is chairman of Celtic FC.
Amid a feverish atmosphere at Westminster, there were even remarkable rumours that the Prime Minister would offer a post to Mr Blair. Mr Brown is keen to recruit a Blairite "big beast" to dissuade allies of Mr Blair from joining the revolt against him – as he achieved last October by recalling Lord Mandelson, his long-time foe.
The Business Secretary, who rallied strongly behind Mr Brown yesterday, will be a pivotal figure in the critical 48 hours ahead. Blairite ministers such as James Purnell and John Hutton are likely to seek Lord Mandelson's advice on whether they should stay in the Cabinet. If any of them refused to serve under Mr Brown, it could bring him down. But there was no sign of that yesterday, when several ministers including Mr Johnson rushed to the Prime Minister's defence in a frantic round of media interviews.
Some backbenchers and ministers will make a final decision on whether to back or try to sack Mr Brown after the council results emerge tomorrow and the European Parliament results are announced on Sunday night.
One cabinet minister said: "If we come fourth behind Ukip in the Euro elections, that could be the trigger."
Mr Brown and his advisers will decide today whether to bring forward the reshuffle from Monday to tomorrow in an attempt to end the disarray sparked by the departures of Ms Smith and Ms Blears.
Allies insisted Mr Brown would not be pushed out and were relieved that he was not outgunned by David Cameron at Prime Minister's Questions. They dismissed the idea that ministers were threatening to scupper the reshuffle, saying that manoeuvring for jobs always happens before such a shake-up.
Brown allies warned rebel backbenchers that installing a new leader would make the growing demands for an early general election unstoppable, and pointed out that many of his Labour critics would lose their seats.
Barry Sheerman, a normally loyal senior Labour backbencher, said: "If the Prime Minister doesn't realise that, across the party, there is a disillusionment with the way the parliamentary party has been consulted, treated and valued, he is heading for trouble."
View all comments that have been posted about this article.
Offensive or abusive comments will be removed and your IP logged and may be used to prevent further submission. In submitting a comment to the site, you agree to be bound by the Independent Minds Terms of Service.
- Print Article
- Email Article
-
Click here for copyright permissions
Copyright 2009 Independent News and Media Limited


Comments
However, the 12 years of his disastrous policies will take a lot of undoing.
The Brown / Balls axis demonstrated its strength yesterday as a (claimed) reforming force by shaking some pieces of the rotting remains of quisling Blatcherism out of the top branches of government. There is renewed hope that either a Cromwell or people's resort to the BNP as a means of giving Britain a measure of protection from more of the pseudu-democratic circus, will be rendered unnecessary. However, that reforming force, if real : a) can be kept on its toes; b) can be given weaponry with which to deal with the rotting remains of blatcherism in government (and fend off the gang of spivs in the wings led by a slippery toff Blair lookalike) by protest votes for the BNP. In other words an effective protest vote is a vote for your enemy's most feared enemy. If the circus prevents you from voting BNP, then utter the vote of a conscientious abstainer.
http://news.independentminds.livejourna
I really don't know who in the labour party would do a better job. At least keep someone with a little experience of things going wrong (albeit if they were arguably his fault).
What a tawdry, disgraceful spectacle. An obdurate duffer of a prime minister, his credibility more than spent, squats like a disabled donkey whilst the hungry wolves encircle his hapless carcass. Resignations aplenty. Some simply wish to jump off the sinking ship. Some, like Blears, use the quit as a weapon, a redactive stab in the back. One has, if not sympathy (for who could sympathise with this tatty bunch of frauds & pretenders) then at least a measure of allowance for Blears' reposte. To single out Blears' transgressions as "totally unacceptable" at a time when it would appear that "acceptable behaviour" has never been in shorter supply among ministers is tantamount to pulling up a ship's officer for being "improperly dressed on deck" amidst the chaos of a sinking.
At every turn, even the last, Gordon Clown manages to get it wrong. Never, never again must a minister be allowed to assume prime ministership unelected.
Mandelson is the one exeption, he joined this stinking- sorry, Freudian slip- ship. But he did get in to the House of Lords, didn't he look pleased when covered in ermine...
However he was not alone and those who now seek to make him the scapegoat, portray hypocrisy at its best.
http://news.independentminds.livejourna
http://news.independentminds.livejourna
"Everybody vote for the BNP to help Brown's position as prime minister"?
Your sillines STILL doesn't make any sense, old chap...
if you're a BNP supporter why not just come out and say it, rather than extending this dubious waffle as a reason/excuse to vote BNP?
X
I have noticed a lot of younger commentators gunning for Brown - clearly they have only read about past Tory Governments in theory, not in practice. It must be difficult for them to comprehend the multitude of dreadful policy decisions made by the Tories in past Governments - we know, we lived through them. Can anyone who slates off Gordon Brown, tell me what the Tory policies are on the economy, health, education and Home affairs that will make life better - please dont repeat the shortcomings of the current lot. Labour has made mistakes but nothing on the scale of past Tory Governments.
Britain needs rid of his warmongering crony vermin, who must be banned from holding public office in future:
Jack Strawman
Hazel Bleeurgh
Lord Scrote of Foy
Geoff Goon
Two-Jags Lardarse Prescott
Rabid Minibrain the American Viceroy
Des Brownnoser
And the dismissal of Sir John Harlot, Unintelligence Chief.
That point has been made many times but it doesn't seem to register. You are right, he never did have a mandate from the punters, he was merely anointed.
The erstwhile aquiescent animals are turning on the planted Prime Minister and the sinister political drama is turning into a sad knockabout farce.
Another tragedy of these Machiavellian times, is that a few months on, these ugly scenes and shabby players will recover--like waters over a sinking stone--and the whole rotten play will resume with promises of greater transparency and honesty.
While this deceitful and dangerous lot of frauds are so desperately discredited, it would be wise for the British people to demand, that they dismantle all the repressive surveillance machinery and policies, which are future chains on public liberties.
More accountability must be wrung from the Chiefs of the Metropolitan Police--no more American-style, zero-tolerance Stockwell killings and cover-ups. Also investigate why after 7/7, no film was (allegedly) installed in several cameras, which could have proved Police culpability beyond any doubt.
This shabby end of undemocratic, Parliamentary arrogance, must initiate new zeal and commitment from the British People, if generations to come are not turned into craven automata.
I love my kids to grow good, please go now like Mohamed Ali , while the going is good, or you never know what tomorrow will bring May be Police.
I thank you
Firozali A. Mulla
http://geocities.com/cronyblatcher/inst
--==* Sugarbabymeet.C'om *==-- It's where Sugarbaby (women who are mature, rich and experienced) and men who like them can meet.
How do accomplaish "democratic maturity" while there is institutionalised obstruction and a wall of mass media disinformation ranged against it?
If Brown gives in and allows Miliband, Darling and Johnson to remain in post after the reshuffle then he will buy himself a little time at least. He obviously offered Reid the Home Office and sensibly he refused. Watch out for Blunkett hanging round number ten.
As to the backbencher's campaign; this could go either way. So I still worry that we will have to put up with the megalomaniac for some time yet.
I think there is something altogether more seedy going on here. From living in England for a few years i am aware of how the english are an inherently racist nation of people. You all hate the French or Germans or Irish or indians or pakistanis (don't worry, i think it is a mutual thing). The english hate the Welsh and Scottish. Northerners hate southerners. Mancunians hate liverpudlians etc. etc.. Why Gordon Brown has never been as popular as your chinless wonder Blair is simple, he is Scottish and deep down you english just cannot stomach being ruled by someone from your northern colony.
It's the whole New Labour thing. Above all, it's Blair ... but hang on, wasn't he Scottish, at least by family? And I loathed Reid ... But it's just coincidence, I swear ... I liked Kinnock, whose family must have been Scots, given the name, even though he grew up in the Welsh valleys. And I'm an Alex Salmond and Charles Kennedy fan. No tarten phobia, honest ... don't get paranoid!
It's the revolution that never was; no electoral reform will come of this unbelievable mess. When Cameron takes over, we might see a few sops to the masses over expenses but it will still be a case of same old, same old. First past the post will survive.
Dear Prudence Brown,
You may have stood a chance right at the beginning, but you blew it. Goodbye and good riddance.
People that have been discredited, surely have no future.
If these women see themselves as an alternative, then
help us all.
70 signatures on the side of corruption, who wants to vote for that ?
The whole New Labour ship is a wreck.
However, I see no New Labour person capable of being a PM
Miliband wanted a private jet to tour the world with in his Foreign Secretary role and he has gardening expense bills to answer.
John Reid appears another obsessive and better he is not in the Cabinet,
Brown and Mandelson could survive in the Bunker against a Labour revolt? Most will tow the party line.
It does not matter what New Labour do. They face annihilation.
I expect in the coming months we will see New Labour MPs jumping ship to other parties so they can increase survival chances?