Britain’s National Health Service would face a staffing crisis if the country were too pull out of the European Union and medical research would be materially damaged, a survey of hospital leaders has found.
Brexit campaigners have put the future of NHS front and centre of their efforts to persuade the public to back a vote to leave in the referendum. Senior figures like Boris Johnson have claimed that up to £350 million more a week could be spent on the health service that, they say, currently gets sent to Brussels.
But the survey of NHS Trust chief executives and chairs reveals deep scepticism about the claims made by the leave campaign with 75 per cent saying that Brexit would have a negative impact on the NHS as a whole. No respondents felt that leaving the EU would have a ‘very positive’ impact.
Among the findings of the survey by NHS Providers that represents 96 per cent of the 238 NHS Trusts were:
- More than third of those questioned felt leaving the EU would have some or a very negative impact on the amount of funding the NHS receives. However 40 per cent felt leaving the EU would have no impact on the amount of funding the NHS receives.
- Almost two-thirds (65%) felt that leaving the EU would have a negative impact on access to knowledge from clinical trials, networks or other research and innovation while 80 per cent felt that leaving the EU would have a negative impact on access to funding for research and innovation.
- However over two fifths (42 per cent) felt that leaving the EU would have some or a very positive impact on procurement and competition rules affecting their trusts.
Perhaps the most significant finding was on staffing where 8 in 10 respondents felt that leaving the EU would have a negative impact on trusts’ efforts to recruit health and care staff.
Around 17,000 (17,138) nurses and health visitors are from EU countries accounting for 6 per cent of the total staffing numbers.
The figure for doctors is even higher with just under 10,000 hospital doctors coming from EU countries – around nine per cent of the total.
Commenting on the findings, NHS Providers chief executive, Chris Hopson, said overall it was clear that NHS leaders were sceptical about the case for Brexit.
The most scaremongering arguments for Brexit
The most scaremongering arguments for Brexit
1/7 22 May 2015
In his regular column in The Express Nigel Farage utilised the concerns over Putin and the EU to deliver a tongue in cheek conclusion. “With friends like these, who needs enemies?”
2/7 13 November 2015
UKIP MEP for Yorkshire and North Lincolnshire Mike Hookem, was one of several political figures who took no time to harness the toxic atmosphere just moments after Paris attacks to push an agenda. “Cameron says we’re safer in the EU. Well I’m in the centre of the EU and it doesn’t feel very safe.”
3/7 19 April 2016
In an article written for The Guardian, Michael Gove attempts to bolster his argument with a highly charged metaphor in which he likens UK remaining in the EU to a hostage situation. “We’re voting to be hostages locked in the back of the car and driven headlong towards deeper EU integration.”
4/7 26 April 2016
In a move that is hard to decipher, let alone understand, Mike Hookem stuck it to Obama re-tweeting a UKIP advertisement that utilises a quote from the film: ‘Love Actually’ to dishonour the US stance on the EU. “A friend who bullies us is no longer a friend”
5/7 10 May 2016
During a speech in London former work and pensions secretary Ian Duncan Smith said that EU migration would cause an increasing divide between people who benefit from immigration and people who couldn’t not find work because of uncontrolled migration. “The European Union is a ‘force for social injustice’ which backs the ‘haves rather than the have-nots.”
6/7 15 May 2016
Cartoon character Boris Johnson made the news again over controversial comments that the EU had the same goal as Hitler in trying to create a political super state. “Napoleon, Hitler, various people tried this out, and it ends tragically.” “The EU is an attempt to do this by different methods.”
7/7 16 May 2016
During a tour of the women’s clothing manufacturer David Nieper, Boris had ample time to cook up a new metaphor, arguably eclipsing Gove’s in which he compares the EU to ‘badly designed undergarments.’ “So I just say to all those who prophecy doom and gloom for the British Business, I say their pants are on fire. Let’s say knickers to the pessimists, knickers to all those who talk Britain down.”
“In response to the big question on whether leaving the EU would have a negative impact on the NHS, the vast majority of NHS leaders in our sample believed it would,” he said.
“This is not an exit poll and we do not claim this to be extensive research of the whole NHS, but it does show us the strength of feeling on what could be a generation-defining decision.
“Our survey shows the concern NHS leaders have about a range of issues if the UK were to exit the EU. High up this list of concerns is the impact on recruiting staff and access to funding for research and innovation.”
NHS Providers added that around 25 per cent of chairs and chief executives from England’s hospital, ambulance, mental health and community trusts had responded to the survey which is in line with other surveys carried out by the organisation.
Professor Martin McKee, Professor of European Public Health at the London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, and a member of the campaign group Better In said it was clear that leaving Europe would open the NHS up to future risk
“From the leaders of NHS trusts, to doctors, former health secretaries and the Chief Executive of NHS England himself, the people who work in and care about the NHS are clear that it is stronger in Europe, while leaving would put it at risk,” he said.
“Being part of the EU also means the NHS benefits from funding for vital medical research, co-operation in fighting diseases like cancer, and the hard work of over 100,000 EU citizens in our health system.
“Our NHS is stronger in Europe, while leaving would be a leap in the dark that would put it at risk.”