Labour’s opposition to any British involvement in military action against Islamic State (Isis) in Syria has intensified, despite the massacre in Paris.
Shadow Foreign Secretary Hilary Benn said the co-ordinated attacks on the French capital, which left at least 127 dead, were an “act of war” – but all but ruled out backing UK air strikes in response.
He said that the idea of British action against Isis in Syria should be put to one side until the country’s civil war had been brought to an end.
Mr Benn, speaking exclusively to The Independent on Sunday, said that the Government should drop plans for a new House of Commons vote authorising military attacks in Syria to concentrate on peace talks and providing humanitarian support for refugees.
His intervention dramatically undermines David Cameron’s hopes of joining the United States-led action against Isis in its Syrian heartland. The Prime Minister, who insisted the French fight against IS was also Britain’s, has maintained he will not ask MPs to authorise RAF bombing raids in Syria until a “political consensus” has been reached.
The world mourns Paris attacks - in pictures
The world mourns Paris attacks - in pictures
1/25 The world mourns Paris attacks
Members of the public gather to lay flowers and light candles at La Belle Equipe restaraunt on Rue de Charonne in Paris
2/25 The world mourns Paris attacks
People lay a memorial to honour victims of the Paris terror attacks at Federation Square in Melbourne, Australia
3/25 The world mourns Paris attacks
Soccer fans display the colors of the French flag in response to the deadly terrorist attack in Paris, France before the soccer match between the New York Cosmos' and the Ottawa Fury for the North American Soccer League championship at Hofstra University in Hempstead, New York, USA
4/25 The world mourns Paris attacks
Pakistani Civil society activists shout slogans during a protest against Isis militants near the French consulate for the victims of the 13 November Paris attacks in Karachi, Pakistan
5/25 The world mourns Paris attacks
People gather and view messages written on the ground at Place de la Republique in Paris
6/25 The world mourns Paris attacks
French flags and a note reading "We will not let you spoil our children's lives" at the site of the attack at the Cafe Belle Equipe on rue de Charonne in the 11th district, in Paris
7/25 The world mourns Paris attacks
A rose is placed beside a bullet hole at La Belle Equipe restaraunt on Rue de Charonne following the terrorist attack in Paris. As France observes three days of national mourning members of the public continue to pay tribute to the victims of deadly attacks
8/25 The world mourns Paris attacks
People gather for a national service for the victims of the terror attack at Notre Dame cathedral in Paris
9/25 The world mourns Paris attacks
Bono and band members of U2 pay their respects and place flowers on the pavement near the scene of yesterday's Bataclan Theatre terrorist attack in Paris
10/25 The world mourns Paris attacks
A man kneels as he pays tribute to victims at Place de la Republique near the deadly attack sites in Paris
11/25 The world mourns Paris attacks
Tributes to the victims at the Place de la Republique square in Paris
12/25 The world mourns Paris attacks
An electronic billboard on a canal show solidarity with Paris in Milan
13/25 The world mourns Paris attacks
People lay down flowers and light candles to tribute victims of Friday's attacks in Paris as the Brandenburg gate is illuminated in blue, white and red in the colors of the French flag, in Berlin
14/25 The world mourns Paris attacks
A man leaves flowers as a tribute following the deadly attacks in Paris, outside the French consulate in Istanbul
15/25 The world mourns Paris attacks
People take pictures of flowers placed in bullet holes in the window of a Japanese restaurant next to the cafe 'La Belle Equipe'
16/25 The world mourns Paris attacks
People gather at a makeshift memorial next to the Bataclan theatre in Paris on November 14, 2015,
17/25 The world mourns Paris attacks
A woman carrying flowers cries in front of the Carillon cafe and the Petit Cambodge restaurant in Paris
18/25 The world mourns Paris attacks
People gather in front of flowers that were laid outside the French embassy in Rome
19/25 The world mourns Paris attacks
People react near the cafe 'La Belle Equipe' at the Rue de Charonne
20/25 The world mourns Paris attacks
A young girl places a candle in front of the Carillon cafe in Paris
21/25 The world mourns Paris attacks
Flowers placed outside the cafe 'La Belle Equipe' at the Rue de Charonne in Paris, the scene for one of the attacks
22/25 The world mourns Paris attacks
A woman is comforted by others outside the Carillon cafe and the Petit Cambodge restaurant in Paris
23/25 The world mourns Paris attacks
The Brandenbourg Gate featuring French national colors is pictured in Berlin, on November 14, 2015 a day after deadly attacks in Paris
24/25 The world mourns Paris attacks
Flowers are laid in front of the French embassy in Rome
25/25 The world mourns Paris attacks
A candle is lit next to flowers outside the French Embassy in Berlin
But Mr Benn said the “terrible events in Paris” meant it was “even more important that we bring the Syrian civil war to an end” before considering air strikes on Isis.
He outlined his thinking: “Why? Because the vacuum in which Isil/Daesh [Islamic State] in Syria thrives is a consequence of that civil war.
“Therefore I hope that the talks that are taking place really will redouble their efforts to say, look we’ve got a find a way of bringing this to a conclusion – we’ve got to bring this to an end.
“Because then, people can then really focus their efforts on the threat from Isil/Daesh and the circumstances in Syria will have changed.”
Mr Benn, who supports military intervention to protect civilians, said he did not think the Government was planning to come forward with a proposal to extend air strikes from Iraq into Syria.
But asked if he thought they should, Mr Benn said: “No.” He added: “They have to come up with an overall plan, which they have not done. I think the focus for now is finding a peaceful solution to the civil war.”
The shadow Foreign Secretary added: “The most useful contribution we can make is to support as a nation the peace talks that have started. That is the single most important thing we can do.”
Mr Benn’s intervention came in a wide-ranging interview in which he said he was “certain” that Jeremy Corbyn could become Prime Minister in 2020, and revealed that he first met the Labour leader as a youngster when he was doing his homework while his dad held meetings with political supporters.
However, it is Mr Benn’s remarks against Syrian intervention which are likely to cause the most concern in Downing Street.
The Prime Minister has insisted that it does not make sense to bomb Isis positions in Iraq – where Britain and other powers have permission to intervene – but not in neighbouring Syria.
Ministers, led by the Defence Secretary Michael Fallon, have warned that the jihadi terror group is planning attacks against Britain as well as France from its stronghold in northern Syria – and that the nominal border with Iraq is irrelevant because it is not recognised by the terrorists.
However, it is unclear whether there is a majority in the Commons to extend British military action into Syria, with up to 30 Tory MPs understood to have reservations.
While a sizeable number of Labour MPs support intervention, the vast majority are unlikely to defy the party leadership to support Mr Cameron.
MPs’ scepticism towards military action hardened after the Tory-led Foreign Affairs Select Committee called on the government to rule out the prospect until a strategy had been developed to defeat IS. Mr Benn said Russia’s intervention into the conflict to prop up President Bashar al-Assad had complicated matters even further, and called for a negotiated peace.
He said: “The government has come to realise the Russian military intervention has changed the position on the ground, and I think that has given them pause for thought.”
Mr Benn said Labour would only consider backing air strikes in Syria if Mr Cameron had the support of the United Nations.
He also outlined his plans for a reformed UN with five new members of the Security Council – Brazil, Germany, India, Japan and one country from Africa.
Mr Benn hailed Mr Corbyn’s election as Labour leader – insisting his “stonking victory” had “enthused a whole new generation of people to take part in politics”.
He said: “Jeremy is very, very open – there is ferment of ideas. Look at some of the positive policies that he has been putting forward – look at the railways. I think this is a time of great opportunity for the Labour party – but having said that we need to win the public’s trust and confidence. Jeremy knows that.”Reuse content