The “horrible” planned TTIP trade treaty is not a good reason to leave the European Union, Caroline Lucas has said.
The Green Party MP said she was strongly against the controversial trade agreement, which is being negotiated in secret between the EU and US, but that Brexit would not save Britain from its effects.
She said the British government was one of the main driving forces behind the treaty at EU level and that outside the bloc a Conservative government would likely pursue similar policies.
“People say ‘how can you support the EU when the EU is negotiating this horrible trade treaty with the US’ – and it is a horrible trade treaty,” she said.
“But you know what? David Cameron and our government is one of the chief cheerleaders for TTIP. The idea that if we left the EU we’d have a lovely, cuddly trade policy in its place is a fantasy.”
Little is known for certain about TTIP because of the secretive way it is being drawn up. However, leaks from negotiations suggest it will include a system called “investor-state dispute settlement” (ISDS) included in similar agreements around the world.
ISDS establishes an international quasi-court that multinational corporations can use to sue national governments that enact policies that harm their profits or contravene trade rules.
At the last election Labour said it would exempt the NHS from the effects of TTIP, but there are concerns such an agreement could be used to push through privatisations or outsourcing through the back door.
Figures in the Leave campaign have previously suggested that outside the EU Britain could negotiate free trade agreements with countries around the world, including the United States.
Ms Lucas, who was speaking at the launch of Another Europe is Possible – an alternative remain campaign that seeks to change the EU – said the best way to defeat TTIP and deals like it was to fight against it within the EU.
The most scaremongering arguments for Brexit
The most scaremongering arguments for Brexit
1/7 22 May 2015
In his regular column in The Express Nigel Farage utilised the concerns over Putin and the EU to deliver a tongue in cheek conclusion. “With friends like these, who needs enemies?”
2/7 13 November 2015
UKIP MEP for Yorkshire and North Lincolnshire Mike Hookem, was one of several political figures who took no time to harness the toxic atmosphere just moments after Paris attacks to push an agenda. “Cameron says we’re safer in the EU. Well I’m in the centre of the EU and it doesn’t feel very safe.”
3/7 19 April 2016
In an article written for The Guardian, Michael Gove attempts to bolster his argument with a highly charged metaphor in which he likens UK remaining in the EU to a hostage situation. “We’re voting to be hostages locked in the back of the car and driven headlong towards deeper EU integration.”
4/7 26 April 2016
In a move that is hard to decipher, let alone understand, Mike Hookem stuck it to Obama re-tweeting a UKIP advertisement that utilises a quote from the film: ‘Love Actually’ to dishonour the US stance on the EU. “A friend who bullies us is no longer a friend”
5/7 10 May 2016
During a speech in London former work and pensions secretary Ian Duncan Smith said that EU migration would cause an increasing divide between people who benefit from immigration and people who couldn’t not find work because of uncontrolled migration. “The European Union is a ‘force for social injustice’ which backs the ‘haves rather than the have-nots.”
6/7 15 May 2016
Cartoon character Boris Johnson made the news again over controversial comments that the EU had the same goal as Hitler in trying to create a political super state. “Napoleon, Hitler, various people tried this out, and it ends tragically.” “The EU is an attempt to do this by different methods.”
7/7 16 May 2016
During a tour of the women’s clothing manufacturer David Nieper, Boris had ample time to cook up a new metaphor, arguably eclipsing Gove’s in which he compares the EU to ‘badly designed undergarments.’ “So I just say to all those who prophecy doom and gloom for the British Business, I say their pants are on fire. Let’s say knickers to the pessimists, knickers to all those who talk Britain down.”
“If you put right wing bigotry into the EU, surprise, surprise, you get right wing bigotry out. That is what we have to change," she said
“The best chance of fighting TTIP is working with our colleagues across Europe, three million of whom have signed a petition against TTIP. 250,000 of whom were marching in the streets of Berlin.
“The French government themselves are now looking as if they might block it too. That is our best way of defeating TTIP.
“We need to build a political momentum here for a better Europe – but let’s make that distinction between the institutions and the current right wing policies of the governments that sit around it.”
More generally, Ms Lucas said the EU needed to “change its end goals too, away from greater competition and privatisation towards more cooperation and stronger public services”.
“I think we need to distinguish between the institutions of the EU and the very broad policies that are coming out of it right now because there’s a majority of right-wing governments sitting around that table right now,” he added.
Nobel prize-winning economist Joseph Stiglitz suggested in March this year that Britain would be better off leaving the EU if TTIP passed.
He described the agreement as “a massive rewriting of the rules with no public discussion”.
“The dangers to our society are very significant,” he said at the time.
Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn has however also said the treaty is best fought from within the EU.
The in-out referendum on EU membership will be held on 23 June this year. Phone polls suggest a lead for the Remain campaign, while online polls show a closer race.Reuse content