Watchdog criticises PM over immigration figures
Wednesday 31 March 2010
Latest in UK Politics
On Facebook
From the blogs
The ugly face of TV: How Jeremy Clarkson brought facial prejudice to a head
If you saw someone with a facial disfigurement walking down the street, would you A) Laugh at them B...
Atlantic Odyssey: Exclusive first hand account of how a world record attempt ended in near disaster
Writing exclusively for The Independent, Mark Beaumont recounts the incredible events that saw an at...
Stacking shelves won’t help career progression
Over the last week, we have seen a series of dodgy manoeuvres by the government regarding unpaid ret...
Is catastrophic global warming, like the Millennium Bug, a mistake?
"The whole idea of climate being one number driven by another number is nutty." Prof Richard Lindzen...
Prime Minister Gordon Brown was criticised by the national statistics watchdog today for mis-using immigration statistics.
Sir Michael Scholar said the PM used data that was "not comparable" in a podcast last week.
The podcast prompted complaints from opposition politicians, who accused Mr Brown of misleading the public on migrant numbers.
In a letter published today, Sir Michael pointed to two errors in the Downing Street internet broadcast.
Mr Brown claimed net inward migration - the number of arrivals minus those leaving - had fallen from 237,000 in 2007 to 163,000 in 2008 and 147,000 last year.
But Sir Michael said the correct figure for 2007 was 233,000. More seriously, he said the 147,000 figure used by Mr Brown was wrong because it was taken from a different data set which has not yet been adjusted.
It was taken from the International Passenger Survey, while the figures Mr Brown used for 2007 and 2008 were Long Term International Migration figures.
In previous years the final LTIM number has been up to 34,000 higher than the IPS data.
Sir Michael wrote that he hoped the political parties would be "careful" in their use of statistics in coming weeks.
He wrote: "I have received representations from several sources about your recent podcast on migration.
"I attach a note, prepared by the ONS, on these statistics. You will see that the note points out that the podcast did not use comparable data series for 2007 to 2009, and that it did not take account of the revised estimate of long-term net immigration for 2007.
"I note that in your speech today you correctly referred to the statistics in respect of migration for the period 2007 to 2009.
"The Statistics Authority hopes that, in the political debate over the coming weeks, all parties will be careful in their use of statistics, to protect the integrity of official statistics."
Shadow home secretary Chris Grayling said: "Gordon Brown is turning into a serial offender in misleading the British people in the run-up to the election.
"He gave false information to the Chilcot inquiry, his advertising campaign about policing was banned, and now he has given an inaccurate picture of his record on immigration. Britain should expect better from its Prime Minister. No wonder we need change."
- 1 How an A-grade prank by a hacker closed a school for a day
- 2 Gallery: Rio Carnival in full swing
- 3 Paradise lust: the man who sexed up America
- 4 Journalists killed in Syria rocket strike 'were targeted'
- 5 New RBS bonus storm
- 6 Prosecutor tells Mubarak he faces death by hanging
- 7 Top Tory attacks PM for Murdoch 'cronyism'
- 1 Last bow for Blur at Brit awards?
- 2 How an A-grade prank by a hacker closed a school for a day
- 3 Copenhagen, probably the best city in the world
- 4 Robert Fisk: 'If only Hague and Clinton would listen to Yusuf Islam'
- 5 How did a man buried in this frozen car for two months come out of it alive?
- 6 The sci-fi movie Hollywood would not dare to make
- 7 Ian McKellen: What's wrong with us? Should we not aspire to happiness?
- 8 Mark Steel: Iraq was such a laugh, let's do it to Iran
- 9 Aborted baby lived 45 minutes
- 10 Journalists killed in Syria rocket strike 'were targeted'
Win an adventure with Subaru XV
Enjoy a three-night family adventure for four to Slaley Hall in Northumberland.
Delivering network infrastructure for London 2012
Cisco is maximising connectivity for the Olympic and Paralympic Games.
Free trial of our new iPad app
Get your daily dose of the best of British journalism, sponsored by American Airlines
Amazing restaurant offers
Three glasses of free champagne and a special menu at 46 top London restaurants.
Latest Independent competitions
Win anything from gadgets to five-star holidays on our competitions and offers page.
Commercial thought leaders
Watch the best in the business world give their insights into the world of business.
Career Services
Day In a Page
Can we pull the plug on the plug?
The 10 Best Lecture Series
Michael Frayn: Still making a big noise




Comments