Afghan leader accused of bid to 'legalise rape'
UN and women MPs say Karzai bowed to Islamic fundamentalists before poll
AFP/Getty Images
Afghan women wearing burqas. Critics say President Hamid Karzai rushed through discriminatory legislation to appease fundamentalists
Afghanistan's President, Hamid Karzai, has signed a law which "legalises" rape, women's groups and the United Nations warn. Critics claim the president helped rush the bill through parliament in a bid to appease Islamic fundamentalists ahead of elections in August.
In a massive blow for women's rights, the new Shia Family Law negates the need for sexual consent between married couples, tacitly approves child marriage and restricts a woman's right to leave the home, according to UN papers seen by The Independent.
"It is one of the worst bills passed by the parliament this century," fumed Shinkai Karokhail, a woman MP who campaigned against the legislation. "It is totally against women's rights. This law makes women more vulnerable."
The law regulates personal matters like marriage, divorce, inheritance and sexual relations among Afghanistan's minority Shia community. "It's about votes," Ms Karokhail added. "Karzai is in a hurry to appease the Shia because the elections are on the way."
The provisions are reminiscent of the hardline Taliban regime, which banned women from leaving their homes without a male relative. But in a sign of Afghanistan's faltering steps towards gender equality, politicians who opposed it have been threatened.
"There are moderate views among the Shia, but unfortunately our MPs, the people who draft the laws, rely on extremists," Ms Karokhail said.
The bill lay dormant for more than a year, but in February it was rushed through parliament as President Karzai sought allies in a constitutional row over the upcoming election. Senator Humeira Namati claimed it wasn't even read out in the Upper House, let alone debated, before it was passed to the Supreme Court. "They accused me of being an unbeliever," she said.
Details of the law emerged after Mr Karzai was endorsed by Afghanistan's Supreme Court to stay in power until elections scheduled in August. Some MPs claimed President Karzai was under pressure from Iran, which maintains a close relationship with Afghanistan's Shias. The most controversial parts of the law deal explicitly with sexual relations. Article 132 requires women to obey their husband's sexual demands and stipulates that a man can expect to have sex with his wife at least "once every four nights" when travelling, unless they are ill. The law also gives men preferential inheritance rights, easier access to divorce, and priority in court.
A report by the United Nations Development Fund for Women, Unifem, warned: "Article 132 legalises the rape of a wife by her husband".
Most of Afghanistan's Shias are ethnic Hazaras, descended from Genghis Khan's Mongol army which swept through the entire region around 700 years ago. They are Afghanistan's third largest ethnic group, and potential kingmakers, because their leaders will likely back a mainstream candidate.
Even the law's sponsors admit Mr Karzai rushed it through to win their votes. Ustad Mohammad Akbari, a prominent Shia political leader, said: "It's electioneering. Most of the Hazara people are unhappy with Mr Karzai."
A British Embassy spokesman said diplomats had raised concerns "at a senior level".
View all comments that have been posted about this article.
Offensive or abusive comments will be removed and your IP logged and may be used to prevent further submission. In submitting a comment to the site, you agree to be bound by the Independent Minds Terms of Service.
- Print Article
- Email Article
-
Click here for copyright permissions
Copyright 2009 Independent News and Media Limited



Comments
Theres no difference between islamic fundamentalists and christian ones
I can't remember the last time I heard about the Catholic Church strapping suicide vests to bishops.
Sick...
But as women can vote in Afghanistan, I sincerely hope that they off Karzai's head at the polls!
What about Saudi Arabia they're not the best at treating their women or Kuwait or several other Arabic countries.
But why stop there why don't we move over to America where the Mormons think they can have all the women they want for wives starting at age 16. And they're not even connected to radical Islam. Their white and there Americans.
And of course we need to stop and ask the pope about all those choirboys that walk funny after a good catholic preaching. And how many nuns have babies.
Or we could travel to India and watch the Hindu believers stoning women that go into a bar or celebrate Valentine's Day.
Or we could travel to Israel, where prostitution is legal and they have the highest European female smuggling statistics.
Or we could stay in Europe where billions of dollars are spent on pornography which some people say is exploitation of women.
Don't you think the protection of women and their rights and dignity should start at home. With equal pay, no sexual discrimination on the job, and a list of other things.
Think to yourself what you keep reading all kinds of propaganda about Afghanistan?
Ex President Bush lied to the world about Iraq right along with Tony Blair so why do you believe anything these two countries have said about Afghanistan?
I'm not saying they don't treat their women like crap, what I'm asking is why we're reading about it almost on a daily basis?
Answer propaganda to give us a feel good reason to go kill more afghanis. We'll move on to Pakistan next take care their problems. And then we'll move on to?
This is a very scary development for women in Afghanistan, especially in light of talks about negotiating with Taleban. Because any negotiations will automatically come at a high price for women's rights and liberties, however non-existent they are already for Afhgan women.
So like voodoo says people,open your eyes and see the reality of the insanity of religious philosophy interpreted by men. Well, actually all religion is a man made phenomenon anyway. All religions are cults, yes ALL religions.
Here's a glimpse of the plight of Afghan women in the hands of Karzai's warlords:
The new law allows men to rape their wives. You are citing warlords who have violent control of areas raping and no dounbt doing lots of other violent things with impunity. They don't have to obey any law, because they are in control, and no democratic rule applies.
Presumablly the war lords can rape their own wives now, just as can any other man.
The two types of violence are created bydifferent things, both bad. The second is religion.
The West is pouring millions into the country to try and improve the lives of the people (men and Women) and establish fair government and law enforcement after the tyranny of the Taliban who sole aim is to banish all forms of pleasure and joy in the country which we take for granted.
Karzai has effectively taken a step which is going back to oppression and discrimination, I think this is worthy of comment, which as I read Independent every day is not reported everyday
By the way the producers of porn get plenty of women wanting to work in the "industry" they don't compel anyone to do it, it is only exploitation if people are forced to do it
Why would you say this about me? For telling the truth!
Why don't you read my entire post and you get the answer.
The articles about Afghanistan are being use as propaganda for reasons to back a war in Afghanistan.
The west is not there to improve the lives of the people in Afghanistan and neither were the Russians.
You don't improve people's lives by bombing and killing women and children, and occupying their country.
And if we're so concerned, then why does the United States and Britain continue to do business With Countries that severely treat their women like crap?
We never question Saudi Arabia and we've been doing business with that country for over 50 years.
It is also known as the birthplace of radical Islam but not one bomb has ever dropped their.
I could go down a list of countries that we support and we do business with that also treat their women horribly but not one word will ever be mentioned about those countries because there are Allies.
Oh, right, so the repressive woman-hating regime will be on our side and not on the other side. What was the pother side again?
Bishops, popes, mullahs, or any religious preacher: same rubbish!
It is wright that Shinkay Karrokhel is a MP member. but you have to know that many Afghan MPs dont have that much knowledge to express. clear. and say the fect and reality.The law depend to Shia peaple and Shia woman. Have your reporter asked any Shia women? What do you think yourselve?Is it a good report? I have a every night programme in Tamaddon TV tonight I said about your report. and how you report. Have a nice time. Sayyed Ali Hosaini . Kabol
Western news delivers stories about what happens in Islamic countries in an way that makes it acceptable to the Western public. So dont be too surprised if the story concentrates on a particular aspect or tells it in a way that doesnt give the complete picture or background information.
You are right to point out that this is not relevant to the Islam in general but only a specific law for a Shia minority tradition. These specific details are not picked up by Western readers because they have a cursory and selective knowledge of Islam (and that again has been gained through the Western media network).
Wrong!
Once again the media mixes up local traditions with Islamic law.
In Islam, forced marriage is forbidden.
possessions of their husbands. Men want to run everything and do not want women to have a say in anything.
Stupidity and greed has no boundries.....
I'll be speaking with mine later today, I hope. I only hope that this foul man is not elected again.
Your wives are as a tilth unto you;so approach your tilth how and when you will. But do........
Riyad-us-Saliheen:-
Abu Ali Talq Ali (RA) reported:- Messenger of Allah (SAW) said when a man calls his wife to satisfy his desire, she must go to him even if she is occupied with the oven.
Says it all really.
Before Paul Bremmer (US) left Iraq, he removed all the Laws of that country and replaced them with new ones, which in part, removed the CAPITAL OFFENCE of rape, among other disturbing additions and removals. There's also new Laws that favour mostly US, British oil companies re their future profits that over-ride the rights of the workers and people of Iraq - the people will lose billions over the next years!
There are at least 30 sexual assaults in Australia each day. Only a small percentage of these make it to Court, and although, recently we have Laws that protect the victim from havingn to face her alleged attacker in Court, it still is a demeaning and too frequently fruitless task, taking the perpetrator to Court.
37% of women have admitted to being physically and or sexually abused by their male partner in an intimate relationship - the older a woman is, the more chance she's experienced abuse. Being killed or assaulted by a man who purports to love you, is still the greatest physical threat to women in Australia - the risk of being killed in this manner is higher than breast cancer, assaults by a stranger or other illnesses in our community. I'm sure that in other Western countries, the stats are either this bad or worse. Leaving a violent relationship is no guarantee of protection - many women are killed AFTER they leave the relationship - sadly, many children are killed too! So, let's not be smug, and wear a superior grin when it comes to crimes of violence against women and girls - whether they're in a relationship or unknown to their assailant.
The use of sexual violence against women and children is a weapon of war - used by all countries, regardless of creed or colour. It's an epidemic with horrific stats! We need to be vocal always about its prevelance in all societies and across all cultures, incomes and areas of employment. It's all to easy to become boastful and complacent upon hearing such horrific stories like this one. When each person,particularly males, stand up and speak out against this horrific violence against women and girls, the rest of us have no right to feel complacent. It's a continuing struggle, and we don't have the luxury of taking a rest.
To find out the real reason for the invasion of Afghanistan, go to, "From Afghanistan to Iraq-Joining the dots with OIL" It's on the Alternet website, but should come up if you put it in your search engine! The truth will be revealed, including the role played by Karzai over the years. It doesn't surprise me that he went along with this - he's never cared for the people of Afghanistan - men, women or children!
Men in the West, don't feel smug! Only when you stand up to those you hear treating women in a demeaning manner, will violence of this type be eliminated. Many brave men come forward each year on White Ribbon Day - we need more!
I would really appreciate it if journalists like Jerome Starkey would take the time to study the claims that people are making. That way when false claims are being made (like in this case) it should be mentioned in the text of the article. It is part of the job of the journalist to check their facts. Especially since there is already so much misinformation on Islam already.
This is a good source for correct information on Shi'a Islam - www.al-islam.org
Thank you
Then their regime oppresses women, kills widows who try to feed their children and hide terriorists
Then we pour billions of dollars for war against terrorists in Afghanistan and new regime
Then that regime not only oppresses women but legislates husbands can rape wives
So women are now property again to husbands, brothers and fathers
What religion that is run by men for men cares about women and children rights?
Where is the kinder, gentler world?
War begets war. War on the people.
Stop war. Work for peace.
In the US we need to pass Womens Equal Rights Admendment to our Constitution.
Pamela
None, because ths refuses women to take part in no such activity.
It bans women from just about everything,
It's also women abuse, from sexual to anything.
This concludes to just show that the Men think women mean nothing.
Women have bared the child why can't they have the rights to the child.?
And now, Karzai and his cronies, in an effort to maintain power, through pandering to foreign and internal pressures, has passed a law that legalises rape and violence against women. Makes me pleased to have hung up my spurs and left the country, for even though some of my tax is still paying for this, I want to tell you that this is not being done in my name. Probably not yours, either.
I ask the question - in whose name is this being done? Then someone can explain to the amputee in a hospital in Solihull, or a widow in Catterick, or a grieving mother in Plymouth. Just be sure to look them in the eye when you do so.
And now, Karzai and his cronies, in an effort to maintain power, through pandering to foreign and internal pressures, has passed a law that legalises rape and violence against women. While it is dangerous to make judgements about other societies and make comparisons with one's own, it has to be more dangerous to actively participate and support a society which appears to have mores and policies that are so divergent from one's own.
All this makes me both sad and pleased to have hung up my spurs and left the country, for even though some of my tax is still paying for this, I want to tell you that this is not being done in my name. Probably not yours, either.
I ask the question - in whose name is this being done? Then someone can explain to the amputee in a hospital in Solihull, or a widow in Catterick, or a grieving mother in Plymouth. Just be sure to look them in the eye when you do so.
Laptop Battery Laptop Battery Laptop Batteries Laptop Batteries discount laptop battery discount laptop battery notebook battery notebook battery computer battery computer battery replacement laptop battery replacement laptop battery notebook batteries notebook batteries