90,000 French GPs go on strike until New Year’s Day - over plans that would make health system more like the NHS

Medical unions object to plans to make the country’s debt-ridden and flailing health system – paid for by patients in surgeries – more like the NHS. John Lichfield reports from Paris

Click to follow
The Independent Online

For 66 years, care which is free at the point of delivery has been integral to the NHS. Across the Channel, however, the issue is dividing the sprawling and economically flailing French health system.

And now, the raging debate will trigger mass strikes in protest against planned reforms. Thousands of GPs and specialists oppose changes modelled on those in Britain which, they say, will turn the independent French medical profession into servants of the state bureaucracy.

Doctors will launch an eight-day walkout today against plans to make the French state health service more like the NHS. The government wants the French system – excellent, but perennially in the red – to adopt the principle of “free at the point of delivery”, which has been hard-wired in the NHS since its creation in 1948.

The Health Minister, Marisol Touraine, says that deep reforms are needed to control the state health budget of €170bn (£133.5bn), which will be €7bn in the red this year. But critics argue that switching to a free-at-delivery system will actually increase costs by encouraging more people to visit doctors for trivial reasons.

Ms Touraine accepts that this may be the case, but she needs a “socialist” coating to her reforms to sweeten the spending cuts that she hopes to impose next year. Free at the point of delivery would, she argues, remove “obstacles and inequalities” in the delivery of healthcare.

At present, patients pay €23 for each GP visit – more for specialists – and then reclaim €15.10 from the state health service and the balance from their work or private insurance scheme. In future, visits would be free and it would be up to the doctor to claim his or her money.

Another proposed reform would allow chemists to administer routine vaccinations. Doctors’ unions say that this will slash the already low income of many GPs.

A new system of regional health bodies would control spending (again broadly reminiscent of the NHS). Unions protest that the regional “commissars” would effectively end the tradition that most French doctors are “liberal”, or independent of the state system.

Doctors are also demanding an increase in their “basic” fee to €25 – and pro-rata increases for specialists.

A high proportion of the 90,000 “liberal” or independent doctors will join the strike, due to end on New Year’s Day. Emergency cover has been organised, but many surgeries will be closed at a period of high demand.

A separate dispute over working hours in accident and emergency wards appeared to have been resolved last night, allowing patients deprived of GPs to turn to A&E departments if necessary.

Behind the anger lies the fact that French doctors – especially GPs – earn less than those in almost all other Western European countries. The average earnings of a GP in France are €60,000 (£47,000) a year. This compares with the UK average of £100,000 for partners in GP practices, and £70,000 for those employed by health trusts.


These figures jar with the high total cost to the taxpayer – €170bn a year compared with €143bn (£113bn) for the NHS. The total budget of the French system is around 20 per cent higher. A further share of the costs falls on the private or work insurance schemes called mutuelles.

As a result, France spends 11.9 per cent of GDP on healthcare (of all kinds) compared with 9.6 per cent in the UK. The result is a high-quality system which often comes near the top of world league tables. Critics complain, however, that the service is gold-plated in some areas and dilapidated in others. The budget has been in the red for decades, adding to France’s mountain of debt.

Doctors  complain that too much is spent on bureaucracy, the unnecessary duplication of some facilities and the relatively high consumption and cost of drugs. As a consequence, doctors’ – and other staff – salaries are depressed.

French medical unions also object in principal to the idea of free medical consultations. Jean-Paul Ortiz, head of the largest French medical union, the Confédération des syndicats médicaux français (CSMF), says that the reform would turn the medical identity card carried by all French citizens – the Carte Vitale – into a “credit card”.

“People behave very differently when things are free,” he said. “All sense of responsibility will be removed. A doctor’s visit will become banal.”

Ms Touraine insisted today that the “generalisation of payments by third parties” – jargon for free at the point of delivery – was the “spinal column” of her proposed reforms. “It already operates for nurses and pharmacies in France and for doctors in many other countries,” she said. Government officials say some concessions could be made before the draft law goes to parliament in April but the idea of “free consultations” is essential to win the support of a cuts-weary Socialist majority in the National Assembly.