World

4° London Hi 9°C / Lo 3°C

Cold, hunger and job losses ignite dissent in Russian town

Impoverished workers resort to eating salads of weeds and nettle soup

By Shaun Walker in Moscow

An old man asks the mayor 'to reach into his pocket and give him 1,000 rubles' so he can feed his family

An old man asks the mayor 'to reach into his pocket and give him 1,000 rubles' so he can feed his family

The Kremlin's worst fears are being played out in a small town outside St Petersburg, as angry residents of crisis-hit Pikalevo marched upon the offices of the local mayor and demanded improved living conditions.

The town, with a population of just over 20,000, has been suffering as its three major factories have hit hard times during the economic crisis. Two of them shut down several months ago, while the third has put its workers on shorter shifts. About half of the employees have been put on enforced leave and even those who are still working have not received their salaries for nearly three months.

The final straw came when the town lost its heating and hot water as the only local power station couldn't afford to keep running. Even kindergartens and hospitals were left without hot water. The town's gas supply was also cut off.

"I've worked here since 1976," Vladimir Folev, a shift manager at the power station, told Russian TV. "I couldn't have imagined this in my worst nightmares. This is the first time in history that the town has been left without heating and hot water."

According to a report in Moskovsky Komsomolets newspaper, the impoverished residents of Pikalevo have resorted to eating nettle soup and salads made from dandelions and weeds. The paper also notes that "suspiciously few cats and dogs remain on the streets". One rueful commentator on the town's online forum raises the possibility that shoelaces boiled with salt might taste like spaghetti.

As officials gathered to discuss the situation last Wednesday, locals began to mass outside the town administration's building. Eventually around 100 of them broke into the meeting room.

Dramatic footage captured by a local television station shows a large group of furious residents brushing aside police officers and shoving their way into the room to air their anger. "I want to work!" screams a hysterical young woman. "I want my child to be able to eat normally. I want to buy toys for my children, but I can't because I am not receiving my salary. We want to work, but we can't."

"We don't want war," said Sergei Voronov, another Pikalevo resident. "Let the government work something out. We want things to turn out well, but if they don't, I don't know... God alone knows what will happen."

One of the factories in Pikalevo is affiliated with the vast Basic Element company, which is run by Oleg Deripaska, the poster boy of the crisis-induced collapse of Russia's oligarch class. Last year, Mr Deripaska had a fortune estimated at $40bn (£25.2bn). This year, Finans estimated his net worth to be just $5bn. His company is engaged in a dispute over payments with the local authorities in Pikalevo, making the clash more complex than a simple "people versus government" issue.

Pikalevo is a typical monogorod – a town based entirely around one industry. There are hundreds of such towns in Russia, partly due to the Soviet planned economy legacy. Similar tensions are brewing in many other industrial areas across Russia. Just yesterday about 1,000 miners protested planned cutbacks in a street demonstration in the northern city of Vorkuta. Worried regional officials came to Pikalevo on Friday offering a package of economic aid.

"Given that there are several hundred similar towns across the country, we can expect this sort of thing to happen a lot more," says Dmitry Oreshkin, a political analyst in Moscow.

The protests are unlikely to turn into a popular, coordinated revolt, say most analysts, as opposition infrastructure has been crushed over the past decade.

"There won't be a revolution," says Mr Oreshkin. "But we may well see more of these incidents and they could turn violent."

Post a Comment

View all comments that have been posted about this article.

Offensive or abusive comments will be removed and your IP logged and may be used to prevent further submission. In submitting a comment to the site, you agree to be bound by the Independent Minds Terms of Service.

Comments

parodox
[info]rexxxxxxxx wrote:
Monday, 25 May 2009 at 12:06 am (UTC)
and so recent history seems to show that extreme versions of both communism and capitalism have failed the proletariat.

I wonder what Carl Marx would now suggest was the political road to utopia

extreme liberalism perhaps ?
The oil and gas won't last forever
[info]red_planet92 wrote:
Monday, 25 May 2009 at 12:31 am (UTC)
Perhaps the oil and gas prices will rise and save Russia in the nick of time. But the oil and gas won't last forever; the economy needs diversifying.

An impoversished, under-populated Russia, next to a booming China and a muslim population demanding independent republics . . . I suspect that at some point Russia may break up.

Russian Fascism
[info]living_fossil wrote:
Monday, 25 May 2009 at 08:26 am (UTC)
They won't call it fascism, for historical reasons, but a desperate and cornered animal becomes vicious to very high level.
Russian mentality
[info]krekelin wrote:
Monday, 25 May 2009 at 09:04 am (UTC)
The Russians seized a small portion of Germany at the end of WW2 called East Prussia. Settled by Poles, Germans, Kasubians, Dutch, Swiss, Austrians and some Scots iafter the plague it was a prosperous part of Gemany and its bread basket. After sixty years of Russian management and despite having special trade agreements and some help from Germany and the EEC it has progressed nowhere, is a haven for crime, poverty, alcoholism, drugs and can hardly grow any anything. The Germans would probably turn it around in ten years. Do I need to explain further or does this say anything about the benefits of good management and the ability of people to work hard and the nature of people.
Re: Russian mentality
[info]irishinrussia wrote:
Monday, 25 May 2009 at 01:35 pm (UTC)
This region was devastated by the second world war on a scale never seen in western europe. So was the rest of Western Russia, by WWII, WWI and the Russian civil war. Virtually everything you say could also be applied to our little darling in the Balkans, Kosovo. Iceland may not be too far behind on that path. As for Ireland and the UK, drugs, crime, alcoholism and poverty sounds like a good description of the poorer areas of every city from Glsagow to London. Furthermore this region like Russia did not benefit from "Russian" management in the same way the UK benefited from managing India and Africa, because for all its crimes, one thing the Communists did not do is transfer wealth from poorer regions to the wealthy metropole, instead the RSFSR subsidised its "colonies".
I really wish people did not post what can only be described as thinly veiled racism. To blame the problems of Russia, Africa, Asia, South America etc on a "mentality" problem is drivel. It takes no account of the many social, political and historical events that effect a country's development.
Re: Russian mentality
[info]rex123 wrote:
Tuesday, 26 May 2009 at 07:59 am (UTC)
irishinrussia - I think you are wrong and krekelin is right (although I am Russian myself). Yes, it is possible to draw the scale of nations according to their ability for good-bad management...And, yes, Germans would be on the top of it, I think they are actually superior in this respect then Brits (not to say French, Italian, Greeks etc...) - everybody knows that from literature as well as from expirience. Russians would perform poorly here...But the fact is that those facts should not even be mentioned the same way as normal person would never say to ugly woman -"You are ugly, mam", or one would never say to his old granny that she is much stupider then he is (although it perhaps is 100% true because of natural reasons of age etc...)...Such kind of refering to national mentality by krekelin is 100% racism in judicial definition of this word...If applied not to a group, but to individual person in connection to his nationality (me for example) - it would constitute a criminal offence in Great Britain (not just grounds for civil suit, but CRIMINAL one)...Still, I always look for motivation in that or another action (or posting) - so what is the aim of krekelin in this particular case?
the bad times are gonna get a whole lot worse for all of us soon
[info]tuskerdeman wrote:
Monday, 25 May 2009 at 10:24 am (UTC)
Even now this smokescreen issue hides even more serious and devious practices within Westminster. Theses issues of public concern promoting furore, debate and distraction hides what is truly happening, by quietly invoking into law, further "legal" abuses to our personal private data whilst our backs are turned.

Big issue, very important, read here:
http://www.guardian.co.uk/politics/2009/may/24/jacqui-smith-dna-profile-database

Beyond financial charades, corporate abuses, ministers expenses and many other issues that have become public knowledge in recent times, "the people" are denied proper and open debate on our basic freedoms.

We must stop this.

The Executive Branch of Westminster must warrant the closest scrutiny and investigation on all of the events of recent times immediately.

Write to your MPs, form action groups, contact anyone that may assist in putting a stop to this crime against the people.
Re: the bad times are gonna get a whole lot worse for all of us soon
[info]derricks wrote:
Monday, 25 May 2009 at 12:27 pm (UTC)
To : tuskerdeman
You. Sir, are barmy. You have focussed on exactly the point that doesn't matter a toss. They can keep my DNA for 1000 years as far as I'm concerned. I support anything the Governement does that helps the Cops do their job, and the Courts identify criminals. Your abject barminess is laid bare by your description of people who are slowly starving and are driven to break into buildings run by the local authorities as "a smokescreen".

This "smokescreen" of slow starvation, generational unemployment and the utter despair of the working class in the face of the collapse of international free-market capitalism will be coming to your town too. Probably in the next decade or two as Britain slowly fragments. If you want to "campaign" for something I'd suggest trying to form a political party that puts the rights of the workers before the rights of the bosses, rather than fiddling about with methods of criminal detection.
[info]mr_scummy wrote:
Monday, 25 May 2009 at 12:30 pm (UTC)

These poor people have had to watch helplessly as huge amounts of their country's wealth were snatched by Russian "businessmen" who, despite their dubious backgrounds, are feted by our spineless politicians and permitted to snap up large chunks of London, buy British companies, own football clubs, etc.
What is the recipe for stinging nettle soup?
[info]collin_brown wrote:
Monday, 25 May 2009 at 12:42 pm (UTC)
Never mind - found it. It's always best to be prepared - right? What's that you say? Britain won't go the same way as Russia! Wanna bet your house on that?

http://www.eatweeds.co.uk/noble-peasant%E2%80%99s-nettle-soup-recipe

Re: What is the recipe for stinging nettle soup?
[info]badalandabad wrote:
Monday, 25 May 2009 at 08:51 pm (UTC)
That is if I got my house left! Redundant and unable to keep up the mortgage payments, I won't be having one soon........................................
Re: What is the recipe for stinging nettle soup?
[info]collin_brown wrote:
Monday, 25 May 2009 at 09:16 pm (UTC)
I'm very sorry to hear that. I'm about a year away from facing the same dilemma. Mortgage payments and electricity bills are totally crippling us.
So the author is the communist?
[info]rex123 wrote:
Monday, 25 May 2009 at 03:23 pm (UTC)
Crisis, 3 biggest fctories in the town where population worked closed, citisens go to the streets with a slogan "Do smth!"...Well, well, well...what to do? To nationalise those 3 factories? Introduce ration cards so that citisens just do no attempt to find job in other areas and wait better times on welfare? - actually what free market mean? - if your production is not needed - do smth. else...where it was different way? - right - in USSR!...So?....What this artickle is about and what it is inciting us,poor Russians, to do?....somebody have no jobs, somebody have no brains...everybody is looking for something...
one more point
[info]rex123 wrote:
Monday, 25 May 2009 at 03:56 pm (UTC)
"suspiciously few cats and dogs remain on the streets". One rueful commentator on the town's online forum raises the possibility that shoelaces boiled with salt might taste like spaghetti.
---------------------------------------------------Shall I believe it?-I live in St.Petersburg, not that far from Pikalevo...What would you recommend, seriously, shall I believe it?...What about emergency food aid to Russia?...or it is a charming joke by Independent?...Well, I already believe you that we have no freedom of press here and TV is Government controlled in Russia - so I tend to believe Independent...Shall I?...What Brits are going to do to help Russian kids who according to Independent eat those things mentioned above because of hunger in Picalevo?...
Communists
[info]kuma2000 wrote:
Monday, 25 May 2009 at 07:10 pm (UTC)
Once again Communists still press on when all hope is extinguished, their tenacity amazes me. These guys are like our top Red Brown Gordon who does not know when to throw in the towel. And to think there are still people in Britain who want us to bow down before the Kremlin. As Ronald Reagan once said "The only good communist is a dead communist"
Re: Communists
[info]rex123 wrote:
Monday, 25 May 2009 at 08:26 pm (UTC)
kuma - but the communist in this case is the author of the artickle - that is my point! Look - he incites people to demand actions from the state - that is to demand the involvement of the state into bancrupsy of 3 private businesses...and what kind of involvement should it be - nationalisation? forcing the owners of those factories to continue production which they can not sell on the market?....The artickle is like accusing authorities for a rain, or bad weather...It is impossible to eat the cake and to have it intact the next day...If it is free market - crisis may strike it...if it is communism - there will be other problems, you know those...So what is the aim of this artickle? The author wants some communist reforms to be introduced there to Russia again, or what?...There is no even a hint on the fact that those people are not even trying to find job in some other nearing town, or to start their own buisiness, or to start for example to grow vegetables - so many land there around and Russian agreculture is devastated by absence of work force since everybody mooved to big cities during last 30-40 years...Strange artickle...really strange...
[info]yurism wrote:
Monday, 25 May 2009 at 07:42 pm (UTC)
The protests are unlikely to turn into a popular, coordinated revolt, say most analysts, as opposition infrastructure has been crushed over the past decade.

What kind of bull...t is this? Which opposition infrastructure was "crushed"? The Communist party is still there, and certainly even in this particular town there is local Communist opposition. The problem is that the people hit by the crisis don't want any "coordinated revolt". They got enough of revolutions the last century.
The Great Depression
[info]fuccup wrote:
Tuesday, 26 May 2009 at 11:35 am (UTC)
The Great Repuglican Depression, falling over the U.S. as we speak, and spreading through-out the world like the plague or worse, is simply the emotion we feel when the gap between our expectations and our input/output widens. We are soon back to the huts of the middle ages, without the forests, trees, animals to hunt, and are in desperate fear of starvation, the moment the collective effort, under socialism, communism or capitalism fails. Hidden by skillful propaganda and absent in the American press by covert command or flat out shame, many warm-state Americans are now living in "Hoovervilles" - Tent cities, with nothing but the clothes on their backs, no jobs and eating anything that moves, squirrels, rodents, dogs cats, road kill, deer, possum, badgers, and boiled grasses, while the rich Americans pass by in new Mercedes, Audis and SUV's. Shanty-Towns are springing up in the back-woods of America, and a large group of very purposefully well armed, well hidden "Off-Gridders", survivalists have sprung up, and are only apparant through their many interconnected web sites. Most poorer folks in North America have started gardening for survival, the glorious lawns of the past are soon to bear food, and practices such as canning, suerkrauting, pickling, food drying, aquaculture, chicken raising, have become popular. Even mighty and communist China is adjusting, with large-scale unemployment and some protesting in the streets. Expect darker days world wide, as fools such as starving North Korea tempt fate by building weapons of mass destruction in place of feeding its people and controlling its population. World War Three is inevitable, we are watching the first steps towards it. It will be nuclear in nature. Great fission-fires will be unleashed as generating stations are targeted by missles, in America, China, France and Russia It will be the last war by mankind. This time, we are doomed to Armageddon, no way out, the hemorage has already started.
YOUTHS LOVE PUTIN
[info]famulla wrote:
Tuesday, 26 May 2009 at 05:44 pm (UTC)
You may hate me but this true. The youths in Russia love Putin.
I thank you
Firozali A.Mulla
The End IS Near
[info]livininthewoods wrote:
Tuesday, 26 May 2009 at 11:51 pm (UTC)
Rex123, thank you for the fascinating insights into the Russian reality. My heart BREAKS for the people there who are suffering from hunger and cold. I agree with you that protestations to the State to come to their aid will be futile. And you are ALSO right that nobody is going to send food aid. It is truly going to become a situation where every country will be looking out for ITSELF...as, ultimately, that is the very nature of mankind. Our selfish hearts ALWAYS seek ME first! Fuccup, you paint a bleak picture, and end it by saying we are DOOMED TO ARMEGGEDON. It is becoming obvious to MANY that the END of all things looms near. Earth has reached a point of unsustainability and social and financial collapse due to the fact that the globalist elite have systematically set the groundwork for the collapse of the economic structures of EVERY soverign nation on the face of the earth. But even though they THINK they are in control...and though they THINK their precious little One World Government is just around the corner...as they squeeze us all into mass SERFDOM...there is one thing many people FORGET or just don't know. This global conflict that we are entering into is NOT the work of evil men, alone. They are inspired by their CAPITAN...the devil himself. That is why they are so RUTHLESS. But there IS a God...and He has a plan, as well! I KNOW THE FUTURE....and GOD wins! How do I know that? I've read His book, and I study it every day. I am well aware of the fact that the majority of the world's population don't KNOW Him, or don't TRUST Him, or don't BELIEVE in Him...but that DOESN'T change the fact that He's THERE! You may think I'm CRAZY...and that's okay. But if you are wise at all please listen to what I have to say ( just in case I'm NOT crazy!) If we are to have ANY hope at all, we need to do 3 things NOW! 1)Start asking Him to help you find Him, 2) Ask Him for His care and PROTECTION from the forces of evil, and 3) Plant FOOD. Plant as much as you CAN so you will have extra to share, and for barter. Having said all that...there IS hope...if you know WHERE to FIND it! It's a free GIFT if you decide you WANT it! Prayers and best wishes to all of you here. You are obviously smart people or you wouldn't BE here...so PLEASE listen to my words of advice.
laptop battery
[info]lapbatterytop wrote:
Saturday, 7 November 2009 at 03:00 am (UTC)

 Laptop Battery Laptop Battery Laptop Batteries Laptop Batteries discount laptop battery discount laptop battery notebook battery notebook battery computer battery computer battery replacement laptop battery replacement laptop battery notebook batteries notebook batteries  



Most popular in Europe

Article Archive

Day In a Page

Sun | Mon | Tue | Wed | Thu | Fri | Sat

Select date