World

10° London Hi 11°C / Lo 6°C

Merciless Ikea memoir flat-packs a punch

Former executive's explosive book rips the cosy façade off the Swedish furniture giant

By Tony Paterson

Claims that Ingvar Kamprad, the founder of Ikea, runs the store with an iron fist, are made in a former executive's book

Claims that Ingvar Kamprad, the founder of Ikea, runs the store with an iron fist, are made in a former executive's book

The wholesome Scandinavian image of furniture and lifestyle giant Ikea has been rudely shaken by a new book which claims the company is hostile to foreign employees and uses Stasi-style secret police methods to spy on its thousands of staff worldwide.

The explosive charges are made by a former senior Ikea executive Johan Stenebo, a Swede who started working for the company at one of its German outlets outside Hamburg over 20 years ago and rose to a senior management position. He resigned last year.

His book, entitled Sanningen om Ikea (The Truth about Ikea), contains wide-ranging allegations about a company which has become a global household name. Justifying the book to Gemany's Der Spiegel magazine, he said: "I did not want to go along with it any more, but I could not stay silent."

Mr Stenebo claims that Ikea, which employs 135,000 staff in 44 countries, is run with an iron fist by founder Ingvar Kamprad and his two sons Mathias and Peter, who were promoted to top management five years ago.

He describes Ikea as "one of the most secretive companies in the world" and claims that senior management were expected to show fanatical loyalty and devotion to Mr Kamprad. "There was an unwritten law for Ikea upper management: loyalty to Ingvar unto death," he writes.

He alleges that Ikea used methods normally associated with former Communist East Germany's hated Stasi secret police to spy on its staff and keep them in line. He claims that a close-knit network of company informers kept Mr Kamprad constantly updated on personal gossip about employees and the prevailing atmosphere in each office.

Foreigners who work for Ikea have been referred to by Swedish executives as "niggers", he writes, and have no chance of being promoted to senior positions. In fact, most of the top Ikea jobs, he claims, go to employees from the town of Älmhult, in the Samaland region of Sweden, where Mr Kamprad grew up. Mr Stenebo claims Ikea has elaborately manipulated the image of its 83-year-old founder, now the world's fifth-richest man, portraying him as "an ascetic, slightly dim geriatric" with alcohol problems and dyslexia, and confecting for him a typical Ikea lifestyle of modest, affordable simplicity, with a Klippan range sofa and the bog-standard Billy bookcase.

In reality, he writes, these stories were made up by Mr Kamprad (who actually drove a Porsche), then disseminated by media which fell for their quaint charm. There was good business sense to the strategy, he says: the company's homely image "helped to push down prices with suppliers".

His book also alleges that the company makes claims to being an eco-friendly concern, while in reality its huge market share means that it can dictate the lowest prices to its suppliers. "The key to Ikea's low prices is the supply of cheap raw materials," Mr Stenebo writes. "Instead of using the best they use the cheapest."

Mr Stenebo insists that he chose to write his open denunciation of Ikea after a furious row with Mr Kamprad's son Peter. "Economic power means a responsibility towards people and the environment, but Peter does not understand that," he claimed.

The book has attracted enormous media attention in Sweden, with its unprecedented attack on a national institution by one of its former senior executives. The last time the furniture giant came in for such negative publicity was more than a decade ago when Mr Kamprad senior was unmasked as having been a wartime member of a Swedish pro-Nazi organisation.

He managed to survive that stain on his reputation by publicly apologising and writing personally to all of Ikea's Jewish staff. This time around, Ikea has dismissed the book as "the author's personal opinion on Ikea and the Kamprad family. Ikea sees no reason to make a comment on someone's personal view on the company."

Yet despite Mr Stenebo's destructive criticisms, it is clear he has not entirely escaped entanglement with the old man's charisma. He has no doubt his denunciations have come to the attention of the man who matters. "Ingvar will be reading the book with his chameleon eyes," he told Der Spiegel with an unmistakable note of pride. "He hates me and he loves me."

Ikea in numbers

565 million Number of visitors to Ikea worldwide in 2008

9,500 Items of furniture available in the catalogue

135,000 Employees in 44 countries

€21.2bn Sales in 2008

594,000sq ft Size of largest branch of Ikea, outside Stockholm

Post a Comment

View all comments that have been posted about this article.

Offensive or abusive comments will be removed and your IP logged and may be used to prevent further submission. In submitting a comment to the site, you agree to be bound by the Independent Minds Terms of Service.

Comments

soulless management, soulless company
[info]contrastcolour wrote:
Saturday, 14 November 2009 at 09:27 am (UTC)
Hmmm, interesting.

I'm quite glad to say that I've never fallen for IKEA. Yes, I've been there a couple of times to buy large bits of furniture that have been necessary and have been cheaper than anywhere else. Other times though, I prefer to just acquire things organically. Or, sometimes pop into second hand furniture stores, where some very interesting things can be found.

IKEA is just dull. A Danish woman I knew arrived in the UK and within two weeks had outfitted her (dull) apartment from floor to ceiling with IKEA tat. It looked just like the catalogue pictures... I think I would have cut my wrists if I had to live in such a soulless place.

And is this any surprise, that they are cheap because they cut corners on working practices and materials? I mean, the products they make are the ipods of the furniture world: built to last until you get tired of the style, basically...

One thing about him previously writing an apology to all Jewish members of staff: how exactly did they KNOW which members of staff were Jewish? Or is this included in the Stasi style database of employees that his secret police collect on staff, as well as their average length of toilet break?
Shopping in Ikea...
[info]occamsghost wrote:
Saturday, 14 November 2009 at 09:56 am (UTC)
... Makes a trip to Tesco seem like a warm, human and homely experience.

I can't speak for the accuracy of the claims, but they do chime with my own feelings as a very grudging customer. On the rare occasions I'm cajoled into going to Ikea I feel like a lab rat in a sterile, brightly-coloured maze - and doubtless it has been designed by very clever psychologists. The whole thing shrieks of ruthless central control - if there's such a thing as totalitarian capitalism, this is what it looks like.

Or maybe that's over-analysing and I'm just an ordinary bloke who sees no reason to waste a perfectly good Saturday looking at picture frames and furniture...
Re: Shopping in Ikea...
[info]ghirone wrote:
Sunday, 15 November 2009 at 12:37 am (UTC)
Buy stuff in a carboot!
[info]hisbigal wrote:
Saturday, 14 November 2009 at 07:45 pm (UTC)
Unfortunately, for those of us on budgets, particularly students, it's often the only game in town. For the record, I bought most of my furniture at Ikea because even the second hand and charity shops were more expensive and, as one of those poor students on a budget, I had little, if any, choice. I realise they do suck you in a rather pernicious way but, then again, the Kamprad family are capitalists, so you can't expect them to run the company like a anarcho-syndicalist collective.
Argos, I love it!
[info]thetitssayso wrote:
Tuesday, 17 November 2009 at 05:33 pm (UTC)
IMHO There is a superior alternative.. ARGOS!!! And they do it far better than Ikea, and have been doing so for years! Last time I shopped at Argos online, they delivered my entire order at about £3.00, on an appointment too! Plus, I can order off the internet, or select from the catalog AND HAVE THE STAFF BRING ME MY PURCHASE!!! Learn that one Idea.
Why Italian children love IKEA?
[info]ghirone wrote:
Sunday, 15 November 2009 at 12:34 am (UTC)
Because they feel at home when visiting their friends.
Merciless Ikea
[info]jamandthebrave wrote:
Monday, 16 November 2009 at 05:52 pm (UTC)
To be honest, none of these comments will be a surprise to Ikea employees who are routinely abused at work, not only on a poorly paid basis but on the stupidity of senior managers not being able to see beyond their own noses. The whole of Ikea from the top managers to the store managers is rife with abuse and the need to be 'Ikea' is forced onto the lower paid staff/co-wrkers. Kamprad should get his head out of the book and go and see the actual people that make the company run, the real co-workers - he might be surprised to learn that not all is rosy in the Ikea world. Supervisors at Ikea are paid a wage that is only slightly above what a co-worker with no experience earns and indeed, a co-worker can, for only a few hours overtime, take home more than a supervisory member of staff without all the hassle that is thrown into the supervisor role.

Kamprad may be clever but he does not really know anything about 'his' company and his son's are even worse as the running of 'Habitat' proves.......
Sounds Familiar
[info]beatdom wrote:
Tuesday, 17 November 2009 at 03:52 am (UTC)
This book sounds strangely familiar to another soon-to-be-released title, this time about Poundland! Apparently Poundland will receive the same beating (as though it had respect to lose...) in a book that's due out in (I think) December.

I assume people are suprised by the Ikea thing, but I doubt anyone who's set foot in Poundland will be suprised by any attack!

Here's a link: http://www.cityofrecovery.com

Article Archive

Day In a Page

Sun | Mon | Tue | Wed | Thu | Fri | Sat

Select date