Now Russia gets caught in the credit crunch
First G8 nation to have rating downgraded since start of global financial crisis
Digg
del.icio.us
Facebook
Reddit
Google
Stumble Upon
Fark
Newsvine
YahooBuzz
Bebo
Twitter
Independent Minds
Reuters
Alistair Darling greets Russia's Finance Minister, Alexei Kudrin, yesterday as his country's credit rating suffered a downgrade
enlarge
The Russian economy, already pummelled by falling oil prices, trade disputes with neighbours and fleeing investors, took another step towards the abyss yesterday as the country's credit rating was downgraded. Russia is the first G8 nation to have suffered a downgrade since the start of the global financial crisis.
After several years of booming commodity prices that have filled the country's coffers and allowed Vladimir Putin to remain popular at home and aggressive abroad, there is a new feeling of doom in Moscow. With the rouble sliding against the dollar – it hit a new low on Tuesday – rising inflation, collapsing growth and soaring unemployment, the country is experiencing the first stirrings of social unrest. Last weekend saw the biggest display of public disaffection for years, with anti-government protests in all major Russian cities. As the economic hardship begins to trickle down, and ordinary Russians become aware of the scale of the crisis, the numbers on the streets are likely to swell.
Amid the deepening international economic gloom, Russia's Deputy Prime Minister and Finance Minister, Alexei Kudrin, held talks in London yesterday with cabinet ministers including the Chancellor, Alistair Darling, and the Secretary of State for Business, Peter Mandelson.
Mr Kudrin conceded that Russia, long one of the world's fastest-growing economies, now expects zero growth this year. To make things worse, while many other countries are seeing the worsening economy at least curb inflation, he said Russia expects prices to rise by a staggering 13 per cent this year. That's much higher than most developed economies, and may also put pressure on the government to raise interest rates – further hurting the economy. "We're facing some very difficult challenges," Mr Kudrin said. "So certainly the forecast for Russia at the moment is worse now than at the end of 2008."
The leading credit ratings agency Fitch added to Russia's economic woes yesterday by downgrading its rating on the country's sovereign debt to BBB. This could make lenders more reluctant to lend, and force Russia to pay higher interest to those who do.
Most developed countries, such as the US or UK, have the top credit rating of AAA. Russia's rating is now eight notches below this, and a mere two notches above a so-called junk rating, at which point it would be prohibitively costly for Russia to borrow.
But the country faces several problems at once. As a big exporter of commodities and natural resources it is a casualty of the sharp slowdown in demand in other countries. The country has additionally suffered from diplomatic disputes with its neighbours, such as the spat over gas with Ukraine in January and last summer's war with Georgia.
In boom times, Russia benefited from Western cash as investors looked to harness its higher-than-average growth. But economic pressure at home and banks calling in their loans has forced such investors to curtail their spending in Russia, creating a flight of capital from the country.
The current situation may further spook Western investors as it risks echoing the Russian crisis of 1998, when a similar fall in commodities prices led to a slide in the value of the Russian currency and eventually the country defaulted on its debt, prompting huge losses among those who had placed money in the country. Britain has in recent years been among the biggest foreign investors in Russia.
This time, while analysts do not forecast complete collapse, Russia is far more dependent on international factors. "Russia is responding to world events that are out of its control," said Roland Nash, head of research at Renaissance Capital in Moscow. "It's all very well for Putin to say that things will improve at the end of this year, but there's not much he can do about it if they don't."
Mr Putin, the Prime Minister, made his prediction in a recent interview, and many analysts agree with him that in the long-term Russia is still a good investment opportunity. But in the short-term, the focus will be on defending the currency and preventing banks and oligarchs, many of whom have huge debts to Western banks, from ruin. According to one estimate Russian oligarchs have lost a total of $230bn (£160bn) since last summer. The rouble has lost more than 30 per cent of its value against the dollar in recent months.
All the economic woe could translate into political problems for Russia's leaders. Mr Putin still has astronomically high approval ratings for now, but he will not be able to distance himself from the effects of the crisis.
Oligarchs feeling the pinch
Roman Abramovich
The Chelsea owner, below, has lost more than $20bn, according to Bloomberg, though he is believed to have large cash stocks and was less indebted to banks than some counterparts.
Oleg Deripaska
SmartMoney estimated in October that Mr Deripaska, Russia's richest man last year, had lost $28.4bn – moving him into the red. He is known to have taken out several huge loans from Western banks, secured against shares in his companies that then slid in value. He is the worst hit of Russia's oligarchs and will be reliant on state support to see him through the crisis.
Vladimir Potanin
The president of the Russian mining and metals conglomerate Interros is also the controlling shareholder of Norilsk Nickel, the world's leading nickel producer. He reportedly lost $13.2bn after his stock in the company plunged by 65 per cent, fuelling rumours of an imminent merger.
Alisher Usmanov
The metals billionaire and Arsenal shareholder has reportedly suffered losses of more than $14bn.
Alexei Mordashov
Steel magnate has lost up to three-quarters of his $22bn paper fortune.
View all comments that have been posted about this article.
Offensive or abusive comments will be removed and your IP logged and may be used to prevent further submission. In submitting a comment to the site, you agree to be bound by the Independent Minds Terms of Service.
- Print Article
- Email Article
-
Click here for copyright permissions
Copyright 2009 Independent News and Media Limited
Comments
If G8 status was reliant on economic performance and maturity then Russia would never have been admitted so the comment that it is the first G8 country to be downgraded is rather disingenuous as credit ratings have nothing to do with this group.
The Russian economy has been treated as a private bank by first Yeltsin and then Putin and his cronies a la Robert Mugabe and ZANU-PF so economic disaster will come as no surprise to any dispassionate observer. It was Helmut Schmidt who famously referred to the USSR as "Upper Volta with rockets". I would contend that today's Russian Federation is only a couple of degrees off being Zimbabwe with rockets.
The economic planners who base the Russian state budget break even point on a fanciful oil price of $90 per barrel were always pissing against the wind but you can be sure that Putin and co were instructing the planners. It's a sorry state of affairs that Russia now finds itself in and the near neighbours had better be careful as the Kremlin looks for "reactionary foreign interference" or even "ethno-fascists" under the beds as a meaningful way to deflect from their gross macro-economic mismanagement. Make no mistake, Russia would have suffered similarly to any global economy in this crisis but because the state coffers have been plundered so unashamedly the margin for safety has been seriously diminished to the point that exhaustion is very much in sight. Think if you will of someone who spots a person who has fallen into a harbour and is struggling to stay afloat. They run to the box where the lifebelt is stored to discover that it has been looted by some vandal. Need I say more?
The London-based Fitch rating agency has now become another pawn in Britain's shrill and desperate war against Putin, through which it is seeking to ingratiate itself with its transatlantic lord and master. The fact that Fitch announced the downgrading of Russia's sovereign rating the very day that Crash Gordon admitted that Britain was in the midst of economic depression has turned the whole thing into a farce. Russia is anticipating zero growth while Britain's very optimistic forecast is -2.7%. Russia has a trade surplus and still considerable foreign reserves while Britain's deficits and debts are so huge that they can't be discussed in polite company. As for the US, fuggedaboudit.
scot-in-canada, I share your surprise. As the economic mess unravels the Russian Federation shows itself to be what Imperial Russia was 92 years ago - nothing much more than an extended family business. The only difference today is that the definition of "family" might be slightly more Sicilian in nature.
But there are apologists and deniers at every turn so therefore this MUST be untrue!
To write a story based on Russia being the 1st G8 country to be downgraded in Febraury 2009 is woeful.
Standard & Poors cut Russia to BBB (sound familiar?) on 8th December.
To observe that 'the rouble has lost >30% against the dollar in recent months' is equally slap dash - 30% covers the last 6 weeks and 50% covers the last 6 months.
Note to philfaebuckie - You should be ashamed of your analysis (you're not a journalist are you?).
To compare Russia with Zimbabwe is puerile - One country has untold human suffering as the result of a despot, the other has seen real wages double over 4 years and a population that has, generally speaking, access to all it's daily needs and consistently endorsed it's politicians. Granted that's subject to change as job losses mount, nonetheless your analogy is infantile.
ihateukus, If I will "lese the remaining brain sell" [sic] I will still be a damned sight more objective than you are permitted to be.
westhamsterdam, If G7 and/orG8 were being established today I am sure, just like you and others who have posted here, that the membership would be slightly different from today's cosy club.
P.S. Don't spend too long queuing on the snow at bus and train stops or lese the remaining brain sell will give up the ghost.
We have only been around for 141 years. Just watch what we can do from here.