World

Rain (AM and PM) 7° London Hi 9°C / Lo 7°C

Oligarch pays for party that enraged Putin

A star-studded hotel opening has cost thousands of Moscow market traders their jobs. Shaun Walker explains why

Azeri businessman Telman Ismailov upset Russian Prime Minister Vladimir Putin after hosting a lavish party at the luxurious Mardan Palace hotel

GETTY IMAGES

Azeri businessman Telman Ismailov upset Russian Prime Minister Vladimir Putin after hosting a lavish party at the luxurious Mardan Palace hotel

Farhad, a 37-year-old migrant labourer from Tajikistan, has little in common with Russia's rich. Sporting an Adidas tracksuit, squatting with a beer on a bench outside the closed and shuttered Cherkizovsky market, he couldn't be further away from the flashy cars, luxury villas and private jets of Russia's oligarch class. But bizarrely, Farhad, along with about 100,000 traders who lost their jobs when the market in Moscow was closed down two weeks ago, may have been made unemployed as a result of the oligarchic party of parties: a tasteless show of wealth that apparently infuriated the Russian Prime Minister, Vladimir Putin.

Cherkizovsky was the biggest market in eastern Europe, a sprawling bazaar where crowds streamed to buy everything from electronics to clothes and carpets. An estimated 5,000 buses arrived at the market every day, filled with shuttle traders who would buy up cheap goods in bulk and take them back to smaller markets in towns and cities across European Russia.

Two weeks ago, the market was closed down by police in what appears to be an attack on the extravagant Azeri businessman Telman Ismailov, the market's owner. Mr Ismailov, famous for throwing some of the world's most lavish parties, opened a resort hotel in Turkey in May that reportedly cost about £1bn to build. The Mardan Palace, named after Mr Ismailov's late father, has 17 bars, 10 restaurants, a swimming pool so vast that it takes half an hour to cross by gondola, rooms decorated in over-the-top palatial opulence, and a beach made with 9,000 tonnes of artificial sand.

For the opening party in late May, pictures from which appeared widely in the Russian media, Mr Ismailov paid Sharon Stone, Richard Gere, Mariah Carey, Paris Hilton and Tom Jones to attend. At one point, Mr Ismailov danced as $100 bills came fluttering down from the ceiling.

Mr Putin allegedly found the images of a tycoon who had made his money in Russia frittering it away publicly – and in another country – distasteful in the extreme, especially at a time of crisis. A week on, Mr Ismailov's problems began.

Mr Putin complained at a government meeting in early June that raids on the market last September had resulted in the confiscation of contraband goods, but there had been no arrests. The wheels were already in motion against Mr Ismailov.

With Mr Putin having given the nod, other senior officials began turning on the market. Alexander Bastrykin, the powerful head of Russia's investigative committee, called it "a disgrace in the centre of Moscow". According to Mr Bastrykin, some people spent a year without leaving the market: "It is a state within a state," he said. "It has its own police, its own customs service, its own courts, its own prosecutor and stand-alone infrastructure, including brothels."

Soon after, state television ran a programme investigating contraband at the market and painting a bleak picture of its occupants. Investigative journalism of this sort on Russian state television is usually provided to order when a nod has been given from above. According to the TV programme, there were 17,000 citizens of Tajikistan alone working at the market, and a Tajik consular point located in its midst. "Many people don't leave the market for years on end, because they have problems with documents, and with language. They don't speak Russian, and they don't want to," it said.

Police officers added that the market was run by its own internal mafia structures, and normal police were not allowed to go anywhere near the market, hinting that top officers were complicit in the corruption. All of this was known before, of course. But it was only at the end of last month that authorities stepped in, citing sanitary and storage violations to close the market down, temporarily initially.

Mr Ismailov has denied any wrongdoing, but is believed to have fled to Turkey. For now, the people suffering the most are the traders, many of whom have lost not only their work but goods at their stalls that they don't know if they will ever get back.

Yesterday at the market, police and security men guarded the entrance to the compound, and traders lurked in small groups outside waiting for news in the summer heat. The groups of traders spoke in a cacophony of tongues – the Turkic languages of Central Asia, Chinese, and the throaty languages of the North Caucasus. There were few native Russian speakers around. The Federal Migration Service said it would deport 151 Chinese and Vietnamese nationals who had been working at the market illegally.

"We have no information about whether or when the market will reopen," said Madzhumder Muhammad Amin, head of the Russian Federation of Migrants, who confirmed that more than 100,000 people had worked at the market. "The authorities have thrown thousands of people out on to the streets and are not telling us anything. Some people still can't get their possessions back from the market; others are sleeping rough." Mr Amin's organisation set up a field kitchen to distribute free food to those workers who had nothing, but police quickly shut down the kitchen and arrested those who came to be fed for not having their documents in order, he said.

Some have interpreted the attack on Mr Ismailov as part of a co-ordinated assault on the power of Moscow's Mayor, Yury Luzhkov. Mr Luzhkov has been a close friend of Mr Ismailov for many years, and running a business like Cherkizovsky market without lofty patronage would be unthinkable. Mr Luzhkov was at the hotel launch in Turkey with his billionaire wife, Yelena Baturina, who is one of Moscow's biggest developers.

The depth of the men's friendship is evident in a video of Mr Ismailov's 50th birthday party, held two years ago, and attended by Mr Luzhkov, as well as Jennifer Lopez, who hugged and kissed Mr Ismailov and sung him a ballad, for a reported fee of $1m.

"Telman, you are our friend, our friend forever," shouts Mr Luzhkov into the microphone, standing underneath a huge chandelier and surrounded by tables piled high with extravagant food and wines. "We are with you, Telman. We have gone through life together and take joy in our friendship."

But even Mr Luzhkov can't take on Mr Putin, and the Moscow Mayor seems to have taken the hint and has promised to close the market down for good. Whether the market closure is an attack on the businessman personally or a way to get at the Mayor, it is clear that Mr Ismailov has thrown his last party, at least in Russia. Whether or not the authorities will finish the job and seek to put him on trial remains to be seen.

For now, those suffering the most are the thousands of workers – many of them without permission to be in Moscow – who have lost their jobs. A crime wave is widely predicted as the migrants run out of food and money.

"The market was my life, I've been here for three years," says Farhad, dejectedly, waiting to find out whether he will be allowed back to his stall. "I've no idea what I'm going to do now."

Post a Comment

View all comments that have been posted about this article.

Offensive or abusive comments will be removed and your IP logged and may be used to prevent further submission. In submitting a comment to the site, you agree to be bound by the Independent Minds Terms of Service.

Comments

Strange ...
[info]ydef wrote:
Thursday, 16 July 2009 at 05:33 am (UTC)
I can understand Putin being upset because of the tasteless display of garish excess by which Ismailov chose to preen during a recession. But shutting down the entire market? The negative impact of its effect on Moscow's local economy would appear, at least on the surface, to be extremely unwise especially during a recession. If he's riled because the merchants have been getting away with not paying taxes, then you would think he would go about a way of imposing a tax without harming its commerce.

There's got to be a much bigger story behind Putin's motives for him to make such an extreme move against Ismailov.
Re: Strange ...
[info]theelectrician wrote:
Thursday, 16 July 2009 at 06:34 am (UTC)
Putin is a corrupt emperor in a corrupt empire. He doesn't need rational motives, he needs to display power to keep people afraid of him. It seems to be the Russian way.
Re: Strange ...
[info]jerusalem1 wrote:
Thursday, 16 July 2009 at 09:53 am (UTC)
You don't understand what this market/bazaar is all about. There you could buy fake goods, products brought into Russia without customs clearance, and past expiry date. This quiet region of Moscow has turned into a gangland with illegal workers, migrants, its own secuirty army, and off-limit to regular police.
This was a scar on the face of Moscw, and even though I admit the reason to close is politically motivated ( well, as Russians say - be simpler and people will love you, something that the market owner didn't take into consideration), it was an outrageous place by all international standards.
Re: Strange ...
[info]fin_d_empire wrote:
Thursday, 16 July 2009 at 11:10 am (UTC)
No you need to display your bigotry and ignorance just to piss us off. It seems to be the BNP way.
There is an economic rationale here
[info]yurism wrote:
Thursday, 16 July 2009 at 07:20 am (UTC)
Don't buy at face value this allegation connecting Ismailov's party and shutting of the market. This is not serious. The market has been a major hub for contraband trade, mostly in cheap garments from East Asia. It wouldn't be allowed in any European country. The clampdown is an (probably awkward) attempt to support Russian light industry, suffering from the recession (check outhere, if you read in Russian). Hopefully, the merchants and vendors will find jobs in more productive businesses. Who knows, maybe Moscow will see more Chinese and Vietnamese eateries at the end of the day.
Re: There is an economic rationale here
[info]fin_d_empire wrote:
Thursday, 16 July 2009 at 11:18 am (UTC)
A political one too. The last thing Russia needs is a billionaire gangster taking control of Moscow through Luzkhov, much like Berezovsky took control of Russia through Yeltsin. Ismailov is obviously carting his loot off abroad, as evidenced by his mega-splurge in Antalya, and the next thing you know it'll end up financing the Islamic Movement of Uzbekistan just like Boris bankrolled the Chechens, as well a "color revolution" or two like the bloody rebellion at Andijan. Maybe just a coincidence but the IMU just staged an attack on a police post in Tajikistan after a long period of latency.
Enhance the Model 42 Improve the Program is Better than Creating Further Problem Problems
[info]amanfrommars wrote:
Thursday, 16 July 2009 at 08:15 am (UTC)
Mr Putin providing Ideal Trading Conditions would allow Alien Trading to Generate Income and Export Soviet Black Market Control Expertise with an Army of Passionate Dependent Amateurs [more than 100,000 people ] Ready Volunteer Stock
Is this artickle pro-Putin or against Putin?
[info]rex123 wrote:
Thursday, 16 July 2009 at 09:46 am (UTC)
Bravo, Putin!...Actually this artickle is pro-Putin, not against him. Look - those who complain are illegal immigrants, mafia and oligarch himselve. Well, thousands of prostitutes (illegal brothels are mentioned in the artickle) and mafia paramilitants (read the artickle) will loose their illigal jobs?- really cruel, cruel Putin...Can smbdy say - does the author support Putin with this artickle or he blames him?
Dyadya Ron skazal...
[info]ron_broxted wrote:
Thursday, 16 July 2009 at 09:52 am (UTC)
Only Aleksandr Y. Lebedev can save Russia.
[info]20_michael_20 wrote:
Thursday, 16 July 2009 at 12:38 pm (UTC)
well done to Putin............
Putin should be commended
[info]edwren wrote:
Thursday, 16 July 2009 at 01:26 pm (UTC)
A strange attitude towards a mafia run 'state within a state' that is teaming with illegal immigrants. Putin has made a good decision with regards to this market. The will still be a need for the products that the market supplied but it can now be managed legally with jobs for legal russian workers and taxes paid to the state.
What is there to complain about?? Imagine this market operating in the UK!
Putin should be commended.
Re: Putin should be commended
[info]tony_ouragon wrote:
Thursday, 16 July 2009 at 03:25 pm (UTC)
Indeed, Putin is just beiing a good nationalist, protecting his country and people.
Disgusting display
[info]leonore35 wrote:
Thursday, 16 July 2009 at 03:32 pm (UTC)
These people are just cocking a snook at the West
Look at us we can throw around a lot more money than you, most of it is illgotten gains stolen when USSR fell apart
advise to the writer of this article from Russina in Britain
[info]maxim125 wrote:
Thursday, 16 July 2009 at 03:38 pm (UTC)
Well, I am not surprised how many sensitive politically motivated with double standards articles you can read in British media these days. They all try to point their dirty finger in Mr.Putin and new modern Russia and now even blame him indirectly for closure of this market , a haunt for illegal immigrants and criminals which were involved in money laundering, tax evasion and breach of Russian immigration law. Dear Readers, please avoid this kind of "Putin" in the subject shying articles as they all mislead you and the writer clearly trying to manipulate your public opinion. He does not care about all these poor immigrants and how to help them, all purpose of this article to blame and point dirty finger to Mr. Putin, great G8 leader who is trying together with China bring world to a balance and stability which other western countries don't want to.I really don't even understand why this subject was raised in british newspaper? Do Brits care about this or interested in this? If the writer of the article cares so much about them then he should probably provide a free legal advise and finance for Central Asian and Caucasus asylum seekers applicants into his own country and provide them with all benefits he is ready to provide including jobs and opening of a new market for trading for them! What a shame on editor of Evening Standard and new owner Mr. lebedev when they continue this rigid double standard political line and try to make zomby from British readers telling them from different not objective prospective their own opinion and thoughts!
a former Moscovite who had to fled from savages
[info]vlad545 wrote:
Thursday, 16 July 2009 at 05:22 pm (UTC)
This is a move in a right direction (the closure of the "market"). Every European democracy would do the same. Thanks God it looks like a first step to put order in Moscow where illegal migrants seems like overpopulated the locals.

Ismailov is a victim of his own stupidity and bad manners. Let's see who is the next "victim"
of Mr. Putin who is quite right that savages if not received good manners in their childhood should be brought to "correction" even if they are in their 50s today:)
Re: a former Moscovite who had to fled from savages
[info]ydef wrote:
Thursday, 16 July 2009 at 11:09 pm (UTC)
I don't have any problem praising Putin if this is in fact how Russians perceive the move (that I would give more gravitas than a carpetbagger's unfamiliar observation) to be a crackdown on lawlessness by Putin for a Russia that suffers both real and perceived lawless and orderliness issues endemic of crisis.

But there still remains the valid question of why did it take Putin so long to take charge and finally give his stamp of approval on this apparent 'lawless bazaar' that has been a festering hornet's nest in the Nation's Own Capital MOSCOW for at least the last 3 years?!?

Putin surely didn't have his head in the sand to the dark realities of this ungovernable sector in the mother these past years. How is it possible that Putin did not give his tacit approval for it to have gotten to the point where it "was run by its own internal mafia structures, and normal police were not allowed to go anywhere near the market" ?!?

Something changed that affected Putin's decision to force an abrupt closure. Putin just doesn't seem like the capricious sort that would just decide one day to make a decision like this with no rhyme or reason. He wouldn't have the respect that he does if he did.
Putin
[info]archie1954 wrote:
Thursday, 16 July 2009 at 06:04 pm (UTC)
doesn't seem to really care about the people he displaces from their jobs. He is acting like a dictator. I think Mevedev should have a heart to heart with him.
Re: Putin
[info]ydef wrote:
Thursday, 16 July 2009 at 10:49 pm (UTC)
Hahaha. Do you really think Medvedev having a 'heart to heart' with Putin would in any way influence his behavior? Putin IS Prime Minister after all, so making domestic decisions and focusing on local economies is completely his call regardless of whatever 'chat to chat' Mevedev could possibly have.
Oligarch pays for party
[info]emuscat_1 wrote:
Friday, 17 July 2009 at 04:02 pm (UTC)
Did the Nabucco gas pipeline have something to do with it?Azeri gas,pipeline is mostly to be in Turkey and is there an azeri middleman called ismailov?
[info]niggag wrote:
Tuesday, 18 August 2009 at 10:47 pm (UTC)
That Nigga Putin needs to stop bullshitin that nigga sittin on 50 billion and pulling plugs on niggas that rollin! mafacka!

EDITOR'S CHOICE


Most popular in Europe

Article Archive

Day In a Page

Sun | Mon | Tue | Wed | Thu | Fri | Sat

Select date