Shortage of vultures threatens ancient culture: Many Parsees are questioning the tradition of sky burial. Tim McGirk reports from Bombay on a bitter life-and-death debate

News in pictures
News in pictures
On Facebook
From the blogs

Roy Hodgson for England: A club of one

To argue against Harry Redknapp for England is akin to arguing in favour of bankers bonuses. While s...

Time for a reality check on the Sri Lankan civil war

Sri Lanka, much like Britain, has side-lined accountability long enough.

Children Of Alcoholics week: One million children may just be the tip of the iceberg

Children Of Alcoholics week starts today. So, what are the aims for Nacoa during this important week...

Review of Being Human: ‘Being Human 1955’

Following on from an episode tinged with tragedy, this week lifted the mood with something lighter.

Suggested Topics
THE fickle habits of Bombay's vultures may soon force the Parsee religious community to abandon its 1,200-year-old custom of leaving the dead to be devoured by birds.

The Tower of Silence looks as forbidding as it sounds. A grim, stone tower, it sits in a private jungle park on Bombay's Malabar Hill. Here, on a high, round platform, the bodies are stripped naked and left for the vultures. After the birds have feasted, the human bones are swept off the ringed platform into a dark, deep well in the Tower of Silence.

Every day for centuries a corpse or two has been placed on the Tower of Silence, and the birds have learned to participate in the Parsee funeral ceremonies with extraordinary punctuality. Even before the dead man was brought out last Tuesday, the vultures and kites had alighted from their eyries atop Bombay's skyscrapers and were gliding in a slow circle high above the tower. With their spiralling pattern of flight, it was as if the hundreds of vultures, kites, crows and sparrows had assembled to create their own Tower of Silence in the air.

In the afternoon, four white- clad pallbearers carried a corpse along a path through the Doongerwadi jungle of palms, banyan trees and vines leading to the tower. As they climbed the tower's outside stairway to the funeral platform, a few crows and kites swooped on to the rampart and were jerking their wings in a spasm of hungry anticipation.

The Parsees, who venerate fire, laid the corpse tenderly on the platform. The only ornaments on the Tower of Silence are lines that beam out from the centre well, and it looked as though the dead man was caught dangling in the rays of a dark sun. As the birds moved in on the corpse, it became apparent that these beams were in fact gutters whose function is to wash the blood into the well.

Sky burials date from the eighth century when the Parsees, also called Zoroastrians, were forced by their Muslim conquerors in Persia to leave their dead unburied. Parsees believe that in the sky burial the corpse is prevented from polluting the sacred elements of fire, air, water and earth.

To escape Muslim persecution, the Parsees sailed to India, taking this custom with them. Letting scavengers devour a corpse on a remote hilltop may have been swift and hygienic, but carrying out the same practice today in densely crowded Bombay is distinctly less so.

Many Parsees believe that this funeral rite has lost its dignity. The vultures, they say, are to blame. Jehan Daruwala, the editor of the Bombay Samachar, a daily that serves the city's 50,000 Parsees, said: 'I speak with authority, rancour and force, and I say that I would not want my dog to be disposed of in this manner - never mind one of my loved ones.'

The problem is that there are now too few vultures adequately to remove the corpse. 'It's like Dante's Hell,' said one Parsee mourner who visited the funeral edifice. 'There are hardly any birds and the bodies remain in an identifiable state for weeks - even months.'

He added: 'There was such a foul stink that I went home and bathed, but for the rest of the night, I still couldn't get that smell out of my nostrils.'

Inhabitants of the skyscrapers that ring the Tower of Silence are unhappy too. Those in the lower floors are hit by the stench, while the penthouse-dwellers sometimes find that a kite has dropped some morsel of human flesh on to their terrace.

Chased away by aeroplanes from the nearby airport, and deprived of the central Bombay slaughterhouses, which have been moved to the outskirts of the city, the vultures are now shunning the Tower of Silence.

Gautam Narayan, an ornithologist with the Bombay Natural History Society, explained: 'When they shifted the slaughterhouses out of Bombay, the vultures went with them.

'The Parsees approached us about this matter a while back and we suggested contructing an aviary over the Tower of Silence, keeping the vultures inside. But nothing came of it.'

The white-backed gyps bengalensis also loses its appetite during the three months of monsoon and vanishes from Bombay to breed. The disappearance of the Tower of Silence's scavengers has sparked off a fiery row between orthodox Bombay Parsees and reformists.

One community leader who visited the Tower of Silence, and was revolted by what he saw, suggested that the Parsees abandon sky burials in favour of cremations. 'I received telephone calls at night from other Parsees, saying they would splash my face with acid,' said the man, who did not want his name published.

The job of pallbearer has traditionally been hereditary, but the Parsees today are a rich, dynamic community that includes doctors and industrialists (the late Freddie Mercury, the pop star, was also a Parsee) and few are willing to haul carcasses up to the Tower of Silence for pounds 16 a month.

Minoo Chhoi, a Parsee actor, spoke recently to a pallbearer, who said: 'My grandfather and father did this job, and so did I - but not my son. He's not carrying any corpses. He's working as a bank clerk.'

(Photograph omitted)

Independent Comment
blog comments powered by Disqus

Day In a Page

Apple admits it has a human rights problem

Apple admits it has a human rights problem

After years of complaints and workers' suicides in China the technology giant faces up to the human cost of its gadgets
Peter Moore: 'I feel guilty I'm the only one alive'

Peter Moore interview

'I feel guilty I'm the only one alive'
Sellafield faces nuclear option as overspending threatens plant's future

Sellafield faces nuclear option

Overspending threatens plant's future
Israel blames Iran for embassy bomb attacks

Israel blames Iran for embassy bomb attacks

Tehran rejects Netanyahu's 'lies' after diplomats in India and Georgia targeted
Former manager enjoying Apoel crack at the big time

Tommy Cassidy interview

Former manager enjoying Apoel crack at the big time
James Lawton: Patience may not be a virtue this time, Roman – Andre Villas-Boas looks all at sea

James Lawton: AVB looks all at sea

Abramovich's visits to training reinforce the idea of a coach feeling pressure from above and below
The 10 Best sledges

The 10 Best sledges

Not all of them require snow...
Procrastination: Not now – I'm busy

Procrastination: Not now – I'm busy

Confronting the real reasons for puttting things off can help us beat it
Fun in the sunset years

Fun in the sunset years

A new movie follows retirees moving to India for low-cost care and a culture of respect for the elderly. For many Britons, it's already a reality
Picture preview: Lucian Freud drawings

Lucian Freud drawings

Picture preview
Silent revolution at the Baftas as the French take top awards

Silent revolution at the Baftas

The Artist wins in seven categories, with Meryl Streep the other big success story
Whitney Houston: The diva who had – and lost – it all

The diva who had – and lost – it all

Nick Hasted charts the highs and lows of Whitney Houston's life
How Picasso won over (some of) the British

How Picasso won over (some of) the British

Winston Churchill and Evelyn Waugh hated his work, but Picasso provided inspiration for a whole generation of UK artists
Topshop: A Decade Of Design

Topshop: A Decade Of Design

When London Fashion Week starts on Friday, Topshop will celebrate 10 years backing its brightest young stars
John Prescott: 'My wife thought I'd just retire, but I'm not a slippers man'

'My wife thought I'd just retire, but I'm not a slippers man'

At 73, John Prescott isn't mellowing. In fact he's taking a shot at becoming a police commissioner