Commentators

Partly Sunny with Showers 2° London Hi 5°C / Lo 2°C

Julia Wrathall: Pressure must be applied to improve animals' welfare

Wednesday, 18 June 2008

Pigs are highly intelligent, inquisitive animals which often outdo dogs in learning tests. Indeed, some believe they are the fourth most sentient animals after primates, dolphins and elephants.

Although many pigs live in large straw-bedded barns that enable them to move around and express natural behaviour, some are still reared in conditions that manifestly fail to meet their physical and behavioural needs.

The problem is that, although the law states that pigs must be given appropriate materials to express their instincts to investigate and root, the Government does not enforce this legislation – hence the ongoing failure to ensure all pigs are provided with a comfortable, interesting and stimulating environment.

Although keeping livestock outdoors is not necessarily always best for welfare, free-range systems do give the animals freedom to move around and indulge this natural behaviour. Most pigs grown for meat are reared indoors. Most indoor sows give birth in farrowing crates, restrictive narrow pens that help to protect newborns from being crushed by their mothers, but seriously restrict the sows' movement and behaviour, especially as the confinement lasts until the piglets are weaned at four weeks.

Some growing pigs (juveniles being reared for market) are kept in densely packed pens with no bedding, on concrete. Crowded, barren environments are known to increase the risk of problem behaviours such as tail biting, which can lead to wounds, infection and death. The problem is usually addressed through docking piglets' tails. Most piglets are docked but this treats the symptom while not addressing the root cause of the aggression.

No rules cover the labelling of pork, unlike poultry and eggs, making consumer choice difficult. Retailers can label pork as "outdoor bred" or "free range" without providing definitions. Non-conforming imported pig products are also sold.

If consumers want to support higher welfare production, they should look out for meat carrying the Freedom Food logo. It identifies pork from animals that come from farms accredited under the RSPCA's higher-welfare assurance scheme.

Responsibility for pig welfare lies with every sector of the food chain: farmers, retailers, Government and consumers can all help. Consumers are potentially the most powerful, but only if they are properly informed.

The writer is Head of RSPCA Farm Animal Science

Click here to have your say

Interesting? Click here to explore further

Comments

14 Comments

Congratulations to The Independent for publishing this material. It further reinforces my conviction that the only sure way to stop such abuse of pigs and other factory farmed animals is stop eating their body parts and products such as eggs and milk. I have been a vegan for more than 20 years and continue to lead an active physical and mental life in my 70s.

Posted by Margaret Setter | 19.06.08, 02:29 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

Well done Independent for publishing this article and exposing these barbaric practices, hopefully others will follow. Animal Aid - I am so happy that all your hard efforts in animal welfare are getting to a wider audience. I hope to see further articles published on issues surrounding animal welfare and animal rights ...don't stop now, this is just the tip of the iceberg. We should be protecting them, not subjecting them to a life of suffering - thats not a life.

'The Pig Who Sang to the Moon' ,By Jeffrey Masson. I recommend this book without hesitation for anyone wanting to read about the emotional world of farm animals

Posted by Lizzy | 18.06.08, 22:38 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

It's utterly disgraceful that humans can be so greedy as to over-breed and ignore animal welfare in order to make a profit.The sooner Freedom Food becomes more widely available the better. My great uncle and an aunt had farms with livestock and I remember the conditions thirty years ago when they took animal welfare into consideration. Tail docking is a result of over-stressing and over-crowding intelligent animals in disgusting conditions. This is similar to de-beaking of birds in the poultry factory farms, done without anaesthetic of course. (Don't spend more money on that as it lowers profits). How far will humans degrade themselves by doing this? What happens to the consumed stress hormones in the humans that eat them? What breeding ground of diseases, mutations and deformities will make humans finally see this is immoral. Thank goodness these disgusting practices have been highlighted. Perhaps this will encourage pork suppliers to clean up their act or face ruin.

Posted by Deborah Wood | 18.06.08, 19:21 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

good on you ,these appalling farming practices need to be exposed over and over again. Well done Animal Aid for your initiative and bravery in uncovering these 'hidden' animals.

Posted by Colin DAVIES | 18.06.08, 17:21 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

The apalling treatment of wildlife as land areas are cleared again is mainly to feed the abused livestock. A double whammy, doh.

Posted by Marcus | 18.06.08, 17:12 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

Thank you for publishing this article. It is time that people realize the often gruesome history of their meat.The number of people who choose to forgo meat is on the increase so everybody involved in the livestock industry should remember the millions of compassionate people out there watching them.

Posted by Maria Bonita | 18.06.08, 17:09 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

Why don`t the Media give more coverage to the appalling treatment of Wildlife in areas of The World being cleared to feed The Dogooders Their Veggie &Vegan lifestyles?

Posted by dave coe | 18.06.08, 17:03 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

Sadly out of sight is out of mind, and so it is heartening to see that the awful conditions that many pigs exist in day in day out is on the front page of a newspaper.The government must improve legislation on the welfare of all farmed animals. For far too long the utterly miserable conditions they live under has gone on with welfare groups voices gone unheard. How will conditions change while the farmers meet the so called legal requirements? Farm animal welfare seriously needs to be addressed.

Posted by Bev Ham | 18.06.08, 15:07 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

I do not believe that the RSPCA should be promoting any animal farming and call it FREEDOM FOOD. There is nothing 'freedom' about it which has been shown by undercover investigations. I personally visited a Freedom Food chicken farm and it was horrendous. In the words of Henry Salt: "Be one or the other my double-face brother, be slayer or saviour, you cannot be both". The only way to ensure that animals are not abused is to stop eating them.

Posted by Pat Griffin | 18.06.08, 14:48 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

Thank goodness that there ARE animal welfare groups who are willing to take risks to expose this unbelievable cruelty. Why on earth do we consider ourselves to be so superior that the suffering of countless animals is acceptable? Don't they deserve a quality of life where they can express their natural behaviour? Seeing these pictures in the Independent today makes me ashamed of my fellow man. Perhaps if the majority of people had to view these images in real life they would think seriously before lining the pockets of these farmers who keep their livestock in such intolerable and disgraceful conditions. And when for Gods sake is this government going to do something positive for a change.

Posted by Alexandra Collins | 18.06.08, 14:37 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

14 Comments