Sarah Sands: Scared of flying? Don't sit next to a pilot at dinner
Sunday, 24 August 2008
The fate of the passengers on flight JK5022 was hideous and pitiful but it was not unimaginable. Every nervous flyer will have empathised with the man who sent a text on the runway to his wife: "My love, there's a problem with the plane.... They won't let me off."
Many will have looked at the slivers of aluminium held together by screws and doubted the whole enterprise. Others listen to changes of engine tone as evidence of approaching doom. We all know that the moment of maximum danger is the point of take-off, when high speed and heavy fuel are unforgiving of technical faults. It is very easy to imagine the Spanair pilot's deadly realisation as he wrestled so hard with the frozen controls that his arms broke. He defied the non-negotiable principle of aerodynamics: take-off is a point of no return.
Friends of mine who tremble at the thought of flying regard the Madrid air disaster as proof that planes are cursed and that flying is an act of hubris. I heard of the crash in the least superstitious of company – surrounded by British Airways pilots and cabin crew. We were in Tanzania, on a Unicef trip to look at health projects financed by the £25m-worth of spare currency that passengers have donated in little envelopes at the end of BA flights.
The response to the news was grave and calm; pilots are phlegmatic at the best of times. They screwed up their eyes diagnostically as they listed various scenarios. Disasters are usually a doomed accumulation of events. In the 2000 Concorde crash, it was a strip of metal on the runway that punctured the wheel, compounded by an extra-heavy load of fuel to compensate for the weight of luggage.
In the case of the crash landing of the BA flight from Beijing in January, the pilots were more circumspect. We still have no idea why the engines lost power on approach to Heathrow. Sometimes, accidents just happen.
Over two evenings, I grilled the pilots and crew about every conceivable danger in the skies. I learned that my talismanic belief that turbulence could not harm you was false. Bad enough, and the plane could snap in half. I learned about the particularly hairy approach to JFK airport that has to be done by ticking off landmarks. I heard of cabin crew chucking tea and coffee down the lavatory as they prepared for cross winds that emptied lockers and left passengers sobbing. I listened to a pilot's account of being struck by lightning eight times during one flight. I followed an argument over the capacity of the new giant Airbuses to resist lightning. I made a mental note of the league tables of air traffic controllers. I deduced that short-haul flights can be as bad or worse than long haul. I was told of a flight from Luxembourg during which a woman was so terrified by the spin-cycle-style shaking of the plane that she became hysterical. Her husband looked around, and then slunk off to a seat at the other side of the plane.
Despite all this, the pilot and crew regard their jobs as charmed. They trade routes with each other fiercely. They have the mischief of those who are away from home. I will not forget the cabin steward's exuberant rendition of "I feel pretty and witty and gay". Only the pilots – the matadors of the airline business – stay aloof.
Global travel is ideologically unfashionable but we should never forget the glorious freedom of it.
Sarah Sands is editor in chief of British 'Reader's Digest'
-
Print Article
-
Email Article
-
Click here for copyright permissions
Copyright 2008 Independent News and Media Limited





John Davies joke sums up why flying is still one of the safest forms of transport.
A pilot is trained to handle the expected emergency and to handle the unexpected one too.
A good pilot experiences a hundred virtual emergencies in his/her mind every day before take off and is checked consistently throughout a career.
When disasters do strike they are invariably the result a succession of issues that overwhelm the pilot, the systems and the whole crew.
Any good pilot will admit to a sense of apprehension, not fear or pacnic, before any flight. It is a positive caution that keeps the mind and senses alert. This positive stress certainly keeps thousands of people alive every day and is better than blind optimism or even worse, boredom.
One can't know the checklists well enough but also one should never become too familiar with them.
Posted by Michael Birbeck | 24.08.08, 21:45 GMT
the excuses are countless, hence ,it is worth to know that every soul shall taste death. Those passengers and cabin crews who have lost their precious life are recorded in history the news are flashed now and then.
Bahlul.
Posted by bahlul | 24.08.08, 17:25 GMT
Rarely a flight takes place without some minor technical hitch to report. Listening-in to the private airline company frequencies is quite educational and probably illegal but is nonetheless very revealing about the technical state of passenger aircraft. Frequently, catastrophic failures result from a chain of minor events which eventually add up to something terrible.
Posted by GHERKIN | 24.08.08, 14:39 GMT
as for nervous pilots - it is a control thing. How many very skilled male car drivers hate to be a passenger especially if the driver is a woman? Most pilots are men and I expect they feel only they can be the best pilot in the world.
Posted by denise | 24.08.08, 11:59 GMT
If all this alarmist stuff is true, how come the last major plane crash was already several days ago? In the time I've taken to write this, how many planes will have landed safely, without so much as a dinner-regurgitating bump, at Heathrow, Gatwick, and Stanstead combined? 150? 200? Then what about the rest of Europe? The States?
Worry about a serious danger to your health instead - a lightning strike, getting eaten by a shark, struck by UFO debris, etc.
Posted by Matthew | 24.08.08, 10:44 GMT
There are old pilots and there are bold pilots but there are no old, bold pilots.
Posted by PaddyMiguel | 24.08.08, 10:33 GMT
There's an old pilot's joke that goes like this..... standard row of three seats. A passenger walks in, takes the window seat, stows his carry-on in the overhead baggage rack, sorts his seatbelt out neatly, gets out a newspaper and begins reading calmly. He's a businessman who flies hundreds of thousands of miles a year.
The second passenger comes in looking nervously around him, fumbles with the seatbelt, tangles it, sits down looking a little nervous. It's his first flight ever.
The third passenger makes sure he gets the seat next to the aisle. You can see him calculating the distance to the emergency exit. He reads the safety instructions five times and checks each detail obsessively. Then the checks them again. Then he sits there pale and trembling. He is a pilot on holiday.
Posted by John Davies | 24.08.08, 10:04 GMT
there for the grace of God go I......gee thanks for this article - for all nervous flyers this will not help at all.
Could you just finish the article by at least saying whether death will come quickly or lingering?
Posted by lola | 24.08.08, 09:44 GMT
I told an airline pilot friend of mine that I had once been terrified of flying but now I wasn't. He looked at me sadly and said that I had it the wrong way round. He had spent his working life as a pilot and as a pilot trainer, and in his early years was totally confident about flying. He now spent his working days in a state of apprehension, with a general feeling of impending doom, because of the impact of cost-cutting on safety and maintenance standards, and the increasingly overcrowded airspace. Potentially lethal incidents occurred on almost every flight.
His advice was chilling. "Don't fly unless you absolutely have to ---"
Posted by Peter Curran | 24.08.08, 08:56 GMT