Commentators

null 13° London Hi 19°C / Lo 11°C

Yasmin Alibhai-Brown: In a sea of corruption we only catch the small fry

I met Derek Conway recently and there was no tremor of culpability

Monday, 7 July 2008

You can't blame Boris Johnson or Ray Lewis for being more baffled than mortified at what has just come to pass. "What is the big deal?" the chaps must be muttering to themselves. In the surf waves that crash in of political corruption and frequent transgressions, the scandal of the London Deputy Mayor is but a droplet. So, Lewis was investigated by the Met (three times, mind) in 1997 for alleged blackmail, then in 1999 after being accused of theft, and there were whisperings about sexual harassment. Not good for a former vicar, deputy prison governor and self-proclaimed saviour of black boys, admittedly, but was it really necessary for him to be pushed off so ignominiously?

Many don't think so and are indignant. They include Iain Duncan Smith, Francis Maude and Stephen Norris. Lewis may have been economical with the truth but, says one friend, the man was never crooked, he just had an "imprecise view of the world". What an imaginative excuse. The shady and shifty should use this one the next time they face stern Milords. Even Ken Livingstone, who stalks Boris like a vengeful ex-spouse, thinks Lewis, like everyone, just has a past.

Other prominent figures were self-righteously outraged when James McGrath, Boris's chief-of-staff, departed last month after "unfortunate" throwaway (not giveaway) comments he made to a black journalist suggesting that Caribbean Britons who said they would go back "home" if Boris became mayor could freely do so. These creatures of power and influence have been swimming in polluted waters and they cannot smell, see or touch the dirt. The idea of ethics and temperance in political life has receded so far that it is invisible to their eyes. When censured, therefore, it feels to them as if they are being sharked upon by a vicious press and public.

I met Derek Conway recently and there was no tremor of culpability anywhere on the jolly old geezer. His well-paid, indolent boys are even more brazen. And now Conway says MPs should get a £200,000 salary to attract exceptional minds like his, I guess – indispensable men of character. The Wintertons are similarly blasé about robbing the taxpayer by making a claim of £66,000 on a house which had no outstanding mortgage. Now we are paying for new rented quarters for this hideous couple, one a knight of the realm.

George Osborne, it has been revealed, received thousands of pounds for making a speech at a private business function. New Labour doesn't dare to condemn "Tory sleaze" because on its watch sordid deals and favours have become the norm. Under the Blairs, corruption got worse than under the bad old Tories and Brown has not yet shown he understands how much cleaning up there is for him to get on with.

"Poor me" Cherie still can't see why we despise her grossly excessive lifestyle and her holidays with Berlusconi. Wannabe deputy leader Peter Hain is being investigated for his fundraising methods. For some inexplicable reason, super-generous donations from friends of Israel remain unexplained. And now MPs, mainly Labour, including Jacqui Smith, and Andy Burnham and Peter Kilfolye (so-called man of the people) voted to keep all the their unfair perks, including the staggering John Lewis list. An independent commission suggested they mend their wicked ways and this lot have simply said fuck off.

Remember Elizabeth Filkin, the fine Parliamentary Commissioner for Standards? They got rid of her fast because she challenged this lax political culture. She didn't understand, apparently, that everyone was at it, the so-called "Dagenham defence", used by Ford car workers when caught smuggling out stolen goods. In 2006, a weary Alistair Graham, chairman of the Committee for Standards in Public Life, also had to go because he took his job seriously.

In Martin Bell's book, The Truth That Sticks, he writes: "Standards of conduct have fallen shamefully. Now the time has come for them to rise again. Reform is not only due, but overdue." The civil service, quangos, public service trusts and charities do not flout rules and corruption is not tolerated. But politics more and more swims free from constraints, contaminating itself and good people who became MPs who still try to do the right thing. In 1995, the Nolan report defined seven probity principles: selflessness, integrity, objectivity, accountability, openness, honesty and leadership.

In 2008, this list is as archaic as the ten commandments. Anything goes in politics. That being the case, you can see why it is so very hard for Lewis and Boris, and was previously for Ken and Lee Jasper. Why punish only small fry swimming with the big fish and the tide of filth? A fair question, and one that will not be silenced by the resignation of Lewis.

y.alibhai-brown@independent.co.uk

Interesting? Click here to explore further

Comments

31 Comments

James McGrath does not fit in with this article. His answer was quite correct and not racist. Anyone who threatens to leave the country if one of the two main parties wins is welcome to do so. In a democracy you have to accept that sometimes your party loses. If you cannot accept that go and find a one-party state.

Posted by David Gwilliam | 10.07.08, 10:33 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

This society is conceived for people whose only purpose in life is to get richer and richer. Exceeding in power means exceeding in corruption. fancy a change for better?

Posted by Lerga | 10.07.08, 00:33 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

Why do we always have to knock public sector emplyees. I think Martin Brighton and junk-male are confusing the status and ability to make decsions that affect others with 'corruption' ie bribery - they may not like/agree with some of the former, but we have laws on the latter. It is also clear that Yasmin thoroughly dislikes those in positions of authority in this country - the white ones that is.

Posted by sk | 08.07.08, 12:04 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

I agree with martin brighton. However, it will be of no consolation to know that the same conditions prevail in Australia, where Big Business and the various levels of government and property developers are so intertwined that overall that the spoils of the "State" are becoming the property of those who can give enough in donations to the various Parties.

Posted by Roy | 07.07.08, 22:08 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

It's not just political organisations that are institutionally corrupt. I have retired from teaching in adult education and I can tell you from experience that the 'Beacon College' where I worked was (and almost certainly remains) an utter shambles with a management structure that is incompetent from top to bottom and rotten to the core. The 'Senior Management Team' are answerable only to a week Principal who is turn responsible to a part time Board of Governors who are, in effect, answerable to no-one.

Posted by junk-male | 07.07.08, 20:45 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

This is undoubtedly one of the best articles from Yasmin.
The civil service, quangos, public service trusts and charities are. however, just as institutionally corrupt as this nulabor government.
Yasmin's description of the Sea Of Corruption has flooded every tier of our society. The corruption is absolute, and out of control, to the point where the ubiquitous corruption is often no longer seen for what it is. Let's not stop at MP's. Elected council members and their respective local authorities are also similarly blighted.
Being rotten to the core and from the core, and having neither the ability nor inclination to change, outside intevention is indicated. It may take more than a change of political party to excise the malignant cancer of corruption.
Thank you, Yasmin, for an excellent article.

Posted by martin brighton | 07.07.08, 18:52 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

I doubt Yasmin reads the comments left here, but if there is anyone who agrees with her that does, could they kindly explain what James McGrath said that was racist? Also, how - as she clumsily implies but weasels of of saying outright - it was a 'giveaway' comment?

(only replies that justify those comments about what he actually said, mind. Not one's that assume he said something like "black people should go back to Africa" which he didn't and would have been racist.)

Posted by sam | 07.07.08, 18:05 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

Well, the snouts remain firmly planted in the deep troughs of taxpayers money, and there are many of the privileged, who want them to remain there. There is no difference between Tory and Labour nowadays, there is too much at stake, and all politicians must answer to their sponsors - big business and the lobby groups. They regulate themselves, so there is little chance that anything will change, because power has corrupted them, and greed is a disease, which must be fed and treated regularly. Labour has aligned itself with society's elite, and has drifted far from the aims and ideals of the original party.
Ramsay MacDonald must be turning in his grave.

Posted by AndyUK | 07.07.08, 16:37 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

'Millions of people in this country are now looking to David Cameron to clear up British politics' Chris 14.04

Really? Well that's it then, Beachy Head for me.

Posted by Andrea | 07.07.08, 14:30 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

Millions of people in this country are now looking to David Cameron to clear up British politics. To get rid of all the corrupt flotsam & jetsom that has infested the British political system. David Cameron you have an opportunity, your time has come. Labour say you are a political lightweight who will wilt under pressure from the vested interests. The vested interests don't believe you have the courage to take them on. Take them on. Show courage like Magaret Thatcher did and make Blair & Brown look like the nobodies they are. If you fail, the consequences for democracy in this country will be catastrophic.

Posted by Chris - ex (lifelong) Labour voter | 07.07.08, 14:04 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

31 Comments

Columnist Comments

howard_jacobson

We like a mirthster, but smart-arsery is not funny

Nothing is sacred but not every act of satirical disrespect is funny.

deborah_orr

Deborah Orr: The Left's wet dream, or crazy market logic?

It's the intellectual chaos that is the really frightening thing.

christina_patterson

Christina Patterson: Art for when the bubble bursts

In the week the economy collapsed, I had a lovely time looking at art.


Most popular in Opinion