Leading Articles

null 0° London Hi 5°C / Lo 2°C

Leading article: A crisis that has vindicated the European Union

But it is still an exaggeration to say that Britain is at the heart of Europe

Thursday, 16 October 2008

There have been times in the history of EU summitry when the gatherings seemed no more than an excuse for a gourmet dinner. Not this time. The two-day summit that opened in Brussels yesterday has what must be one of the most packed agendas on record. Even Gordon Brown, notorious for his just-in-time arrivals and early departures, swept in early and gave interviews in front of a European flag that almost obscured the Union Jack.

Such are the extraordinary transformations wrought by this financial crisis. President Bush is accused of turning socialist; France's most free-market President for a generation has pronounced the end of laissez-faire; Britain's Conservatives are demanding curbs on City bonuses, and Mr Brown is not only travelling willingly to Brussels, but being feted when he gets there.

True to form, perhaps, he used his interviews to talk about the global, rather just the European, context. The huge rescue package for British banking that he and his Chancellor, Alistair Darling, made public before the London Stock Exchange opened on Monday might have provided a template for other EU countries to follow, but it was quickly also taken up by the United States. Now Mr Brown is calling for reform of the global financial system and its institutions, starting with the "rebuilding" of the IMF. This is ambitious but it is not unrealistic given the scale of the crisis, Mr Brown's long years as Chancellor, and his interests in globalisation and development.

But to concentrate right now on what might eventually be achieved in the global dimension – laudable and necessary as those plans might be – risks distracting attention from something that has already been achieved. As so often, it takes a certain distance to see clearly something that seems only a confused blur up close. What US and non-EU observers have noted, however, is that after some irritated huffing and puffing, some predictable striking of national poses and playing to party political galleries, the Europeans have been getting their act together.

The Brown-Darling rescue package, with its partial nationalisation of major British banks, might have supplied a model – and one that, with its roots in partial public ownership and limits on market excesses, chimes well with long-standing Continental inclinations – but its principles were swiftly accepted across the European Union. Further changes, such as higher guarantees on EU bank deposits and better capitalisation of European banks, look likely to follow. Europe could be closer to a common economic policy than it has ever been and, as the British involvement shows, one that is not restricted to the euro-zone.

From warnings that the euro could be strained to breaking point, expressions of relief can be heard around the world about its stabilising effect. Near-bankrupt Iceland has revived the question of EU membership. Negative comparisons are routinely drawn between the capacity of the US and the EU to act, despite the fact that the US, unlike the EU, is a sovereign state. In this crisis, the European Union for all its differences has so far acted quickly and cohesively – to the envy of some of our transatlantic friends.

Interesting? Click here to explore further

So, it was actually France that saved banking system? Its President Sarkozy called a the original meeting in Paris on 4 October. Brown was not invited. Luxumberg says UK came begging to be invited. France and Germany then said alright, you can come. Brown then politicised the whole thing in order to take advantage and get his ratings up in the polls. Now the truth is coming clear. Most of Europe is saying UK did thing. It was all our idea dn Brown stole it to claim credit. Brown you crafty %$&#*£!.

Posted by John | 16.10.08, 14:03 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

There is still time for Euro to face implosion on the back of all this. We really have only just started to see the fallout of the crisis manifest itself in the real economy. Europe is a cumbersome entity that has the turning capacity of an marine tanker weighed down by lead. Political unity is as far away now as it ever was and the divisions are liable to widen as each economy faces severe challenges. The Euro could well face destabilising forces which may well force the political questions to be answered sooner rather than later.

Posted by James C | 16.10.08, 11:03 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

So Brown paves the way for closer economic integration and common regulation? Is he doing this to spite Cameron, who will have to somehow find a way to say No, Nein, Non in 2010? There was always two important prerequisites for any Brown engagement in Europe. First the press must be convinced he is actually saving the Euro and secondly they must swallow the fiction that he has won important concessions to the running of the ECB and thirdly he must be portrayed as a world statesman. This is very easy to do with the British press at Brussels who speak no foreign language, read no foreign newspapers and don't understand a word said at any of the other press conferences, so feed off everything Brown's aides tell them.

Posted by john Walter | 16.10.08, 10:13 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

It's not a "Union Jack" (unless flown on a ship). It is, of course, the Union Flag.

Posted by Chris | 16.10.08, 09:56 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

I believe the Europeans would become a roaring success together, economically, culturally, and politically, if we decide to come together as a ...

*** CONFEDERACY ***

... and not a Union.

Coming together as a Union advances the NWO.

P.S. The United States is NOT a sovereign country. Its legal status is that of a CORPORATION.

Since the Act of 1871 which established the District of Columbia, American "citizens" have in fact been living under the UNITED STATES CORPORATION which is owned by certain international bankers and the aristocracy of Europe and Britain.

This is the truth. The much lauded American Constitution has been essentially void since 1871. President Abraham Lincoln was assassinated because he opposed this development.

The Bankers had Lincoln assassinated, just as they had President John F. Kennedy assassinated (and for similar reasons).

You try to oppose the bankers hegemony, and you risk inviting a "mysterious and violent" demise.

Posted by Errol Flynn | 16.10.08, 09:10 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

The only proposal agreed at the meeting of Eu finance ministers last week was a french proposal that finance ministers exchange personal mobile phone numbers to better cooridinate matters. The reality is that the EU has done nothing in this financial crisis. The fist inclnation of the French presidency was to ape the Paulson plan from the US. Then when the alternative Brown strategy emerged they aped that plan instead. The EU likes to claim the credit but the reality is that a deeply undemocratic regional body can have no part to play in a world financial crisis requiring significant tax-payer money (which the EU cannot raise) to address the issues.

Posted by Freeborn John | 16.10.08, 05:57 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

"The Guardian has learned that the European commission forced the government to ban the dividend pay-outs on the three banks taking part in the bail-out as the price for winning its approval under EU competition rules. It is understood that this was one of up to 10 conditions imposed by Brussels on the government as it sought clearance for its £500bn capital injection, debt guarantee and liquidity funding scheme last weekend"

This is why the EU is a dead weight on this country. A useless curse. It didn't stop the rampaging economic nationalism in Germany, Ireland and elsewhere. Europe dithered and each nation did its own thing anyway.

Time the EU was scrapped.

Posted by Neil Murphy | 16.10.08, 01:13 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

Columnist Comments

deborah_orr

Deborah Orr: One more inquiry isn't going to help

I don't believe a public inquiry into the Baby P case is necessary

hamish_mcrae

Hamish McRae: It will take time, but we'll recover

If officialdom seems over-optimistic in its forecasts, the markets seem too pessimistic

janet_street_porter

Janet Street-Porter: Mother does not always know best

One of the most sensitive subjects for writers is the mother-daughter relationship

mark_steel

Mark Steel: Never mind the baby, just get back to work

The next thing will be an exciting new scheme known as the 'workhouse'