Britain is suffering from a housing crisis - who is to blame and how can we fix it?

The Independent's economics editor Ben Chu rates the possible culprits and touted solutions and asks how likely they are to help us get through this mess…

Britain has a nightmare, and its name is housing. At the heart of the nightmare is the sheer expense. The average house costs five times the average person’s annual income, not far off record highs. And they’re going up too. In December house prices were almost 10 per cent higher than they were a year ago, largely thanks to George Osborne’s various mortgage subsidies. Rents have also been rising quickly too in recent years. Housing now eats up around 20 per cent of the typical family's weekly outgoings, up from 16 per cent in 2000. Housing is expensive for the Government too, as it must help the less well-off afford their soaring rents and there are now 1.7 million people hoping to secure a state-subsidised home.

Young people are finding it increasingly difficult to get on the housing ladder, and many are forced to live at home with their parents well into their twenties (or later) as they try to scrape together the enormous deposits demanded by the banks. Since the turn of the millennium, the proportion of the public who own their own homes has dipped from 70 per cent to 65 per cent, despite most people telling researchers they are as keen as ever to buy. Why is housing so dysfunctional in Britain? Here, we look at 10 oft-cited culprits and rate their level of blame – and we consider 10 frequently touted solutions and ask how likely they are to help us get through this mess…

TO BLAME?

1) Margaret Thatcher

The case against

In 1980, the Conservative Prime Minister gave council tenants the right to buy their houses at knockdown prices as part of her project of liberating people, as she saw it, from dependence on the state. But she did not allow councils to spend the proceeds from sales on building more council homes. The result was that the stock of state-owned homes dwindled, creating today's massive social-housing waiting lists and forcing many poorer people to rent from unscrupulous private landlords. The state must then subsidise those rents, hence the rocketing housing-benefit budget.

The verdict

Whatever one's view on the merits of Right to Buy, Mrs Thatcher undoubtedly diminished the social-housing stock. Yet no government since has done anything to restore council house constriction levels, so the blame cannot rest with her alone.

Culpability rating: *

2) Foreigners

The case against

A surge in immigration in recent decades has forced the existing population to compete with newcomers for housing. Unlike, say, America, Britain is densely populated and cannot respond to a sudden increase in demand for homes by simply building more. Too many people are chasing too few houses.

The verdict

While it is true that wealthy foreigners from Asia, the Middle East, Europe and America have been buying up property in the most desirable postcodes in London, pushing up prices in the capital, there is little evidence for the same effect in the rest of the country. Nor is there evidence of immigrants with families "jumping the queue" for social housing, a frequent complaint of the xenophobic right.

Rating: *

3) Buy-to-let landlords

The case against

Decades of rising house prices have encouraged many (particularly middle-aged) Britons to regard houses as financial assets, rather than simply as homes, and thus encouraged them to plough their savings into bricks and mortar and become landlords. Because "buy-to-let" landlords snap up so many properties, and since they are commonly favoured by the banks (as they can usually put more money down up front), younger people who merely want a place to live are often shut out of the market.

The verdict

Buy-to-let has certainly become popular among the postwar baby boom generation and banks have been happy to lend to landlords. But it is not clear that this trend has significantly worsened the property situation for younger people. Buy-to-let landlords often carve up big old houses and turn them into smaller flats to let. This has helped increase the supply of homes, rather than reduce it.

Rating: *

Margaret Thatcher's right-to-buy scheme reduced the stock of social housing, with disastrous consequences (Getty Images) Margaret Thatcher's right-to-buy scheme reduced the stock of social housing, with disastrous consequences (Getty Images)
4) "Nimbies"

The case against

Rural communities, mostly made up of the old and well-off, have been campaigning against new housing developments that could house younger people with families. Their selfish motivation is that new housing will block their views of the countryside and depress the value of their own homes. They often claim that they are, in fact, in favour of housing for the rural young – only "not in my backyard".

The verdict

Local campaigns have indeed stymied many new construction projects. There is a political dimension to this problem because local politicians are more attentive to the needs of older, retired homeowners, who tend to have time to devote to lobbying, while the younger working people who would benefit do not.

Rating: ***

5) The Campaign to Protect Rural England

The case against

CPRE and other rural campaign groups such as the National Trust constitute a formidable obstacle to any construction of houses on the "green belt", which has protected the countryside from development since the 1950s. Making this vast area of the country out of bounds for construction (only 13 per cent of the UK's land is built on) means there is massive pressure on existing overcrowded urban areas, where prices inevitably go up.

The verdict

These lobby groups, like the Nimbies, have political clout. They often work effectively with the media to intimidate politicians who try to increase construction in rural areas. Scaremongering headlines about plans to "tarmac the countryside" are ubiquitous. Even though not all of the green belt is equally valuable, the CPRE and the National Trust tend to treat any encroachment as intolerable.

Rating: ***

6) House builders

The case against

They don't build enough houses. This inflates their profits, because what new homes they do sell become more expensive. In a competitive market, new firms would enter and erode those profits by building homes. But this hasn't happened in housing, pointing to a market failure.

The verdict

There is some evidence of "land hoarding", whereby firms acquire land for development and then sit on it while it goes up in value, but these tend to be investment companies rather than builders. A 2008 probe by the Office of Fair Trading in 2008 found no evidence of monopolistic behaviour among builders.

Rating: *

7) The banks

The case against

The banks suddenly stopped lending to young people to buy new homes in the 2008 recession, and are only now beginning to do so again. They became excessively risk-averse, demanding massive deposits and high interest rates for new lending. This is why it has been so hard for youngsters to get on the housing ladder in recent years: there is demand out there but they can't get the finance.

The verdict

The banks did stop lending abruptly in the recession, having previously been liberal with mortgages. And it has undoubtedly become harder for young people to get on the ladder as a result. Yet banks are right to be wary about lending to young people who overstretch their finances and could have trouble making their payments if interest rates were to rise sharply.

Rating: *

The road to ruin: the Government's 'Help to Buy' scheme is pushing us into yet another boom-and-bust cycle (Reuters) The road to ruin: the Government's 'Help to Buy' scheme is pushing us into yet another boom-and-bust cycle (Reuters)
8) George Osborne

The case against

The Chancellor has cynically decided to stoke another housing bubble to give the economy a short-term sugar rush, with his Help to Buy scheme. This encourages youngsters to jump into an overvalued housing market by offering them state equity loans – which has helped prevent a correction of house prices and pushes us into another boom-and-bust cycle.

The verdict

No reputable independent economist looks favourably on Help to Buy. And despite the claims of the Government that it is spurring house building, there is little sign of it yet. Mr Osborne argues that he is helping first-time buyers. But this is belied by the fact that there is a second element of the scheme which guarantees mortgages up to £600,000 and which is open to all. The one defence of the Chancellor is that he is not responsible for the entire crisis; he is merely making it worse.

Rating: **

9) The law

The case against:

Compared with people in mainland Europe, renters in Britain have scanty rights. Contracts are often short-term, giving the whip hand to landlords. Fees for credit checks and estate agents can be large. This creates a corrosive feeling of insecurity for many renters.

The verdict:

Long-term renting is indeed more common on the Continent and it is very likely that greater tenant rights have something to do with that. If British renters had more rights vis a vis landlords, they might be less desperate to own their own homes, thus reducing demand for new mortgage loans.

Rating: ***

10) Councils

The case against

The planning system operated by local authorities is too restrictive. Developers want to start building but have to go through endless council approval processes and must negotiate a forest of red tape from town-hall bureaucrats. Reform this process and more homes will be built.

The verdict

Councils should certainly be more conducive to development. Many are overly influenced by nimby and rural lobbies (see above).

Rating: ****

Buy-to-let landlords snap up property, shutting younger buyers out of the housing market (Getty Images) Buy-to-let landlords snap up property, shutting younger buyers out of the housing market (Getty Images)
SOLUTIONS?

1) Control rents

The case for

Landlords are gouging tenants, who have nowhere else to go in such a severely squeezed housing market. To offer tenants protection, the Government should impose some kind of cap on rents. They could, for instance, limit rent rises to below the rate of inflation.

The verdict

Controlling rents might sound superficially attractive, but it would have baleful knock-on consequences. In American cities that have rent-controlled apartments, tenants have a strong incentive not to move, even if the housing is no longer suitable for them, as they would likely lose the benefit. Meanwhile, all of those who can't get rent-controlled apartments are no better off. Controls also tend to deter landlords from developing more properties, which means that supply is even more constrained.

Effectiveness rating: No stars

2) Impose a mansion tax

The case for

Property is under-taxed in Britain. People in £1m-plus homes should be forced to pay a special annual levy. This would ensure that the wealthy pay their fair share to the public coffers, release the air from the incipient property bubble, and also help curb our national obsession with home ownership.

The verdict

Property does look under-taxed. Council Tax valuations have not been reviewed since the 1990s. And it is a regressive tax, meaning that those in less expensive homes pay a larger share of the value of their homes each year than those in extremely valuable properties. Levies on static wealth such as housing are also more economically efficient than taxes on labour, such as income tax.

Rating: ***

3) Confiscate land from house builders

The case for

Because firms are land-hoarding for private profit, the state should step in to guarantee the public good. This would mean a "use-it-or-lose it" law, whereby if a plot of land is acquired but not built on within a certain time period, perhaps a year, the council would be allowed to seize the land and sell it to a developer.

The verdict:

Where markets are not functioning properly, the state sometimes intervenes, so there are grounds in principle for this. But there could be complications with state confiscation if it were not coupled with further planning reform, as there may be legitimate reasons for some development delays.

Rating: *

There is a strong case for a mansion tax on houses worth £1m-plus to help release the air in the property bubble (Alamy) There is a strong case for a mansion tax on houses worth £1m-plus to help release the air in the property bubble (Alamy)
4) Relax the planning laws

The case for

The planning laws are too restrictive and should be redrawn so that there is a strong presumption in favour of development when projects are proposed. This would unleash a flood of new building, increase supply and thus bring down prices. The Coalition has pushed through something along these lines.

The verdict

This is a sensible idea to counter the nimby lobby (see previous page), although it needs safeguards to ensure that construction isn't excessive or massively inappropriate.

Rating: ****

5) Protect tenants

The case for

As already discussed, tenants in Britain have minimal rights. Bolstering those rights would help create a renting-friendly culture. This would help Britain avoid some of the excesses of the boom-to-bust lending cycle. It would also make the workforce more mobile and result in less of our national wealth being tied up in housing stock.

The verdict

The ingrained British culture of aspiring towards home ownership will probably take a good deal more to eradicate than making life easier for tenants.

Rating: **

6) Impose a land value tax

The case for

Taxing the land underneath properties, based on its market value, would penalise anyone who did not develop land and generate an income from it. And people who live in desirable locations (and thus have expensive homes) would be required to pay a regular levy that would match the social benefit they receive. If councils received a share of the revenues, they would also have an incentive to develop more land.

The verdict

Taxing land values should have the same result as confiscating land from tardy developers and increasing the tax on expensive residences. The problem is that the land tax has been floating around as an idea in British politics for more than a century. The radical Liberal government of the Edwardian era came close to adopting it, but got cold feet. It is difficult to be optimistic that the time for this fine old idea has finally come now.

Rating: *****

The current rate of construction is at its lowest since the 1920s; indicators suggest the best way out of the housing crisis is to build - and keep building (Getty Images) The current rate of construction is at its lowest since the 1920s; indicators suggest the best way out of the housing crisis is to build - and keep building (Getty Images)
7) Ban multiple home ownership

The case for

The wealthy are snapping up multiple properties and rubbing their hands together as prices soar. They often leave properties empty in areas where poor people live in cramped conditions, fomenting resentment and inequality. No one really needs more than one house to provide them with shelter, so that is the limit. As housing is a scarce resource, it should be rationed.

The verdict

Another superficially attractive proposal that would have malign consequences. Depriving people of their legally acquired possessions should always be avoided if possible, especially when there are effective alternatives to solving social problems such as a housing shortage.

Rating: No stars

8) Subsidise mortgages

The case for

Because house prices are so high, young people should be given a helping hand from the state to get on to the housing ladder. This means offering first-time buyers an equity loan and then guaranteeing the rest of their mortgage so the bank is persuaded to lend to them – even though the property is worth many times their annual income and they can only muster a 5 per cent deposit. This is the Government's Help to Buy scheme.

The verdict

This terrible plan promises to inflate the demand for houses, yet do nothing to increase supply, ensuring that prices carry on rising. This means that future first-time buyers will need to take on even-larger mortgages relative to their incomes and require even more state support to be viable borrowers.

Rating: No stars

9) Help housing associations to borrow more

The case for

Since local authorities stopped building council houses in the 1980s, institutions called housing associations have partially filled the gap. These are non-profit-making firms that buy and rent out properties at affordable prices. Often their tenants are on income support or housing benefit. They use their surpluses to bring new properties forward either by building or renovating. A state guarantee of their borrowing, as implemented by the Coalition last year, should enable them to step up their building rates.

The verdict

A sound idea, but there would have to be tight safeguards. If a housing association were to borrow imprudently and go bust, it would have to be bailed out by the government, since otherwise its – often vulnerable – tenants could face eviction. The policy should be re-enforced by lifting the cap on council borrowing for home investment, allowing local authorities to build council houses directly once again.

Rating: ***

10) Build more houses

The case for

Britain simply does not build enough houses to meet rising demand. The rate of new-home construction is around 150,000 a year, the lowest since the 1920s. But annual demand for new residences is an estimated 250,000. The laws of supply and demand dictate rising prices. Building more houses by whatever means – giving councils bigger development budgets, easing planning restrictions, allowing housing associations to borrow, imposing a land value tax, etc – will increase supply and reduce prices, removing many of the symptoms of our housing nightmare.

The verdict

All roads lead to the same conclusion: Britain needs more new homes – and anything that helps generate that should be embraced.

Rating: *****

Ben Chu is economics editor of The Independent

“Correction: the original article stated “Allow housing associations to borrow”. This has been amended to “Help housing associations to borrow more”

Discover more property articles at Homes and Property
PROMOTED VIDEO
Property search
Property search
Have you tried new the Independent Digital Edition apps?
iJobs Job Widget
iJobs General

Nursery Manager

£100 - £110 per day: Randstad Education Ilford: Nursery Manager Long term Ran...

Sales Consultant – Permanent – West Sussex – £24-£25k plus commission and other benefits

£24000 - £25000 Per Annum plus company car and commission: Clearwater People S...

SEN Teaching Assistant

£45 - £65 per day: Randstad Education Bristol: Supply SEN Support Jobs in Bris...

SEN Teaching Assistant

£45 - £60 per day: Randstad Education Bristol: Supply SEN Support Jobs in Glou...

Day In a Page

Isis in Syria: A general reveals the lack of communication with the US - and his country's awkward relationship with their allies-by-default

A Syrian general speaks

A senior officer of Bashar al-Assad’s regime talks to Robert Fisk about his army’s brutal struggle with Isis, in a dirty war whose challenges include widespread atrocities
‘A bit of a shock...’ Cambridge economist with Glasgow roots becomes Zambia’s acting President

‘A bit of a shock...’ Economist with Glasgow roots becomes Zambia’s acting President

Guy Scott's predecessor, Michael Sata, died in a London hospital this week after a lengthy illness
Fall of the Berlin Wall: History catches up with Erich Honecker - the East German leader who praised the Iron Curtain and claimed it prevented a Third World War

Fall of the Berlin Wall

History catches up with Erich Honecker - the East German leader who praised the Iron Curtain and claimed it prevented a Third World War
How to turn your mobile phone into easy money

Turn your mobile phone into easy money

There are 90 million unused mobiles in the UK, which would be worth £7bn if we cashed them in, says David Crookes
Independent writers remember their Saturday jobs:

Independent writers remember their Saturday jobs

"I have never regarded anything I have done in "the media" as a proper job"
Lyricist Richard Thomas shares his 11-step recipe for creating a hit West End musical

11-step recipe for creating a West End hit

Richard Thomas, the lyricist behind the Jerry Springer and Anna Nicole Smith operas, explains how Bob Dylan, 'Breaking Bad' and even Noam Chomsky inspired his songbook for the new musical 'Made in Dagenham'
Tonke Dragt's The Letter for the King has finally been translated into English ... 50 years on

Buried treasure: The Letter for the King

The coming-of-age tale about a boy and his mission to save a mythical kingdom has sold a million copies since it was written by an eccentric Dutchwoman in 1962. Yet until last year, no one had read it in English
Can instilling a sense of entrepreneurship in pupils have a positive effect on their learning?

The school that means business

Richard Garner heads to Lancashire, where developing the 'dragons' of the future is also helping one community academy to achieve its educational goals
10 best tablets

The world in your pocket: 10 best tablets

They’re thin, they’re light, you can use them for work on the move or keeping entertained
Lutz Pfannenstiel: The goalkeeper who gave up Bayern Munich for the Crazy Gang, Bradford and a whirlwind trawl across continents

Lutz Pfannenstiel interview

The goalkeeper who gave up Bayern Munich for the Crazy Gang, Bradford and a whirlwind trawl across continents
Pete Jenson: Popular Jürgen Klopp can reignite Borussia Dortmund’s season with visit to Bayern Munich

Pete Jenson's a Different League

Popular Klopp can reignite Dortmund’s season with visit to Bayern
John Cantlie video proves that Isis expects victory in Kobani

Cantlie video proves that Isis expects victory in Kobani

The use of the British hostage demonstrates once again the militants' skill and originality in conducting a propaganda war, says Patrick Cockburn
The killer instinct: The man who helps students spot potential murderers

The killer instinct

Phil Chalmers travels the US warning students how to spot possible future murderers, but can his contentious methods really stop the bloodshed?
Clothing the gap: A new exhibition celebrates women who stood apart from the fashion herd

Clothing the gap

A new exhibition celebrates women who stood apart from the fashion herd
Fall of the Berlin Wall: Goodbye to all that - the lost world beyond the Iron Curtain

The Fall of the Berlin Wall

Goodbye to all that - the lost world beyond the Iron Curtain