Rash of referrals blight the game
Monday 02 March 2009
No other sport could get itself into such an unholy mess. No other governing body but the International Cricket Council could mean so well with such a dire outcome.
The trial regulation officially known as the Umpiring Decision Review System has, once more, made Test cricket a figure of fun.
It is supposed to be the purest, most protected form of the game, trading on the eternal verities. The review system was introduced in the innocent desire to eradicate, with the help of technology, umpiring errors. Instead, as the series between England and the West Indies has confirmed, it is a blot on the landscape, like building a casino in a conservation area.
Doubts were sown during the first Test in Kingston but there was room for forgiveness because the players and officials were putting their toes in alien waters. The fourth Test in Barbados, however, has merely exacerbated the worst fears.
This was manifest on the third day by the case of Shivnarine Chanderpaul, the world's No 2 ranked batsman. He was given out lbw to Jimmy Anderson when he was 70 and involved in a match-saving partnership with Ramnaresh Sarwan. Since it was patently obvious to most naked eyes, except those belonging to the umpire, Russell Tiffin, that the ball would have gone over the top of the stumps, Chanderpaul asked for a review of the decision.
Under the regulations for the series, each side is allowed two unsuccessful referrals in each innings whether batting or bowling. It was confidently expected that Chanderpaul would be reprieved. Somewhat surprisingly, the third umpire Daryl Harper must have disagreed. In cases such as these it is his job to impart information to the on-field umpire which might persuade him to change his mind.
As the regulation puts it: "If an out decision is being reviewed the TV umpire should have a high degree of confidence that the ball would have made no contact with any part of the stumps or bails in order to report that the ball would have missed the stumps."
He is allowed to use slow-motion replays and tracking devices only until the point of impact. Still, as the Chanderpaul case demonstrated, one man's high degree of confidence is another being wracked with doubt.
In all, four of the first five West Indies wickets to fall came after reviews, which take an interminable time and, pertinently, are rarely conclusive. This is the third series and in terms of media coverage the one with the highest profile in which the trial has been conducted. Three referrals have been reduced to two.
The system was dropped for the hastily arranged match in Antigua as the technology could not be moved in time. It was all the better for it and the players were much more relaxed. But cricket continues to find ways of making itself look perfectly stupid. Time to review the reviews.
Jose Mourinho: 'The dogs bark and the caravan goes by,' Chelsea manager gives cryptic assessment after Blues win title
Floyd Mayweather next opponent: Mayweather more likely to pick a former foe than a fresh contender like Amir Khan in Las Vegas lottery
Manchester United transfer news: Adnan Januzaj to be offered in deal for Memphis Depay
Arsenal transfer news: Tomas Rosicky and Mathieu Flamini set for showdown summer talks over future
Arsenal transfer news: Arsene Wenger reveals: 'We are not close to signing anybody. We need to lose some players'
- 2 How the language you speak changes your view of the world
- 4 Italian police 'reveal' what Jesus looked like as a young boy
In defence of liberal democracy
Over 50,000 families shipped out of London boroughs in the past three years due to welfare cuts and soaring rents
EU asylum policy is 'a direct threat to our civilisation', says Nigel Farage
The Rothschild Libel: Why has it taken 200 years for an anti-Semitic slur that emerged from the Battle of Waterloo to be dismissed?
General Election 2015: UK will be 'run for the wealthy and powerful' if Tories retain power, Labour warns
Schools forced to act as 'miniature welfare states' with teachers buying underwear and even haircuts for poor pupils