Dream team v scream team

Colin Murray's axing as host of 'Match of the Day 2' has trained spotlight on the abilities of studio 'experts'; Chris McGrath picks his best and worst line-ups for fans on the sofa

You can't apply the usual Fantasy Football rules to this exercise. For a start, a budget of £100m would barely upholster the sofa required to cushion the drooling somnambulists who slump together every Saturday night on Match of the Day. But football on TV above all needs to go outside the box, as it were, and abandon its discredited enslavement to ex-players.

Many exasperated viewers nowadays measure mainstream cliché and consensus against the sophistication and heterodoxy they reliably find elsewhere. Yet producers and pundits alike persevere in the fatuous misapprehension that you are only eligible to pass comment if you have also passed the ball at the highest level – unlike, say, Jose Mourinho or Andre Villas-Boas. That's why the first name on the team sheet is blank, a rotation of the best voices emerging from underground. We all have our favourites, from podcasts or Press Pass or Revista La Liga or whatever, and every few weeks yours would be on the show.

Rare is the man both eligible to comment, according to all these complacent ex-pros, and competent to comment, as a broadcaster. In fact, he is just about unique – and his name is Gary Neville. Never the most popular of players, he has dismantled all prejudice with his meticulous insights on Sky. On Monday, he froze frames of Nemanja Vidic staring at David de Gea after Manchester United conceded that last-gasp equaliser. "It's not because he fancies him," he deadpanned.

Neville is an automatic choice, albeit his rather solemn, urgent style probably needs complementing with a lighter touch. But that is only one of many reasons for installing James Richardson as host. He is funny and intelligent but has the humility, rare in his line of business, not to impose his personality on proceedings. Perhaps that is why much of his career has been mysteriously wasted on the margins. Unless it is because he might not indulge undue egotism in anyone else, either – a major problem, demonstrably, for the current MOTD shower.

Jeff Stelling would bring many of the same virtues, and more smoothly. In a spirit of Fantasy Football, however, we'll limit the number of appointments from any one channel. Perhaps the other man from Sky can instead be Graeme Souness, if only because he shows uncompromising opinion is permitted even to ageing Anfield stars. He seems immune to the endemic vice of the ex-players, who dread offending anyone they might meet at a golf day.

From ITV and its coverage of this weekend's FA Cup action we'll summon Lee Dixon, far too considered and pleasant a fellow to have lingered long in the MOTD clubhouse, while Pat Nevin represents the BBC, where his fringe role betrays the corporation's chronic mistrust of cerebral flavours among the slop of blandness.

Now for the nightmare line-up. If restricting ourselves to no more than two per channel, we are somehow supposed to omit one of those weird shirts from MOTD. At the end of the deah, you know Alan Shearer will come in and do a job; and Alan Hansen would be unforgivable. Diabolical. (But how do we leave out hangdog Lawro? I know, I know…) For Sky, Jamie Redknapp is a top, top pundit. Literally. ITV offers one or two nice guys with nothing to say and a nasty one with disappointingly little to say in Roy Keane.

As anchor, let's recall Richard Keys from radio to remind everyone what a blessing Sky made of the crossroads it met when required to dispense with his smug, creepy style. To think people feared Keys and Andy Gray might leave a void! To remind yourself exactly what those look like, you only have to tune in to MOTD every Saturday.

Pundit fantasy five-a-side: best and worst of talking heads

Gary Neville (capt)

Most likely to say: "He shouldn't be there. And he shouldn't be turning his back."

Least likely to say: "I know he's achieved a lot but I do wish Sir Alex would try zonal marking."

Graeme Souness

Most likely to say: "If I was his manager and he did that I would have him on a butcher's hook for a week."

Least likely to say: "It's easy to say that he underhit that back pass, but sometimes funny things can happen with these balls when it's damp."

Pat Nevin

Most likely to say: "The trajectory of that pass reminds me of something I once saw in the Schirn Kunsthalle at Frankfurt."

Least likely to say: "Can't we get a new theme tune done by Phil Collins?"

James Richardson

Most likely to say: "It's high time we put the pun back into punditry."

Least likely to say: "And that's why Italy, Spain and Germany are all looking on enviously at the greatest league in the world."

Lee Dixon

Most likely to say: "I don't have a problem with that, but I do think it would help if they looked at it this way."

Least likely to say: "To be honest, I'm not really sure what I'm looking at, now I don't have the two Alans to explain it."

Alan Shearer (capt)

Most likely to say: "OK, should have scored, but it was good play. They'll be all right."

Least likely to say: "I've seen a lot of this kid for Catania and I think he could be the making of Frei at Fulham."

Roy Keane

Most likely to say: "What am I doing with this bunch of *^#@*?"

Least likely to say: "Of course, I might be wrong. I'll look into it thoroughly and see."

Richard Keys

Most likely to say: "That Gary Neville, he's working for al-Qaeda. You wait and see."

Least likely to say: "Don't you think we need more women on this panel?"

Alan Hansen

Most likely to say: "Pace. Power. Grit. Determination. And that's an unbelievable pass."

Least likely to say: "Now see how Martinez changed it after he brought Jordi Gomez on."

Jamie Redknapp

Most likely to say: "They've shown literally 200 per cent improvement since he came back – he's a top, top professional."

Least likely to say: "He's a friend but I'd say it to his face: he's had an absolute shocker today. I'm sorry, but he's over the hill."

Have you tried new the Independent Digital Edition apps?
Arts and Entertainment
Buttoned up: Ryan Reynolds with Helen Mirren in ‘Woman in Gold’
filmFor every box-office smash in his Hollywood career, there's always been a misconceived let-down. Now he says it's time for a reboot
News
people
News
Actress Julianne Moore wins the Best Actress in a Leading Role Award for 'Still Alice' during the 87th Annual Academy Awards in Hollywood, California
people
Sport
Ross Barkley
footballPaul Scholes says it's time for the Everton playmaker to step up and seize the England No 10 shirt
News
'We will fix it': mice in the 1970s children’s programme Bagpuss
science
Life and Style
2 Karl Lagerfeld and Choupette
fashion
Caption competition
Caption competition
  • Get to the point
Latest stories from i100
Have you tried new the Independent Digital Edition apps?

Bleacher Report

Daily Quiz
Independent Dating
and  

By clicking 'Search' you
are agreeing to our
Terms of Use.

Day In a Page

War with Isis: Iraq declares victory in the battle for Tikrit - but militants make make ominous advances in neighbouring Syria's capital

War with Isis

Iraq declares victory in the battle for Tikrit - but militants make make ominous advances in neighbouring Syria
Scientists develop mechanical spring-loaded leg brace to improve walking

A spring in your step?

Scientists develop mechanical leg brace to help take a load off
Peter Ackroyd on Alfred Hitchcock: How London shaped the director's art and obsessions

Peter Ackroyd on Alfred Hitchcock

Ackroyd has devoted his literary career to chronicling the capital and its characters. He tells John Walsh why he chose the master of suspense as his latest subject
Ryan Reynolds interview: The actor is branching out with Nazi art-theft drama Woman in Gold

Ryan Reynolds branches out in Woman in Gold

For every box-office smash in Ryan Reynolds' Hollywood career, there's always been a misconceived let-down. It's time for a rethink and a reboot, the actor tells James Mottram
Why Robin Williams safeguarded himself against a morbid trend in advertising

Stars safeguard against morbid advertising

As film-makers and advertisers make increasing posthumous use of celebrities' images, some stars are finding new ways of ensuring that they rest in peace
The UK horticulture industry is facing a skills crisis - but Great Dixter aims to change all that

UK horticulture industry facing skills crisis

Great Dixter manor house in East Sussex is encouraging people to work in the industry by offering three scholarships a year to students, as well as generous placements
Hack Circus aims to turn the rule-abiding approach of TED talks on its head

Hack Circus: Technology, art and learning

Hack Circus aims to turn the rule-abiding approach of TED talks on its head. Rhodri Marsden meets mistress of ceremonies Leila Johnston
Sevenoaks is split over much-delayed decision on controversial grammar school annexe

Sevenoaks split over grammar school annexe

If Weald of Kent Grammar School is given the go-ahead for an annexe in leafy Sevenoaks, it will be the first selective state school to open in 50 years
10 best compact cameras

A look through the lens: 10 best compact cameras

If your smartphone won’t quite cut it, it’s time to invest in a new portable gadget
Paul Scholes column: Ross Barkley played well against Italy but he must build on that. His time to step up and seize that England No 10 shirt is now

Paul Scholes column

Ross Barkley played well against Italy but he must build on that. His time to step up and seize that England No 10 shirt is now
Why Michael Carrick is still proving an enigma for England

Why Carrick is still proving an enigma for England

Manchester United's talented midfielder has played international football for almost 14 years yet, frustratingly, has won only 32 caps, says Sam Wallace
Tracey Neville: The netball coach who is just as busy as her brothers, Gary and Phil

Tracey Neville is just as busy as her brothers, Gary and Phil

The former player on how she is finding time to coach both Manchester Thunder in the Superleague and England in this year's World Cup
General Election 2015: The masterminds behind the scenes

The masterminds behind the election

How do you get your party leader to embrace a message and then stick to it? By employing these people
Machine Gun America: The amusement park where teenagers go to shoot a huge range of automatic weapons

Machine Gun America

The amusement park where teenagers go to shoot a huge range of automatic weapons
The ethics of pet food: Why are we are so selective in how we show animals our love?

The ethics of pet food

Why are we are so selective in how we show animals our love?