Can the Premier League clubs find a wage cap that fits all?

The logical solution to protect clubs from themselves is to tie wages to turnover as now happens in League's One and Two

To no great surprise the 20 Premier League clubs failed to agree on a form of salary capping this week, though they promised to revisit the subject in the new year. Rather like the newspapers post-Leveson there is a broad agreement that "something must be done", but, as with the newspapers, so disparate are the individual perspectives, finding agreement on what should be done is challenging.

At least the press are united by a single threat, that of Government intervention. The clubs do not even agree on the problem. While for most the issue is how to resolve the bizarre conundrum of an industry that is experiencing an extraordinary boom yet fails to produce a financial return, others (Arsenal, Manchester United) view a salary cap as a means of combating clubs with limitless resources (Manchester City, Chelsea). There are also a few who object to any cap either because they fear it would make their club less attractive to investors or it would destroy their operating model. Aston Villa, West Bromwich, Fulham and Manchester City are reportedly among the objectors.

What is not in doubt is that wages have increased exponentially during the Premier League era, growing even faster than the explosion in television income. Even with clubs exploiting other revenue streams, notably charging ever-higher ticket prices and developing the global market, they have failed to prevent wage ratios when measured against turnover from spiralling.

In 1995-96 the 20 Premier League clubs had a joint turnover of £346m, out of which they paid £173m in wages, a ratio of 50 per cent, resulting in a collective profit (before transfers) of £52m (an average £2.6m each). Fifteen years later in 2010-11 (the last season for which all clubs' figures are available) Manchester United alone turned over £331m, with the league's revenue as a whole totalling £2bn. But wages had mushroomed with the result that eight of the 20 clubs recorded a loss.

The suggested barometer above which wages are a cause for concern is two-thirds of income. Of the 20 current Premier League clubs only five were within that range in 2010-11: Arsenal, Manchester United, Tottenham, Newcastle United and West Bromwich Albion. All are noted for keeping a relatively tight rein on wages – Manchester United may pay big money, but they earn big money.

Four clubs had a wage bill that exceeded their entire turnover: Aston Villa, Manchester City, Queen's Park Rangers and Swansea. The latter two were in the Championship, and in the process of going up, but while promotion would have brought in vastly increased income, it is probable, given their transfer activity and limited ground capacity, that QPR's wage bill still exceeds 100 per cent of turnover.

Villa's situation is instructive. In 1995-96, despite keeping wages to 41 per cent of turnover, the club came fourth under Brian Little, as well as making a decent profit. By 2010-11 Villa's turnover had increased five-fold but wages were 103 per cent of income, precipitating a £34m loss. And the club finished ninth. By then owner Randy Lerner, having taken fright at the cost of attempting to break into the top four, had already decided to rein in expenditure and the consequences were starting to show with results waning and Martin O'Neill walking out in 2010. Villa now pursue a youth-first policy, supplemented by lesser-known overseas talent.

Manchester City, like Chelsea, operate under different conditions to the rest of the league, especially City who are playing the same game of catch-up Chelsea did when Roman Abramovich arrived in 2003.

Both clubs have driven up wages. Manchester United have been able to compete because Old Trafford is the country's biggest domestic stadium and they have a global support to "monetise". Arsenal have competed up to a point because of continued Champions League participation, supplemented by the lucrative Emirates Stadium. Tottenham, by dint of Daniel Levy's acumen have hung in, but others have struggled to compete. Newcastle are sensibly run now, but that was not always the case, and for every West Brom, shrewdly banking their parachute payments as they yo-yoed between the Premier League and Championship, before using them to stabilise, there has been a Portsmouth or Leeds, Birmingham or Coventry.

If it is clear from the accompanying table that wage restraint is even harder outside the top flight than in it (thus the spread of salary capping measures in the Football League) the majority of top-flight clubs now recognise the only winners in this arms race are players and agents.

So what is to be done? The logical solution to protect clubs from themselves is to tie wages to turnover as now happens in League's One and Two. However, like Uefa's Financial Fair Play plans and those in the Championship, which follow a "break-even" principle, that will effectively preserve the status quo making it difficult for owners to challenge the established order. The same applies to any regulation limiting annual wage increases to a set percentage.

Unsurprisingly the likes of Arsenal and Manchester United favour these models. "You should just get the resources you generate, that will determine the real size of the club," said Arsène Wenger this season.

It is not just City and Chelsea who object to this, Fulham have long been bankrolled by Mohamed al-Fayed and he has reportedly threatened legal action if prevented from continuing to support the club financially.

An alternative is an annual limit to how much can be added to the collective wage bill, with Sunderland's Ellis Short understood to have suggested £4m. This would probably benefit the middle-sized clubs, enabling them to close the gap, but not arrivistes. It should also ensure some of the new £5bn TV deal, which will bring in £60-100m a year per club, ends up in the accounts of those owners who expect a financial return as well as reflected glory.

Most clubs' approach is one-eyed. Reading and Southampton opposed FFP when they were spending to get out of the Championship last year; they support it now. Wigan chairman Dave Whelan massively outspent his club's income as he propelled them up the league – Wigan's wages-turnover ratio in 1995-96 was a staggering 223 per cent – now his team is a small fish in a big pool he wants clubs to show restraint.

What is not on the agenda is a limit on owners piling debt onto clubs. A personal view is that Uefa and the English game should allow big investment but only if, as with City, Chelsea and Southampton, owners' loans are converted into equity not dumped on the balance sheet. That way a club's future is protected. In addition a much larger slice of income should be directed into grassroots and other good causes before the owners get their mitts on it. Both measures would indirectly curb wage inflation.

What is crystal clear is that left to their own devices too many clubs will continue to spurn the opportunities offered by the greatest bonanza in the game's history.

twitter.com/GlennMoore7

Unbalanced books: Premier wage inflation

1995-96:

*Revenue *Profit Wages Ratio

[£m] (loss) [£m]

Arsenal 21 2.5 10 48%

Aston Villa 18.9 5.8 7.7 41%

Chelsea 15.9 0.7 9.2 58%

Everton 17 1.3 10.1 59%

Fulham (L2) 1.4 (0.5) 1.2 86%

Liverpool 27.4 7.4 13.2 48%

Man City 12.7 0.8 6.4 50%

Man Utd 53.3 16.7 13.3 25%

Newcastle 29 0.8 6.4 20%

**Norwich (C) 5.2 (2.4) 5.6 108%

QPR 7.2 (1.3) 5 69%

Reading (C) 2.8 (-1) 3.1 111%

So'ton 7.6 1.6 4 53%

Stoke (C) 3.7 0 2.5 68%

Sund'land (C) 7.2 (0.4) 4.5 62%

Swansea (L1) 1.2 0.3 1 83%

Spurs 27.4 15.5 11.5 42%

WBA (C) 5.4 0.3 2.7 50%

West Ham 12 1.4 6.2 52%

Wigan (L2) 0.6 (1.1) 1.4 233%

2010-11:

*Revenue *Profit Wages Ratio

[£m] (loss) [£m]

Arsenal 226.8 34.1 124.4 55%

Aston Villa 92 (34.2) 94.8 103%

Chelsea 228.6 (48.7) 191.2 84%

Everton 82 (0.5) 58 71%

Fulham 77.1 2.6 57.7 75%

Liverpool 183.7 (2.8) 134.8 73%

Man City 153.2 (81.6) 174 114%

Man Utd 331.4 100.7 152.9 46%

Newcastle 88.5 13.3 53.6 61%

Norwich (C) 23.4 (3.4) 18.4 79%

QPR (C) 16.2 (22.5) 29.7 183%

Reading (C) 23.1 (8.4) 20.5 89%

So’ton (L1) 16.4 (11.5) 15.3 93%

Stoke 66.8 8.5 47.1 70%

Sunderland 79.5 (2.1) 60.9 77%

Swansea (C) 11.7 (9.1) 17.4 149%

Spurs 163.5 32.3 91.3 56%

WBA 65.1 11.8 43.9 67%

West Ham 80.9 6.8 55.7 69%

Wigan 50.5 6.8 39.9 79%

*Excluding transfer fees.

**six-month figures, doubled for comparison.

C=Championship; L1/2=League One/Two equivalent

News
The Banksy image in Folkestone before it was vandalised
people
Life and Style
tech

Sales of the tablet are set to fall again, say analysts

Sport
football West Brom vs Man Utd match report: Blind grabs point, but away form a problem for Van Gaal
Arts and Entertainment
Gotham is coming to UK shores this autumn
tvGotham, episode 2, review
PROMOTED VIDEO
Have you tried new the Independent Digital Edition apps?
News
i100
Arts and Entertainment
Bloom Time: Mira Sorvino
tvMira Sorvino on leaving movie roles for 'The Intruders'
News
Brian Harvey turned up at Downing Street today demanding to speak to the Prime Minister
news

Met Police confirm there was a 'minor disturbance' and that no-one was arrested

Arts and Entertainment
George Lucas poses with a group of Star Wars-inspired Disney characters at Disney's Hollywood Studios in 2010
films

George Lucas criticises the major Hollywood film studios

Voices
Chris Grayling, Justice Secretary: 'There are pressures which we are facing but there is not a crisis'
voices

Does Chris Grayling realise what a vague concept he is dealing with?

Life and Style
A street vendor in Mexico City sells Dorilocos, which are topped with carrot, jimaca, cucumber, peanuts, pork rinds, spices and hot sauce
food + drink

Trend which requires crisps, a fork and a strong stomach is sweeping Mexico's streets

Life and Style
The charity Sands reports that 11 babies are stillborn everyday in the UK
lifeEleven babies are stillborn every day in the UK, yet no one speaks about this silent tragedy
News
Blackpool is expected to become one of the first places to introduce the Government’s controversial new Public Space Protection Orders (PSPOs)
news

Parties threaten resort's image as a family destination

Life and Style
Northern soul mecca the Wigan Casino
fashionGone are the punks, casuals, new romantics, ravers, skaters, crusties. Now all kids look the same
Life and Style
gaming

I Am Bread could actually be a challenging and nuanced title

News
Nigel Farage has backed DJ Mike Read's new Ukip song
i100
Caption competition
Caption competition
Latest stories from i100
Have you tried new the Independent Digital Edition apps?

Bleacher Report

Daily Quiz
Independent Dating
and  

By clicking 'Search' you
are agreeing to our
Terms of Use.

Day In a Page

Oscar Pistorius sentencing: The athlete's wealth and notoriety have provoked a long overdue debate on South African prisons

'They poured water on, then electrified me...'

If Oscar Pistorius is sent to jail, his experience will not be that of other inmates
James Wharton: The former Guard now fighting discrimination against gay soldiers

The former Guard now fighting discrimination against gay soldiers

Life after the Army has brought new battles for the LGBT activist James Wharton
Ebola in the US: Panic over the virus threatens to infect President Obama's midterms

Panic over Ebola threatens to infect the midterms

Just one person has died, yet November's elections may be affected by what Republicans call 'Obama's Katrina', says Rupert Cornwell
Premier League coaches join the RSC to swap the tricks of their trades

Darling, you were fabulous! But offside...

Premier League coaches are joining the RSC to learn acting skills, and in turn they will teach its actors to play football. Nick Clark finds out why
How to dress with authority: Kirsty Wark and Camila Batmanghelidjh discuss the changing role of fashion in women's workwear

How to dress with authority

Kirsty Wark and Camila Batmanghelidjh discuss the changing role of fashion in women's workwear
New book on Joy Division's Ian Curtis sheds new light on the life of the late singer

New book on Ian Curtis sheds fresh light on the life of the late singer

'Joy Division were making art... Ian was for real' says author Jon Savage
Sean Harris: A rare interview with British acting's secret weapon

Sean Harris: A rare interview with British acting's secret weapon

The Bafta-winner talks Hollywood, being branded a psycho, and how Barbra Streisand is his true inspiration
Tim Minchin, interview: The musician, comedian and world's favourite ginger is on scorching form

Tim Minchin interview

For a no-holds-barred comedian who is scathing about woolly thinking and oppressive religiosity, he is surprisingly gentle in person
Boris Johnson's boozing won't win the puritan vote

Boris's boozing won't win the puritan vote

Many of us Brits still disapprove of conspicuous consumption – it's the way we were raised, says DJ Taylor
Ash frontman Tim Wheeler reveals how he came to terms with his father's dementia

Tim Wheeler: Alzheimer's, memories and my dad

Wheeler's dad suffered from Alzheimer's for three years. When he died, there was only one way the Ash frontman knew how to respond: with a heartfelt solo album
Hugh Bonneville & Peter James: 'Peter loves his classic cars; I've always pootled along fine with a Mini Metro. I think I lack his panache'

How We Met: Hugh Bonneville & Peter James

'Peter loves his classic cars; I've always pootled along fine with a Mini Metro. I think I lack his panache'
Bill Granger recipes: Our chef's heavenly crab dishes don't need hours of preparation

Bill Granger's heavenly crab recipes

Scared off by the strain of shelling a crab? Let a fishmonger do the hard work so you can focus on getting the flavours right
Radamel Falcao: How faith and love drive the Colombian to glory

Radamel Falcao: How faith and love drive the Colombian to glory

After a remarkable conversion from reckless defender to prolific striker, Monaco's ace says he wants to make his loan deal at Old Trafford permanent
Terry Venables: Premier League managers must not be allowed to dictate who plays and who does not play for England

Terry Venables column

Premier League managers must not be allowed to dictate who plays and who does not play for England
The Inside Word: Brendan Rodgers looks to the future while Roy Hodgson is ghost of seasons past

Michael Calvin's Inside Word

Brendan Rodgers looks to the future while Roy Hodgson is ghost of seasons past