Ferguson refuses to point finger at fragile defence
It is just one of those high-scoring seasons, says manager of United's failings at the back
Digg
del.icio.us
Facebook
Reddit
Google
Stumble Upon
Fark
Newsvine
YahooBuzz
Bebo
Twitter
Independent Minds
enlarge
For a manager whose championships have been built on rock-solid defence – just 24, 22 and 27 goals conceded in the past three title-winning seasons – Sir Alex Ferguson's explanation yesterday of his side's sudden defensive fallibility was odd.
"You have to look at the number of goals scored in the Premier League this season as opposed to the previous season," Ferguson said. "It's the most there's been, maybe we are just in one of these unusual seasons." Granted, 319 goals scored against 299 at the same period last season but Manchester United are not one of those sides whose defence is supposed to cave in.
It has hardly been an avalanche of balls bulging in their own net – in the league United have shipped 11, as opposed to nine at the same point last season – but none of their six clean sheets have been against distinguished opposition and the frailties exposed by Manchester City, Sunderland, Liverpool and then CSKA Moscow in midweek augur ill for the meeting with Didier Drogba and Chelsea tomorrow. Carlo Ancelotti's side, incidentally, have kept nine clean sheets and conceded only one goal on the way to maximum points at Stamford Bridge this season.
For their part, United have started with 12 different defences in Premier League and European competition, if you include the goalkeeper. Ben Foster's eight-match Premier League run deputising for Edwin van der Sar contributed to the poor communication, which has seemed so uncharacteristic, and the Dutchman's return has coincided with Rio Ferdinand's collapse in form, which has led some to a fundamental reappraisal of the defender.
Both Ferguson and Wes Brown have admitted this week that Ferdinand has been playing while injured and there was a worrying prognosis yesterday from the manager, who said United are baffled as to why he cannot recover from a calf injury which has seen him missing since Fernando Torres gave him the runaround at Anfield two weeks ago.
"We don't know exactly where the calf injury is coming from, whether it is coming from the lower back or whether it's a nerve thing," Ferguson said. "Calf injuries are usually two to three weeks, but there's no sign of him recovering from this injury. We're looking at the whole situation – whether or not it's coming from the back – but in the meantime he's out. There's no improvement, put it that way, so we're looking at something different."
With none of last Tuesday's back four – Gary Neville, Brown, Jonny Evans and Fabio da Silva – looking comfortable, United can take some heart from Nemanja Vidic's expected return from a calf injury tomorrow – possibly alongside Evans with Brown switching to right-back as United attempt to repel the vibrant Drogba, 12 goals to the good in all competitions.
Vidic's dismissal in the 2-0 defeat at Anfield overshadowed a big display in which he seemed intent on demonstrating that Torres does not have the Indian sign over him and went some way to achieving that. Meanwhile, Brown is still playing his way back in after the last injury-ravaged season.
Ferguson's rather unconvincing support of his side's rearguard also included the suggestion that the dubious defending against CSKA was a product of his side experimentation . "In a way we experimented a little bit," Ferguson said. "It didn't particularly work but in saying that, by being so open we've created 10-12 chances in the match. It's the devil and deep blue seas sometimes. We were open because of it and we won't be as open on Sunday I hope."
United's poor record at Stamford Bridge – one win in 11 and that came in April 2002 – and the prospect of Chelsea opening a five-point lead at the top – will make sure of that.
Titanic battles: Best of Chelsea v United
*15 Aug 2004 – Chelsea 1 Man Utd 0 Jose Mourinho's first game in charge ends in victory, courtesy of Eidur Gudjohnsen's 15th-minute goal.
*10 May 2005 – Man Utd 1 Chelsea 3 Ruud van Nistelrooy scores early, but Chelsea win with goals by Tiago, Gudjohnsen and Joe Cole.
*29 April 2006 – Chelsea 3 Man Utd 0 Chelsea clinch their second successive title thanks to goals from William Gallas, Ricardo Carvalho and Joe Cole. Mourinho throws his medal to fans.
*24 Sept 2007 – Man Utd 2 Chelsea 0 Avram Grant's first game in charge ends in defeat with goals from Carlos Tevez and Louis Saha.
*11 Jan 2009 – Man Utd 3 Chelsea 0 Nemanja Vidic, Wayne Rooney and Dimitar Berbatov settle this one-sided contest. Luiz Felipe Scolari is sacked a month later.......... Mark Fleming
View all comments that have been posted about this article.
Offensive or abusive comments will be removed and your IP logged and may be used to prevent further submission. In submitting a comment to the site, you agree to be bound by the Independent Minds Terms of Service.
- Print Article
- Email Article
-
Click here for copyright permissions
Copyright 2009 Independent News and Media Limited
Comments
Since, he has only bashed 2 other referees, which is not too bad by his standards, supposedly.
Finally they said November 3rd was the decision day, but hey, that would make a bad influence on the morale before the Chelsea game, so let's wait!
Pathetic FA, you are shamefully corrupt, and it is too transparent!
1) October 2009: Andre Marriner's decision to dismiss Nemanja Vidic against Liverpool rather than Jamie Carragher.
Fergie said: “The Vidic booking was the worst decision. It is a foul, fine. But the player has played on, he won the second ball and knocked it for a throw in and got booked. It put Nemanja under pressure.”
2) October 2009: Alan Wiley's decision not to add any more injury time at the end of Manchester United's draw with Sunderland.
Fergie said: "I was disappointed with the referee. He didn't add on any time for the goal. He played four minutes and two seconds. He was also walking up the pitch for the second goal needing a rest. He was not fit enough for a game of that standard. The pace of the game demanded a referee who was fit. He was not fit. It is an indictment of our game.
3) August 2009: Chris Foy's decision to allow play to continue after Michael Ballack had floored Patrice Evara in the Community Shield.
Fergie said: "The referee saw it, he clearly saw it. I’m disappointed because he has stopped the game twice before that. Once when Ballack went down he jumped up and was back on his feet again in seconds. That decision cost us the game. We’ve said it time and time again, all we want is consistency.”
4) November 2008: Mike Dean's decision not to send off Hull's Michael Turner during United's 4-3 win at Old Trafford.
Fergie said: "The player's already been booked so the referee's failed in his duty there. It should have been a red card as he was right through."
5) September 2008: Keith Hackett's decision to rescind a red card awarded to John Terry by Mark Halsey, clearing him to play in a crucial league game against Manchester United.
Fergie said: "My information is that Hackett told Mark Halsey to rescind the red card and he would not do it. Now I understand that Halsey is being made to referee in the Second Division this weekend. I just don't understand how this could have happened. If it had been a Manchester United player, Hackett would never have done this for us."
6) March 2008: Martin Atkinson's decision to award Portsmouth a penalty and send off Tomasz Kuszczak during the FA Cup tquarter-final at Old Trafford.
Fergie said: "Managers get sacked because of things like that and he's going to referee a game next week."
7) December 2007: Mark Clattenburg's decision not to protect Manchester United players enough during a 1-0 defeat at Bolton.
Fergie said: “I told [Clattenburg] exactly what I thought and he didn’t like it. I told him just how bad he was in the first half.”
8) November 2007: Howard Webb's decision to award Arsenal a 92nd minute equaliser after Edwin van der Sar thought he'd kept William Gallas' header out.
Fergie said: "It is very difficult for the referee ... at times, he favoured Arsenal. Their second goal came from him not giving a free-kick for a foul on Louis Saha on the far side. It should have been a foul for us!"
9) April 2007: Herbert Fandel's decision to send Paul Scholes off during United's 2-1 defeat to Roma in the Champions Legaue.
Fergie said: "I can't have any complaints about [Scholes's] first booking but I do have complaints about the second one. In a big game like that, a good referee would not have sent him off."
10) August 2003: Uriah Rennie's decision not to penalise Newcastle's Andy O'Brien after he brought down Ryan Giggs.
Fergie said: "!#@!" - or words to that effect to fourth official Jeff Winter, for which he was subsequently charged with misconduct
And of course he's the only manager for the last 50,000 years to do such things.
You and Guv111 from Stockport need help with the OCD you both have regarding SAF and all things United.
Is the simple logic understood?
There seems to be a very deeply rooted old grudge between Man U fans and Logic?