Pros and cons: four in the frame to coach England
Ian Botham
Age: 40
Playing career: England, Somerset, Worcestershire, Queensland, Durham. 102 Tests (12 as captain); 5,200 runs at 33.54; 383 wickets at 28.40.
For: Powers of inspiration and motivation. Charisma.
Against: Two-thirds of above are unproven - the England side he captained was not famous for team spirit. Inexperienced in management.
John Emburey
Age: 43
Current position: Northamptonshire player-coach.
Playing career: England, Middlesex. 64 Tests. 1,723 runs at 22.67; 147 wickets at 38.44.
For: Huge knowledge; forward thinking; respect from current players.
Against: Lack of meaningful management or coaching experience - just one England A tour.
David Lloyd
Age: 49
Current position: Lancs coach, England U-19 coach.
Playing career: England, Lancashire. Nine Tests; 552 runs at 42.46.
For: Enthusiasm, motivation.
Against: Will what works with the Under-19s translate into the full international arena? Why do his Lancashire side still under-achieve in the Championship?
Phil Neale
Age: 41
Current position: Warwickshire director of coaching.
Playing career: Worcestershire; no Tests.
For: Excellent management skills and track record, both as captain and manager-coach; knowledge; forward thinking.
Against: Lack of international experience.
Subscribe to Independent Premium to bookmark this article
Want to bookmark your favourite articles and stories to read or reference later? Start your Independent Premium subscription today.
Join our commenting forum
Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies