Man for man marking: England v Wales

 

Martin Pengelly
Monday 27 February 2012 01:00 GMT
Comments

England

Ben Foden: Solid and reasonably adventurous. No howlers, à la Rome. 6/10

Chris Ashton: Went looking for the ball more than recently and was almost dangerous. 6

Manu Tuilagi: Strong in the first half, faded in the second – knackered, no doubt. 6

Brad Barritt: Excellent tackling from chap raised on 300lb Afrikaaners. Natch. 6

David Strettle: Said he scored a possibly equalising try. Maybe. Very good in defence. 7

Owen Farrell: Whatever "it" is, he has it in spades. A very, very good start at No 10. 8

Lee Dickson: Very good. Quick and eager... though overly so occasionally, at the scrum. 7

Alex Corbisiero: Found Adam Jones to be a large and very hairy handful at the scrum. 6

Dylan Hartley: Solid and less penalisable than usual, which is half the battle. 6

Dan Cole: Good game – got a little change out of Gethin Jenkins at the scrum. 7

Mauritz Botha: One of those Afrikaaners Barritt was talking about. Strong. Also natch. 7

Geoff Parling: Decent first start, if occasionally betrayed by his own excitement. 7

Tom Croft: Lots of line-out ball, lots of leg work – though he couldn't stop the try. 7

Chris Robshaw: Good captain's knock, though couldn't match Sam Warburton. 6

Ben Morgan: On this evidence, will be a very good Test player indeed. In the future. 7

Key replacement: Courtney Lawes. Lost the ball for the try. Whoops. 5

Wales

Leigh Halfpenny: Pinged about like a red bowling ball being hit by white pins. Kicked well. 7

Alex Cuthbert: Did his thing well enough without doing much to commend or criticise. 6

Jonathan Davies: A hard centre with soft hands and a lovely rugby brain. Very influential. 7

Jamie Roberts: Struggled, surprisingly, against smaller men. Went off, crocked. 5

George North: A proper player. One big tackle, on Farrell, was a thing of brutal beauty. 8

Rhys Priestland: Not his best day. Charged down, sent to the sin-bin, generally hesitant. 5

Mike Phillips: Best moment was at the off, sending North through with a fine flip pass. 6

Gethin Jenkins: Had a tougher job against Cole than Jones did against Corbisiero. 6

Ken Owens: Line-out service was a little wobbly; pleasingly industrious elsewhere. 6

Adam Jones: Excellent on front foot and back, making one superb covering tackle. 8

Alun Wyn Jones: Herman Munster in a monstrous lock pairing. Tired later, after time off. 6

Ian Evans: Looks a bit like Lurch Addams, plays a lot like Grizzly. Ferocious effort. 7

Dan Lydiate: One of his quieter games, but still good in a rather Richard Hill-y way. 7

Sam Warburton: Magnificent, with his try-saver on Tuilagi the standout. Lions captain? 9

Toby Faletau: Had a lot to do and all of it hard. Now knows how to win while struggling. 7

Key replacement: Scott Williams. Try made up for missed try earlier. 7

Join our commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies

Comments

Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in