'Bloodgate' rugby physio wins appeal
Friday 21 January 2011
Former Harlequins physiotherapist Steph Brennan won a High Court battle today over the decision to strike him off for his part in the "Bloodgate" rugby controversy.
Lawyers for the top physio accused the Health Professions Council (HPC) of unlawfully imposing a "one strike and you are out for good" approach to his case.
They argued that his conduct had merited a sanction, but not one of such "gross severity".
Today Mr Justice Ouseley, sitting at London's High Court, quashed the decision against him and ordered the HPC's conduct and competence committee to reconsider the case.
Brennan had been due to start work with the RFU as an England physio until his role in the systematic use of fake blood capsules during matches was exposed.
He helped fabricate a blood injury to winger Tom Williams during Harlequins' Heineken Cup quarter-final defeat by Leinster at Twickenham Stoop in April 2009.
He admitted five instances of faking blood injuries, the first of which happened during Harlequins' 2005/06 season.
On three occasions this was for player welfare, while Brennan said the fourth was to get an unnamed player in a key position on to the pitch following the sin-binning of a team-mate.
Stephen Brassington, for the HPC, argued that the striking-off order was not open to legal challenge.
He rejected accusations that panel members had failed to give adequate reasons and explain in their decision how they had dealt with Brennan's expressions of sorrow and remorse.
Mr Brassington said: "His expressions of remorse and sorrow simply were too little too late."
Brennan's misconduct "was so egregious and damaging to the reputation of his profession that the only appropriate way to deal with it was striking-off".
Today Mr Justice Ouseley ruled that the reasoning of the HPC's disciplinary committee on its decision to strike off was "legally inadequate".
He said the same committee must now reconsider what sanction to impose in the light of his ruling.
The judge said Brennan's dishonesty had occurred in unusual circumstances.
Patients were not harmed and "what was done was done at the behest of a dishonest coach on behalf of their joint employer".
Although Brennan's actions deserved punishment, that was a matter for rugby's regulatory body, and it was "not the task of the committee when deciding on sanction".
Given that no patient was at risk, the committee's interest in Brennan's case was in deterring similar conduct, protecting the reputation of the profession, or ensuring confidence in the regulatory process, "or all three".
It was concerned with "the relationship between cheating in sport and lying about it" and Brennan's abuse of his position as a physiotherapist to enable cheating to take place.
"This relationship required careful attention if sanction was not to become a further punishment, and the committee did not address this issue in its expressed reasoning," said the judge.
Quashing the striking-off decision, he declared: "The reasoning is legally inadequate, failing to deal with the issues properly raised for its consideration by Mr Brennan."
Paul Harris, appearing for the physio, asked the judge to order a differently constituted panel to reconsider the question of sanction "to avoid the appearance of bias".
Mr Harris emphasised that Brennan was anxious to call fresh evidence to put an end to any lingering doubt "about the genuineness of his contrition and remorse" and it would appear fairer if it was head by a fresh panel.
Mr Harris stressed he was not saying there had been any actual bias.
But the judge said he could see no disadvantage "in terms of perceived unfairness" in referring the matter back to the same panel, while the advantage was that the panel members had already heard all the evidence.
He ordered the HPC to pay Brennan's legal costs of more than £12,000.
Phil Hughes dead: List of players who have tragically died on the cricket pitch
Nani transfer: No future for winger at Sporting Lisbon as club cannot afford his wages when loan deal with Manchester United runs out
This letter from a reader explains why women can’t play football
Mario Balotelli is playing badly at Liverpool because he misses his daughter, says agent
Tottenham Hotspur vs Partizan Belgrade match report: Spurs go through in Europa League - but pitch invaders grab the attention
- 2 This letter from a reader explains why women can’t play football
- 4 Scientists predict green energy revolution after incredible new graphene discoveries
Ukip says babies born to immigrants in the UK should be classed as migrants – which would include Nigel Farage’s own children
Obama: The only people with the right to object to immigration are Native Americans
The young are the new poor: Sharp increase in number of under-25s living in poverty, while over-65s are better off than ever
Tamir Rice: 12-year-old boy playing with fake gun dies after being shot by Ohio police
Rochester aftermath: Sacking of Emily Thornberry will make work of Labour MPs '10 times harder'
Ed Miliband's 'north London set' must be demolished to save Labour, say critics